第168案 | 危志立Case 168 | Wei Zhili
危志立,广州大学新闻系出身的劳工编辑,大学献血时读到一本尘肺宣传册,从此把命搭在工人身上:2010年毕业进深圳手牵手工友活动中心,2013年与杨郑君、柯成兵合办劳工媒体「新生代」,替为深圳打钻、肺先坏掉的湖南工人写报道、教法律、陪维权,账号封了就重开、文章删了就重发;2019年1月主编杨郑君先被抓,他明知危险仍不收手,3月20日凌晨两点在广州父母家被深圳警方抄家带走——警察当面对他母亲说,你儿子没买房、没孩子、没正经工作,被洗脑了,要带走再教育——其后五天杳无音讯,妻子郑楚然跑遍公安机关寻人,3月28日律师会见时他卷发已被剃光,4月19日又被转入本只适用于国安重罪的指定居所监视居住,与柯成兵的父亲被扣十小时逼签解聘书一道,三名编辑先后被宣布「自愿解聘」了家属律师;郑楚然写长文、跑一万公里、每日贴面具照片声援,自己的账号却接连被封;2019年7月联合国四专家发出紧急呼吁,2020年4月24日,在被关十三个月之后,他被判有期徒刑一年六个月、缓刑三年——作出判决的法院叫什么名字、判决书写了什么,至今无公开记录。Wei Zhili, a Guangzhou University journalism graduate turned labour editor, read a pamphlet about pneumoconiosis while donating blood at university and gave his life to workers from that day: the Hand-in-Hand Workers Centre in Shenzhen after graduating in 2010, then in 2013 co-founding the labour platform iLabour with Yang Zhengjun and Ke Chengbing, writing about, advising and standing with the Hunan migrant workers whose lungs had been ruined drilling Shenzhen's foundations — reposting every deleted article and reopening every closed account. When editor-in-chief Yang was seized in January 2019 he knew the danger and did not stop; at 2 a.m. on 20 March 2019 Shenzhen police took him from his parents' home in Guangzhou, telling his mother to her face that her son had no house, no children and no proper job, had been brainwashed, and was being taken away for re-education. Five days of silence followed while his wife Zheng Churan — herself one of the 2015 Feminist Five — searched bureau after bureau; by his lawyer's meeting on 28 March his curly hair had been shaved off; on 19 April he was moved into residential surveillance at a designated location, a secret-detention tool the law reserves for state-security cases; and, in the same weeks that Ke Chengbing's father was held ten hours without food to sign away his son's lawyer, all three editors were announced to have 'voluntarily dismissed' the lawyers their families had hired. Zheng wrote their story, ran for him, posted a mask photograph every day, and had her own accounts shut one by one. Four UN experts appealed in July 2019. On 24 April 2020, after thirteen months in custody, he was sentenced to one year and six months' imprisonment, suspended for three years — and the name of the court that sentenced him, and anything his judgment says, has no public record to this day.
1. First, pin down four corrections: who the co-defendants were, the sentence, the year, and a court no source will name
Four things in this file are most often got wrong — and this check found wrong versions in circulation — so they are fixed here at the top. First, the co-defendants. Wei Zhili's co-defendants were iLabour's editor-in-chief Yang Zhengjun and its co-founder Ke Chengbing; supporters abroad called the three the 'iLabour Three' or the 'New Generation editors'. Any version naming someone else in the trio — the name 'Ding Yan', for instance — finds not one word of support in Amnesty International, the UN documents, the Committee to Protect Journalists, Human Rights Watch, Front Line Defenders or Zheng Churan's own long account, all of which name the same three men every time: Yang Zhengjun, Ke Chengbing, Wei Zhili. Whether a Ding Yan has some other case somewhere is not this page's business; she does not belong in this one.
Second, the sentence. This check encountered a version claiming 'sentenced to three years in 2021'. It does not match any verifiable source. The hardest record available comes from the case file of the ILO Committee on Freedom of Association: Yang Zhengjun, Wei Zhili and Ke Chengbing were tried on 24 April 2020 on suspicion of provocative offences and sentenced to one year and six months' imprisonment with a three-year probation term. Sentenced the same day, in the same batch, were the five Shenzhen Chunfeng labour-centre defendants (Zhang Zhiru and others, on 'gathering a crowd to disrupt social order', with various probation terms) and four Jasic workers — 24 April 2020 was the day Shenzhen wound up the whole 2018–19 labour crackdown in one sitting. Third, the year follows from the sentence: trial and sentencing were in 2020, not 2021; and a 'release in March 2022' after three years in prison does not fit a suspended sentence at all — a man on probation is not in prison serving out three years. See Sections 15 and 16. Fourth, the court. This check searched the ILO file, the UN documents, the CECC material and every rights-organisation record, and not one of them names the court that sentenced him; the Chinese government never transmitted copies of the judgments to the ILO, whose file records that failure with 'deep regret'. This page therefore writes only: tried and sentenced on 24 April 2020; the court's name and the text of the judgment have no public record. Anyone who supplies a district court's name is guessing.
2. A child of the port: books, workers, and a pamphlet about ruined lungs
Almost everything known about Wei Zhili's formation comes from one document: the long essay his wife Zheng Churan wrote within days of his seizure in March 2019, 'Separated Again by a High Wall', published by Hong Kong Free Press — the single most important first-hand source in this case, and the basis, labelled as such, for everything this page says about his early life. Per her account: he grew up by a port. His grandfather had been a port worker before 1949, later a stevedore decorated as a 'model worker'; his mother spent thirty years in port administration; his father had been a worker, a taxi driver and a nurse in a psychiatric hospital. The family was not rich, but his parents never stinted on books: at middle school he stumbled on Das Kapital, liked it, was bought the simplified edition by his mother, finished it, then went to the school library and read the brick-thick full text cover to cover. As a boy by the docks he watched old workers wreck their backs until they lay expressionless with pain, and watched the same men treat each other like brothers — Zheng writes that the condition of workers took root in his heart there.
The moment that decided his life came at university. Per Zheng's account, he was about twenty, a regular blood donor, and while queuing at the campus blood station he picked up an occupational-health pamphlet left by the noticeboard; that issue was about pneumoconiosis — lungs blackened like honeycombs, an old man holding a crying child. He told her he felt for a few seconds as if he himself had the disease and could not breathe. He was reading journalism at Guangzhou University but skipped countless classes — his roommate recalled that everyone else skipped class to play games in the dormitory, while Zhili skipped class to go and sit in on lectures at Sun Yat-sen University, where he fell in with sociology teachers and students. In his final year he joined the research team of the sociologist Pun Ngai, travelling to several provinces to study the living conditions of workers with pneumoconiosis. He came back with his career decided: he would help workers. He never looked back. This section is filed as Zheng Churan's account — a wife writing about her husband, through a filter of love — but its checkable skeleton of school, degree, the Pun Ngai team and the 2010 graduation coheres with Amnesty International's profile line that he had worked on labour and feminist issues since graduating in 2010.
3. Hand-in-Hand and iLabour: what a labour editor's working day looked like
Per Zheng's account and Amnesty's profile, straight after graduating Wei went to work at the Hand-in-Hand Workers Centre in Shenzhen, giving workers legal advice, representation and organising support. When Hand-in-Hand was forced to shut, he moved into work matching his degree: editing a labour medium. Front Line Defenders and the UN appeal agree on the founding facts: in 2013 Wei Zhili, Yang Zhengjun and Ke Chengbing co-founded and co-edited the independent online platform iLabour — Xinshengdai, 'New Generation', later also styled Weigonghui — stating its mission as to 'promote economic democracy, safeguard labour values, and build a just society'. Beyond reporting labour news, the platform ran a consultation channel for workers whose rights had been violated, teaching them the law and helping them file complaints.
His editorial daily life is best documented by Zheng. He liked to illustrate workers' lives with stills from Hong Kong films. The iLabour circle analysed labour relations through a Marxist frame and all took pen names surnamed 'Ma', for Marx; his favourite pen name was 'Ma Xiaoling', borrowed from the heroine of the Hong Kong television drama My Date with a Vampire — Zheng is at pains to say he was no slogan-shouting flag-waver but a writer workers actually liked to read. His 'Women's Weekly' column dealt with women workers: menstrual leave, sexual harassment at work, maternity leave, domestic violence, the burdens of the home. That a labour editor also wrote feminist copy surprised no one in that household: he was the labour activist, she the feminist, and each had dragged the other onto their own battlefield. He went out to meet workers constantly; workers writing about him online always said his clothes were too shabby and that they wanted to club together to buy him new ones; older women workers pressed fruit and snacks on him to take home to his family. This section is written in detail deliberately: when the charge sheet arrives in later sections, the reader should hold in mind what the 'conduct' in this case actually consisted of — writing articles, running a consultation channel, helping workers file complaints, and showing up where they protested.
4. A history of dead accounts: from 2014, the platform's accounts did not live long
The tug-of-war between iLabour and the censors has a ready-made chronology in the UN experts' urgent appeal of 19 July 2019, which this page reproduces with its source labelled. In November 2014 iLabour's WeChat account was shut down by WeChat at the government's behest — the first of several such closures; the account was reopened and shut repeatedly afterwards. In April 2016, after the platform's WeChat shared articles about a coal miners' protest in Heilongjiang, Ke Chengbing was interrogated by police. In January 2017, after the platform published an article on a workers' strike in Guangzhou, the WeChat account was closed again. In November 2018 a newly opened WeChat account for the platform was shut down after it posted information about police using pepper gas to suppress a protest of Hunanese workers in Shenzhen. Alongside the closures ran the deletions: Zheng records that he reposted the workers' rights articles again and again as they were deleted, treating every word, in her phrase, as if it had been squeezed from the workers' blood.
This section stands alone because it supplies a key to the arrests of 2019. The authorities' first toolkit against iLabour was the platform toolkit — dead accounts, deleted posts, an editor called in for questioning — used patiently for more than four years. By the end of 2018 the Hunan pneumoconiosis line was no longer something 'coverage' could settle: the workers were protesting in person and the editors were standing with them in person. The last tool left in the box was arrest.
5. The pneumoconiosis workers: the men who drilled Shenzhen's foundations, whose lungs went first
The centre of the three editors' work in their last free years was the Hunan pneumoconiosis workers. The outline is consistent across sources. Most of these men came from a single village in Hunan and had come to Shenzhen in their prime to work as drillers on construction sites; Shenzhen's ground is lightly weathered granite, hard rock, and drilling it raises a fine dust that settles in the lungs. Protective equipment was wretched — Zheng writes that some men washed their mask at the end of the day and wore the same mask underground the next morning. Their lungs were destroyed grain by grain: first treated as tuberculosis cases, they were later diagnosed with the 'unknown' disease. Pneumoconiosis is irreversible; the men cough up black phlegm, every breath hurts in the chest, and they can only wait — watching their own parents and children. They built Shenzhen's towers, and then stood among those towers asking for compensation, blocked by two gates: some doctors refused to issue diagnosis certificates, and employers refused to confirm the employment relationship. Without a diagnosis and without an employment relationship there is no work-injury certification, and without that, no money.
What the iLabour three did, in Human Rights Watch's summary, was three things: raise public awareness of the silicosis victims' plight, give them advice on the relevant laws, and join their protests. Zheng preserves one detail this page keeps on file: Wei seldom cried, but he cried telling her about one worker's family — the man had died of pneumoconiosis, in such pain at the end that he stopped breathing; his elder and younger brothers had died of the same disease; what remained was a mother in her eighties and the youngest son, also sick with pneumoconiosis and weakening by the day. He had not cried at his grandfather's funeral, not when his wife was detained in 2015, not when he broke his arm playing basketball — only there. In November 2018 Hunan workers came to Shenzhen to press their case and were treated violently by police and dispersed with pepper gas (the UN file says pepper gas; Zheng and other reports say pepper spray — both wordings kept on file); family members and even pregnant women were pushed and shoved. He knew the risk — labour activists were being taken one by one — and, per Zheng, he told her: 'I have to help them no matter what.'
6. The setting: after Jasic, the net closed over Shenzhen's whole labour world
Wei Zhili's case is not an isolated one; it is one cell in a sweep that began in the summer of 2018. Lay the line out. In July 2018 workers at Jasic Technology in Shenzhen tried to form a union through legal channels; dozens were seized, and the students and activists who supported them were taken, disappeared or filmed making confessions in the months that followed — Human Rights Watch's April 2019 article put the workers and student activists still held in connection with Jasic at more than forty. On 20 January 2019 Shenzhen police seized five more labour NGO figures: Zhang Zhiru, director of the Shenzhen Chunfeng Labour Dispute Service Centre, its former staff members Jian Hui and Song Jiahui, and the labour activists Wu Guijun and He Yuancheng; all five were later formally arrested on suspicion of 'gathering a crowd to disrupt social order' and held at Bao'an District Detention Centre — none of them directly involved in Jasic. China Labour Bulletin's spokesman told the press at the time that the authorities were making a concerted effort against civil-society actors who supported legitimate worker protests. This page sets that cell in place to make the sequence of the iLabour arrests legible: first Jasic's workers and students, then the veteran NGO directors, and last the editors of a media platform. Each step stood one pace further from the picket line than the last — by the time they came for the editors, the people being arrested were not strikers but the people who wrote about strikes.
7. 8 January 2019: the editor-in-chief was taken first
The first of the three to fall was the editor-in-chief, Yang Zhengjun. Per the information set out in the UN urgent appeal: on 7 January 2019 a group of the Hunan migrant workers he had been defending came to Shenzhen to demand a response from the local government to their occupational-disease complaint — Front Line Defenders' version puts the group at about fifty and records that police intercepted them and forcibly sent them back. The next day, 8 January, officers from the Shenzhen Public Security Bureau and a Guangzhou residential-district branch came to Yang's home in Guangzhou and took him and three other people in the house: no arrest warrant was shown, no reason given, the room was searched, computers, phones and other devices seized; of roughly ten officers, only one showed his identification, and only when asked. The three taken with him were released within twenty-four hours, reportedly questioned about their relationship with Yang and his advocacy for the workers who had come to Shenzhen. Yang was held at Shenzhen No. 2 Detention Centre until 6 February, when he was placed under residential surveillance at a designated location — the charge being 'picking quarrels and provoking trouble' under Article 293 of the Criminal Law, an offence in the 'disrupting public order' category, while RSDL under Article 75 of the Criminal Procedure Law is supposed to apply only to suspects in cases of endangering national security, terrorism or especially serious bribery. His family and lawyers were not officially notified of the change; from that day, where he was held, nobody knew.
After the editor-in-chief vanished, the two who remained did not stop. Ke Chengbing and Wei Zhili went on reporting and went on standing with the Hunan workers — a fact recorded by both Zheng's essay and Front Line Defenders. She writes that several times she opened her mouth to tell her husband to give it up and stop publishing, and could not say the words, because the workers' misery was too great; and that he was afraid too, and that they fell back on the words they had always used to brace each other: 'My feet are trembling with fear, but how can I not do it?' Those weeks between January and March 2019 are the heaviest passage in this file: they knew exactly that Yang's today was their tomorrow, and they published anyway.
8. 20 March 2019, about 2 a.m.: the seizure at his parents' home
At about 2 a.m. on 20 March 2019 Wei Zhili was taken from his parents' home in Baiyun District, Guangzhou. Per the UN appeal: the officers were from the Pingshan District Sub-Bureau of the Shenzhen Public Security Bureau; no arrest warrant was presented; the police told his parents he was being taken away for 'education', because he had been 'brainwashed', and said that through his activism he had 'disrupted public security' and 'opposed the Communist Party'; his computer and mobile phone were confiscated. Amnesty International's first urgent action adds scene detail: the officers searched his room and questioned him for about an hour before taking him, told his father the ground was 'disturbing social order', and said he would be criminally detained and a formal notice sent to the family in a few days. The CPJ's version carries one discrepancy: per Zheng Churan's Facebook account, the officers were from the Longhua branch of the Shenzhen Public Security Bureau — the Pingshan and Longhua attributions are both kept on file, this page taking Pingshan as the main line because the UN appeal and Amnesty's actions (addressed to Pingshan director Song Yiyang) converge on it, with the Longhua version labelled to its source, not deleted. And there is one sentence the police said to his mother's face, which Zheng recorded word for word: your son graduated from a good university, but he has not bought a house, does not have children, does not have a proper job — we need to take him away and re-educate him. The same day, Ke Chengbing was taken from his home in Huangpu village, Haizhu District, Guangzhou, by Pingshan officers, likewise shown no warrant, and driven to Shenzhen No. 2 Detention Centre; his family received formal notice of his detention only on 3 April — a full two weeks later, where Article 83 of the Criminal Procedure Law requires notification within twenty-four hours.
The vocabulary of the seizure deserves to be fixed on its own. To the parents, it was 'education' and 'brainwashing'; on the legal paper, it was 'picking quarrels and provoking trouble'. What the police said in the living room — no house, no children, no proper job — is not legal language; it is another kind of judgment: first declare the man's life substandard, then explain helping workers as a symptom of a washed brain. Zheng answered that line in her essay: the three arrested men might look to mainstream society like men without proper jobs, but to the workers they were the kindest of people; in a society where not buying a house and not having children are treated almost as crimes, helping others had somehow become the offence of picking quarrels.
9. Five days missing, and the phone call of 26 March: how Zheng Churan searched
After he was taken, for five full days, neither his parents nor his wife received any news and no official notification of any kind. Zheng's essay turns those five days into an itemised account, and this page keeps its skeleton: she visited three public security bureaus and two local police stations, crying the whole time; she petitioned; she called 12389, the police supervision hotline; she called 110 to report her husband missing; she called 12345, the municipal services hotline, to complain; her Weibo post was forwarded more than six thousand times. She comforted his parents and her own; she coughed blood, could not sleep, was hungry with no appetite, had diarrhoea, and woke after ten minutes' sleep to check her phone for news. In her words: when the person you love has disappeared and the people in power refuse to tell you where he is, how is that different from tearing the middle out of a love story?
On 26 March, as she was setting out to ask at every detention centre in Shenzhen one by one, the police telephoned: Wei Zhili was detained by Shenzhen Pingshan public security at the No. 2 Detention Centre for 'picking quarrels and provoking trouble'; the police said the detention notice had been sent and they had no idea why she had not received it. She wrote that she had never been so happy to receive a detention-notice call — at least it meant he was formally held, not simply disappeared and abused. She hired a lawyer at once; the lawyer applied for a meeting and was told that this was a sensitive case and a meeting could take place only forty-eight hours after the appointment. On 28 March the lawyer, Fan Biaowen, finally saw him — in the lawyer's own words they were 'lucky', having almost failed: the bureau running the case had many ways to block meetings, such as scheduling an interrogation at the meeting time or simply refusing appointments. The news the meeting brought back: his trademark curly hair had been shaved off, he was in the grey detention uniform, his condition was fair; he confirmed that the three iLabour editors — Yang Zhengjun, Wei Zhili and Ke Chengbing — were all detained in the same centre for helping the pneumoconiosis workers. He told the lawyer he had not been tortured to extract a confession, but that the police kept scolding him, saying he was unfilial to his parents and had been manipulated by the workers. One further item comes from Hong Kong Free Press, relaying lawyer Fan: that police had forced Wei back to search his Guangzhou home and claimed to have found several mobile phones he had stolen — an accusation Zheng called a lie and 'a stupid excuse to humiliate Wei'. That item is single-sourced through the lawyer's relay and is filed at that grade.
10. RSDL: a public-order case held with a national-security tool
On 19 April 2019 Wei Zhili and Ke Chengbing were placed under residential surveillance at a designated location (Amnesty International's urgent action of 25 April records that police informed Wei's parents he had been under RSDL since 19 April; Amnesty's own headline dating says transferred on 20 April — the one-day difference is kept on file). From that day, where they were held, nobody knew; lawyers could not meet them; families could not contact them. The legal problem was stated without varnish by the four UN experts in their urgent appeal of 19 July 2019: under the Criminal Procedure Law, RSDL is meant to apply only to suspects in cases of endangering national security, terrorism or especially serious bribery, while the three men's charge, picking quarrels, is an ordinary offence in the Criminal Law's 'disrupting public order' category. To use a secret-detention tool designed for state-security cases in a picking-quarrels case produces exactly what the experts called it in their letter — enforced disappearance. Front Line Defenders later added the procedural detail that the three were moved into RSDL after the initial thirty-seven-day period of criminal detention expired: thirty-seven days is the statutory maximum for criminal detention, and when the deadline arrived and release was not intended, the label was changed and the men were moved to a place with no address.
Zheng Churan's fear of RSDL is on the record in HKFP's reporting, in her own words as relayed there: under RSDL people can disappear off the streets for up to six months, held in solitary confinement in custom-built prisons operating outside the judicial system; 'We don't know if he is safe. We've heard about a lot of people who were tortured while in RSDL.' Her fear was not rhetorical decoration — in the same period, the treatment of detainees in RSDL in the Jasic and other labour cases was already the subject of extensive public allegations. As for Wei Zhili's own treatment inside RSDL, this page holds only the sentence he gave his lawyer before the transfer: he had not been tortured to extract a confession, but he had been verbally abused. What happened in the months after the transfer has no public record, and this page neither guesses nor fills it in.
11. The 'dismissed' lawyers: how this case dismantled a defence, step by dated step
The part of this case most worth nailing down day by day is the destruction of the defence, because every step of it carries a document date. On 22 April 2019 the three men's families sent a joint letter to the People's Procuratorate of Pingshan District, Shenzhen, explaining that the men's actions did not constitute picking quarrels, calling for their release, and expressing their fears for the men's wellbeing and their possible exposure to torture in detention. The next day, 23 April, national security officers came to Ke Chengbing's father's workplace and held the old man for ten hours without food until he signed an agreement dismissing his son's lawyer. On 23 and 24 April Ke's lawyer filed complaints with the Pingshan Procuratorate over the denial of visits and the detention of Ke's father; the Procuratorate replied that, according to information provided by the Pingshan Public Security Sub-Bureau, Ke's family members had dismissed the lawyer — and did not address the complaints about the sub-bureau's illegal actions at all. On 25 April Yang Zhengjun's lawyer filed a bail application at the Pingshan sub-bureau; the next day he requested a visit and was told the police there did not hold Yang's case files and he should go to the municipal bureau; there he was informed that the 'special working group' running the case could not be contacted directly, that he would not be given the name of the official in charge, and that his request should be submitted through a petitioning office. On 14 May one of the two lawyers hired by Wei's family requested a visit through the Pingshan sub-bureau and was refused: the authorities claimed Wei had stated in writing that he had dismissed his other lawyer and would recognise no one else as his defence. On 20 May Yang's lawyer filed another bail application and visit request and was told Yang had declared in writing back in February that he would accept only lawyers entrusted by himself; when the lawyer asked to see the statement, he was told he would need to make an appointment in advance.
By August 2019 the police formally informed all three families: the three men had been formally arrested and were back in Shenzhen No. 2 Detention Centre — and all three had 'dismissed' their family-appointed lawyers and had now 'voluntarily hired' new lawyers. Lay the timeline end to end and the manufacture of that word 'voluntarily' is plain: first hold the men incommunicado in RSDL; then detain one father for ten hours to extract a signature; then block every visit with a written statement no family member is ever allowed to see; then announce that the dismissals are complete. This page's filing is exact: every claim that the men dismissed their lawyers comes from the investigating authorities alone; not one of the alleged statements has ever been produced to a family or to the public; and the UN experts and Front Line Defenders both list the episode among the case's core procedural allegations. A man held in secret for months 'voluntarily' sacks the lawyer his family hired — the reader will judge the credit of that sentence.
12. Zheng Churan's campaign: the essay, the postcard, the 10,000 kilometres and the daily masks
Through the years her husband was held, Zheng Churan fought a public campaign — and she was herself one of the 2015 'Feminist Five': on the eve of International Women's Day 2015 she and Wei Tingting, Wang Man, Wu Rongrong and Li Tingting were seized in Beijing for planning to distribute stickers against sexual harassment on public transport; the five were held thirty-seven days and released on bail amid an international outcry. She knew better than almost anyone what 'being forgotten' means. The sentence she gave HKFP states the campaign's whole thesis: 'I wanted to let people know that he's a very responsible guy who cares about workers and their rights. I don't want people to forget about him.'
Her methods are each on the public record. First, the essay: within days of the seizure she wrote the story of their six years together — beginning with the night in the industrial park when he bent down and picked up the cigarette end she had carelessly thrown away, because the sanitation workers were exhausted every day — writing it in the knowledge it would be censored, and saying she would make her utmost effort to let the world know Wei Zhili's story. Second, the postcard: Human Rights Watch's article of 1 April 2019 opens with the postcard she wrote to her husband — 'The whole world is waiting for you to come back', and the line from the Hong Kong band Beyond's 'Glorious Days', 'hold fast to freedom in the wind and rain', a song long since an anthem of protest in the region. Third, the run: she launched a campaign to run 10,000 kilometres calling for his release, posting daily updates of her progress on Twitter. Fourth, the masks: she vowed to tweet every day an image of supporters wearing masks of the three detainees' faces until their release — a form of activism she said helped offset the pain of separation. Fifth, the account her own body and life paid, as HKFP recorded: in the months after his detention she lost all appetite and contracted chronic laryngitis, crying as she thought about his health — he has a bad stomach, and she hoped he was not sick. She had coughed blood in the first five days; see Section 9.
The price of campaigning also fell on her item by item, and it is documented. A WeChat account she had used for more than five years was abruptly taken offline; a new one, registered seconds later, was blocked from posting publicly or sending group messages. The Weibo account she used to publicise her husband's stories was banned. Seven thousand five hundred yuan in her WeChat Wallet was seized by the platform operator and refunded only after she complained and publicised the incident on her public account — which was itself subsequently deleted. Amnesty International's urgent action records the general fact in one line: Zheng Churan faced continued harassment merely for speaking out publicly about her husband's detention. Her own metaphor for it: they took him away and forbade her to cry out; they cut out her vocal cords and forbade her to shed tears for him in public. This page files this section beside the last one deliberately, because they are two exits of the same machine: for the man inside, cut off the lawyer; for the wife outside, cut off the accounts.
13. The workers answer back, and Hong Kong protests: the interception at the departure station
The support did not come only from his wife. When the Hunan pneumoconiosis workers the three had helped learned of the arrests, they cried — that is Zheng's own word in her essay — and set out at once for Shenzhen to demand an explanation; the police intercepted them and they never arrived. Human Rights Watch's version supplies the number and the place: more than a hundred silicosis-stricken workers from Hunan decided to go to Shenzhen to show support, and police stopped them at their departure train station. HKFP separately records that about a hundred workers afflicted with pneumoconiosis signed a petition for the release of Wei and the other two detained editors. A group of men whose lungs were ruined, for whom breathing itself hurts, tried to board a train to speak for the man who had written for them, and were turned back on the platform — of all the solidarity records in this case, this page judges that one the heaviest.
Outside the wall there was Hong Kong. In March 2019 the League of Social Democrats protested outside the Central Government Liaison Office, demanding the immediate release of Yang Zhengjun, Wei Zhili and Ke Chengbing and an end to the crackdown on online media. Messages of solidarity, HKFP recorded, arrived from the United States, France and elsewhere. This page states the limit of this section honestly: none of it changed the three men's position by a single day — they were moved into RSDL anyway, 'dismissed' their lawyers anyway, and waited a year for a trial their families could not be shown attending. The meaning of the solidarity is not in instant effect; it is in the record itself. Without Zheng's essay, the workers' petition and the organisations' day-by-day files, Wei Zhili's name — together with his sentence of eighteen months suspended for three years — would have left no public trace at all. As it is, his judgment itself still has left none; see Section 15.
14. The international response, in full: from press-freedom groups to four UN experts
The international response is nailed down in date order. On 21 March 2019 the Committee to Protect Journalists demanded Wei's immediate release, noting that Ke Chengbing had gone missing the same day and was believed in police custody and that Yang Zhengjun had by then been held two months. On 27 March Amnesty International issued its first urgent action (UA 37/19), calling for letters to Pingshan director Song Yiyang. On 28 March Reporters Without Borders called for the release of the three journalists investigating workers' conditions. On 1 April Human Rights Watch published 'China's Labor Activists "Hold Fast to Freedom"', setting the three men's case inside the nationwide crackdown that followed Jasic. On 25 April Amnesty's second urgent action recorded Wei's transfer into secret detention. On 19 July four UN mandate-holders — the Working Group on Arbitrary Detention, the Working Group on Enforced or Involuntary Disappearances, the Special Rapporteur on freedom of opinion and expression and the Special Rapporteur on human rights defenders — sent a joint urgent appeal (UA CHN 14/2019) to the Chinese government expressing serious concern at the three men's arbitrary detention, enforced disappearance and charging, and interrogating in detail the use of RSDL and the obstruction of lawyer visits. On 25 July the Network of Chinese Human Rights Defenders issued a statement demanding the release of detained labour-rights advocates, with a dedicated section on the iLabour three. On 26 July Amnesty's third urgent action listed Wei and Ke as labour activists held in secret detention. On 8 August the CPJ wrote to the Shenzhen authorities demanding the three editors' release and the end of all legal proceedings against them. Of any public Chinese official reply to this entire sequence, this check found none: Shenzhen and Guangzhou police 'did not immediately respond' to AFP and CPJ inquiries at the time of the seizures, and no later public answer is on record — filed as no public record.
15. The long wait: epidemic, black hole, and the trial of 24 April 2020
After the formal arrests of August 2019 the case entered a soundless phase: no trial announcement, no published indictment, no word of family attendance. On 26 February 2020 Pun Ngai published an article in Hong Kong speaking for the three editors — she wrote that since the second half of 2018 labour advocates had been arrested in succession, some held eight or nine months before release, but the fate of the New Generation's three editors remained unknown; that the public security authorities had committed outrageous violations of privacy from the start of the investigation; that the law gives arrestees the right to choose their own attorneys, yet the authorities had repeatedly demanded the men dismiss their family-hired lawyers and use appointed ones; and that although the families had been notified the case was about to go to trial, it had been put on hold because of the epidemic, the three men still detained without justification, what went on inside the detention centre unknown, 'as if in a black hole'. Pun Ngai was the scholar whose research team Wei had joined as a student; the article is that teacher-student bond answering, seven years on. On 20 March 2020, the first anniversary of the seizure, Front Line Defenders marked it: Ke Chengbing and Wei Zhili had been detained a full year, Yang Zhengjun in incommunicado detention for over fourteen months, all three still held at Shenzhen Municipal No. 2 Detention Centre, on a charge carrying up to ten years.
Then came 24 April 2020. The case file of the ILO Committee on Freedom of Association records that Yang Zhengjun, Wei Zhili and Ke Chengbing were tried that day on suspicion of provocative offences and sentenced to one year and six months' imprisonment with a three-year probation term. The same day, the five Chunfeng defendants — Zhang Zhiru, Jian Hui, Song Jiahui, Wu Guijun and He Yuancheng — were likewise sentenced to various probation terms for 'gathering a crowd to disrupt social order': the whole batch of 2018–19 labour cases closed on a single day, in a single manner — conviction, probation, release, no published judgments. Of the trial itself, this page can fix only that one institutional line: whether the hearing was public, whether the families were notified or present, whether the three pleaded guilty, who if anyone defended them in court — all of it has no public record. The ILO repeatedly urged the Chinese government to transmit copies of all the relevant judicial decisions, these three men's included, 'without further delay', and its file states, with deep regret, that the government did not provide them. The date of indictment and the indicting authority were likewise not found in any public source in this check; they are filed as no public record and are not filled in by inference from usual practice.
16. Release: the page with no date on it
A suspended sentence means the prison term need not be served: the three had by then been held continuously for between thirteen and fifteen and a half months (Wei, counted from 20 March 2019 to 24 April 2020, for thirteen months and four days), and on the ordinary operation of such a sentence they should have gone home at sentencing, into three years of community correction under probation. But the exact date of release, the place, whether anyone was there to meet him, what he said when he got home — this check found none of it in any source, and all of it is filed as no public record. The nearest institutional point this page can fix for 'a free man' is the report of the UN Working Group on Enforced or Involuntary Disappearances on its 124th session in May 2021: on information provided by sources, the Working Group clarified the cases of Ke Chengbing, Wei Zhili and Yang Zhengjun, who were 'reportedly at liberty'. A 'clarification' in that body's procedure means the disappearance is over and the person's whereabouts are accounted for — the only formal landing-point, in any international document, for the three men's return to freedom: some time before May 2021, manner unknown.
This section must also deal head-on with the circulating wrong version: 'sentenced to three years in 2021, released in March 2022'. This check's conclusion is that it conflicts outright with the ILO's record of the 24 April 2020 sentence of eighteen months suspended for three years, and finds no support in any UN, CECC or Amnesty source. The March 2022 date is, suggestively, the month in which the ILO Committee on Freedom of Association examined this case and its report was approved at the Governing Body's March 2022 session — the wrong version most plausibly grew out of misreading an institution's document date as an event date. This page follows the ILO record; the wrong version is registered here, corrected, and kept out of the timeline.
17. After the probation years: where the public record stops
Counted from the sentence, the three-year probation period would have run out around April 2023 (24 April 2020 plus three years; the exact starting point of a probation term is fixed by the judgment, and the judgment has no public record, so this date is this page's arithmetic, not a source's confirmation). During probation, Chinese law subjects the person to community correction: periodic reporting, approval required to leave the place of residence, no new offences — that is the statutory content of probation, stated here as institutional background only; this page does not claim knowledge of how he personally was supervised, and whether he was monitored after the term, or restricted in travel or work, has no public record. Since his release he has appeared in no public reporting at all: no new articles, no interviews, no news of any fresh seizure, no record of a return to editing. Of Zheng Churan's public activity after 2020, this check likewise found nothing new about her husband's situation. A couple who once laid their life out in the open, in writing, thereafter fall silent in the public record together — and this page does not guess at the reason: it may be the price of probation, it may be exhaustion, it may simply be a wish to live quietly. The archive's rule is to record silence as silence.
18. Filed side by side: divergences between sources, and unverified items
One: the co-defendants — every source names the same three men, Yang Zhengjun, Ke Chengbing and Wei Zhili; the 'Ding Yan as co-defendant' version has no source support at all — see Section 1. Two: the sentence and year — the ILO file records trial on 24 April 2020 and one year and six months with three years' probation; the 'three years in 2021' version has no source support — see Sections 1 and 16. Three: the investigating unit — the UN appeal and Amnesty's actions name the Pingshan District Sub-Bureau of the Shenzhen Public Security Bureau; the CPJ, relaying Zheng Churan's Facebook account, names the Longhua branch; both kept. Four: the RSDL date — the UN file gives the transfer as 19 April 2019; Amnesty's action is headlined 20 April while its text says police told the parents the measure ran from 19 April; one day apart, both kept. Five: the place of seizure in detail — the UN file gives his parents' home in Baiyun District, Guangzhou; the model letter in Amnesty's first urgent action says his home 'in Shenzhen', at about 2 a.m. after an hour's search — the Baiyun parents' home is the consensus line across sources, and Amnesty's 'Shenzhen' wording looks like a template error; registered for the record. Six: his graduation year — Amnesty's documents mostly give 2010; one Amnesty USA web page gives 2001, which, against his reported age of thirty in 2019 and Zheng's account of him at university at about twenty, is plainly a misprint; this page takes 2010. Seven: the typesetting of Yang Zhengjun's name — the header of the Front Line Defenders file at one point sets the three characters of Yang Zhengjun's name in a separated, disordered form, while its text and all other sources give Yang Zhengjun; this page follows Yang Zhengjun. Eight: the number of Hunan workers who came to Shenzhen in January 2019 — Front Line Defenders says about fifty; the UN file says only 'a group'; both kept. Nine: what was used to disperse the workers in November 2018 — the UN file says pepper gas; Zheng's account and other reporting say pepper spray; both wordings kept. Ten: Wei Zhili's exact birth date, the couple's marriage registration date, the indictment date and authority, the sentencing court's name, the full text of the judgment, the exact release date, any confirmation that probation was completed, and his work and life since release have no public record, and this page fills in none of them.
19. Full timeline
Born about 1988–89 (the only fix being 'aged 30' in 2019; exact date no public record). At middle school he reads the simplified Das Kapital, then the full text. At about twenty, donating blood at university, he reads the pneumoconiosis pamphlet and resolves to help workers. Studying journalism at Guangzhou University, he sits in on lectures at Sun Yat-sen University and in his final year joins Pun Ngai's pneumoconiosis research team. 2010: graduates and goes to work at the Hand-in-Hand Workers Centre in Shenzhen. 2013: co-founds and co-edits iLabour (Xinshengdai) with Yang Zhengjun and Ke Chengbing; the same year he meets Zheng Churan. The Hand-in-Hand centre is later forced to close; he edits labour media full-time, usually under the pen name Ma Xiaoling. November 2014: iLabour's WeChat account is shut for the first time. 2015: Zheng Churan is held thirty-seven days as one of the Feminist Five; he waits outside. April 2016: Ke Chengbing is interrogated after the platform shares articles on the Heilongjiang miners' protest. January 2017: the WeChat account is closed again over a Guangzhou strike report. From July 2018: the Jasic case triggers a nationwide crackdown on labour activism. November 2018: Hunan pneumoconiosis workers protesting in Shenzhen are dispersed with pepper gas; iLabour reports it and its new WeChat account is closed again; Wei, knowing the risk, insists on helping the workers regardless. 7 January 2019: about fifty Hunan workers come to Shenzhen again and are intercepted and sent back. 8 January 2019: Yang Zhengjun is seized in Guangzhou; on 6 February he is moved into RSDL. 20 January 2019: Zhang Zhiru and four other labour NGO figures are seized. About 2 a.m., 20 March 2019: Wei Zhili is taken from his parents' home in Baiyun District, Guangzhou, by Shenzhen Pingshan officers; Ke Chengbing is seized the same day in Haizhu District. For five days the family hears nothing; Zheng Churan searches bureaus and works the hotlines. 26 March 2019: the family is told by phone that he is held at Shenzhen No. 2 Detention Centre on suspicion of picking quarrels. 28 March 2019: lawyer Fan Biaowen achieves a meeting; Wei's hair is shaved, he is in the grey uniform, and he says he has not been tortured but has been verbally abused. 19 April 2019: he and Ke are moved into RSDL, whereabouts unknown. 22 April 2019: the three families write jointly to the Pingshan Procuratorate. 23 April 2019: Ke's father is held ten hours by state security and made to sign the dismissal of his son's lawyer. 14 May 2019: Wei's family lawyer is refused a visit on the ground that Wei has 'dismissed' his lawyer in writing. 19 July 2019: four UN experts issue their urgent appeal. July–August 2019: Amnesty's third urgent action and the CPJ's letter follow. August 2019: police tell the families the three have been formally arrested, are back in Shenzhen No. 2 Detention Centre, and have all 'dismissed' their family lawyers. 26 February 2020: Pun Ngai writes that the case is stalled by the epidemic and the three are as if in a black hole. 20 March 2020: one year on, the three are still held. 24 April 2020: the three are tried and sentenced to one year and six months' imprisonment with a three-year probation term (ILO file; court's name and judgment text no public record). May 2021: the UN disappearances working group records the three as 'reportedly at liberty'. About April 2023: the three-year probation term, counted from the sentence, expires (this page's arithmetic; no source confirmation). Thereafter to this check: no public record.
20. Latest status: released years ago; his present situation has no public record
As of this check, the last verifiable state of Wei Zhili is this: sentenced to a suspended term on 24 April 2020 and released (the exact day has no public record); recorded by the UN Working Group on Enforced or Involuntary Disappearances, before May 2021, as 'reportedly at liberty'; his three-year probation term expired, by arithmetic, around April 2023. Since then there has been no reliable public reporting of continued surveillance, of an exit ban, of any fresh summons or seizure — and equally no record of his return to public activity. This page therefore judges that the case does not meet the threshold for the 'Ongoing' column: he is not still in custody, his probation has on any computable view expired, and no sourced, continuing restriction exists; to list him as 'still under persecution' would repeat exactly the class of error corrected in Section 1. The case is kept as a closed persecution file: a criminal conviction for picking quarrels follows a man in China for life, in his record, in background checks and at a hundred invisible thresholds; the judgment has never been published; and the machinery that dismantled his defence has never been corrected or apologised for by any authority. Those are the entries this archive keeps — not a live status in the Ongoing wall.
21. Verification and sources
The sources actually consulted for this check are as follows. First rank, primary and near-primary records: Zheng Churan's essay 'Separated Again by a High Wall' (written in late March 2019, published by Hong Kong Free Press on 21 April 2019; read in full via the China Labor Crackdown Concern Group republication and in Made in China Journal, vol. 4 issue 1, 2019) — the spine of his early life, the night of the seizure, the five days of searching and the 28 March meeting; and the urgent appeal of four UN special-procedure mandates of 19 July 2019 (UA CHN 14/2019, read in full in the OHCHR's public PDF) — the spine of the places and manner of the seizures, the RSDL dates and legal analysis, and the day-by-day destruction of the defence. Second rank, institutional records: the ILO Committee on Freedom of Association case file (public NORMLEX text, including the record of its March 2022 examination) — source of the three load-bearing facts of the 24 April 2020 trial, the sentence of eighteen months with three years' probation, and China's failure to transmit the judgments; its character, as a committee's recital of a complainant's material and its demands on the government, is graded accordingly throughout this page; the report of the UN Working Group on Enforced or Involuntary Disappearances on its 124th session (2021) — source of the 'reportedly at liberty' clarification; the U.S. Congressional-Executive Commission on China's 2020 and 2021 annual reports and its Political Prisoner Database records 2019-00127 to 2019-00129. Third rank, rights organisations and professional bodies: Amnesty International's three urgent actions (27 March, 25 April and 26 July 2019, read in full); Front Line Defenders' one-year statement of 18 March 2020 (read in full); the Network of Chinese Human Rights Defenders' statement of 25 July 2019 (read in full via republication); the Committee to Protect Journalists' articles of 21 March and 8 August 2019 (read in full); Reporters Without Borders' March 2019 call (via the ecoi.net archive); Human Rights Watch, 'China's Labor Activists "Hold Fast to Freedom"', 1 April 2019 (read in full). Fourth rank, independent long-form reporting: Hong Kong Free Press, 'I don't want people to forget him', 5 May 2019 (read in full via republication) — source of Zheng's campaign in detail, the silencing of her accounts, the CN¥7,500 WeChat Wallet seizure, the workers' petition, and the lawyer-relayed 'stolen phones' item; AFP's report of 21 March 2019 (read via multiple republications); Made in China Journal's first-quarter 2019 survey of the crackdown on labour activism; Pun Ngai's article of 26 February 2020 (read via its positions politics republication). Fifth rank, background only: Freedom House's China Media Bulletin items on the case. Image check, see metadata: no compliant photograph of him was located on Wikimedia Commons in this check — details in the metadata.
22. Our Take
What is worth fixing about Wei Zhili's case is the charge sheet's list of 'acts'. Lay every source side by side and the totality of what earned him eighteen months suspended for three years is this: he edited a labour medium, he wrote the stories of men with ruined lungs, he taught workers the law, he helped them file complaints and stood with them at their protests, and when his articles were deleted he posted them again. No violence, no property, no identifiable individual 'victim' — the offence of picking quarrels and provoking trouble, in this case, was made to hold the most ordinary work of civil society there is. What the police said in his parents' living room was, in truth, more honest than the indictment: no house, no children, no proper job — to be taken away for re-education. A legal document needs an offence; the living-room sentence needed none. A thirty-year-old graduate of a good university who declined the standard life and insisted on writing for pneumoconiosis workers was, in that view, himself a malfunction of order.
Look next at the procedure, which reads like a standard operating sample for how to make a defence disappear: seize the man from his parents' home at 2 a.m. and give the family no notice for five days; when the thirty-seven days of criminal detention run out, switch him into RSDL — a tool reserved by law for state-security felonies — and vanish him; hold one father for ten hours without food until he signs his son's lawyer away; block every other lawyer with a 'written statement' nobody is allowed to see; then announce that all three men have 'voluntarily' changed counsel. By trial day, who sat in that courtroom for the defence, and whether the families even knew, is something the public record does not contain a single word about. And the manner of the sentence makes the same point: after thirteen months inside, eighteen months suspended for three — the term roughly cancelling the time already served, release following conviction, no acquittal ever uttered, and no judgment ever published. The ILO has asked for that judgment for years; there is still no answer. This page's closing judgment is simple: the archival value of Wei Zhili's case lies precisely in its smallness — a small charge, a small sentence, no spectacular torture allegation, no international headline. It is in small cases like this that one sees most clearly how a system handles an editor who writes, and a group of men whose lungs are gone.