EndCCPWorld.com

China: Archive of Communist Crimes & Victims
ARCHIVE / MEMORY / EVIDENCE

让历史被看见
让受害者被铭记
Let History Be Seen
Let Victims Be Remembered

第155案 | 鲍彤Case 155 | Bao Tong

鲍彤,1932年生于浙江海宁,中共中央前委员、中央政治体制改革研究室主任、赵紫阳的政治秘书,十三大政治改革方案的主要操盘手与执笔人,1989年5月28日在六四镇压前夕被捕,1992年被以泄露国家秘密与反革命宣传煽动罪闭门判刑七年,在秦城监狱单独关押,1996年刑满当日又被转往西山加押近一年,1997年在全家迁入监控住所的条件下回家,此后被全天候监视、封口二十余年,2022年11月9日在北京病逝,终年90岁,连告别仪式都有多名友人被警方明令禁止到场。Bao Tong, born in Haining, Zhejiang in 1932, was a CCP Central Committee member, director of the Central Political System Reform research office and political secretary to Zhao Ziyang, and a principal drafter of the 13th Party Congress political-reform programme. Arrested on 28 May 1989 on the eve of the Tiananmen crackdown, he was sentenced in a closed trial in 1992 to seven years for leaking state secrets and counter-revolutionary propaganda, served in solitary confinement at Qincheng Prison, was held for roughly another year at Xishan after his sentence expired in 1996, was sent home in 1997 only on condition that his family move into a surveilled apartment, and lived under round-the-clock watch and silencing for over two decades until his death in Beijing on 9 November 2022, aged 90 — with many friends expressly barred by police even from his farewell ceremony.

Time
Born 5 November 1932 in Haining, Zhejiang (raised in Shanghai); joined the Chinese Communist Party in 1949 as an underground member; purged in the Cultural Revolution and separated from his wife for rural "re-education"; from about 1980, political secretary to Zhao Ziyang, director of the CCP Central Committee's political-reform research office, a lead drafter of the 13th Party Congress report, political secretary to the Politburo Standing Committee from November 1987 to May 1989, and a member of the 13th Central Committee; arrested in Beijing on 28 May 1989 — the highest-ranking official formally charged and sentenced over the 1989 movement; held in solitary confinement at Qincheng Prison from 1989 to May 1990, then under house arrest, and re-arrested on 21 January 1992; tried behind closed doors at the Beijing Intermediate People's Court on 21 July 1992 and sentenced to seven years in prison plus two years' deprivation of political rights for "leaking state secrets" and "counter-revolutionary propaganda and incitement" (the two counts carried a combined nine years, reduced to seven at the court's stated discretion, with his three years of pre-trial detention credited); his appeal was rejected by the Beijing Higher People's Court on 6 August 1992; on 27 May 1996, the day his sentence expired, he was not freed but transferred to a government compound at Xishan outside Beijing for roughly another year; released home on 26 April 1997 on condition that his family move into a specially prepared apartment in Shijingshan; deprived of political rights until May 1998; thereafter he lived for more than two decades under round-the-clock surveillance, gate control at his home and periodic silencing, until he died in Beijing at 07:08 on 9 November 2022, aged 90; his farewell ceremony was held at Babaoshan Revolutionary Cemetery on 15 November 2022, with many friends expressly barred by the authorities from attending
Place
Haining, Zhejiang (birthplace); Shanghai (raised there, Nanyang High School); Beijing (Central Organization Department; service as Zhao Ziyang's secretary; place of arrest on 28 May 1989, of trial, of his home and surveillance for decades, and of his death); Henan and Jiangxi provinces (the villages to which he and his wife were separately sent for "re-education" in the Cultural Revolution — he worked on a Henan tobacco farm, per a 2015 McClatchy report); Qincheng Prison (the high-security prison north of Beijing where he was held in solitary confinement); Beijing First Hospital (where he was treated during a serious deterioration of health documented by Amnesty International in 1995, returning to Qincheng for monthly family visits); a government compound at Xishan (where he was held for about a year after his sentence expired in May 1996); Shijingshan district, Beijing (the specially prepared apartment, about 10 km from the city centre, into which the family was required to move in 1997; he later moved to another Beijing apartment and the surveillance system followed); Babaoshan Revolutionary Cemetery (farewell ceremonies for his wife Jiang Zongcao on 25 August 2022 and for Bao Tong himself on 15 November 2022, both in an ordinary public hall rather than a leaders' hall)
People
Bao Tong (1932–2022), former Central Committee member, director of the Central Political System Reform research office and political secretary to Zhao Ziyang, the most senior official sentenced after 1989, who after prison became one of the best-known critics of the system from within its own ranks; Zhao Ziyang (1919–2005), CCP general secretary (1987–1989) and premier (1980–1987), Bao's superior and lifelong point of reference, held under house arrest for the rest of his life and died on 17 January 2005; his wife Jiang Zongcao (died of cancer on 21 August 2022, aged 90), a former underground party member who later worked at the Central Compilation Bureau, pushed to the ground by a plainclothes officer in January 2005 on the way to mourn Zhao, fracturing a vertebra and spending three months in hospital; his son Bao Pu, Hong Kong-based independent publisher and founder of New Century Press, editor-publisher of Zhao Ziyang's memoir (Journey of the Reforms / Prisoner of the State, 2009), who announced his father's death on social media on 9 November 2022; his daughter Bao Jian, who lived with her parents in Beijing, and granddaughter Bao Yangyang; Gao Shan, a senior official of the political-reform research office and close colleague of Bao, arrested the same day, 28 May 1989, and sentenced to four years in a closed trial on 5 August 1992; An Ziwen, head of the Central Organization Department and Bao's early superior and mentor; Gao Yu, independent journalist and close friend of the couple, barred by police from both farewell ceremonies in 2022; Shang Baojun, rights lawyer, barred from Bao's funeral, per Radio Free Asia
Charges and sentence
Charges: "leaking state secrets" and "counter-revolutionary propaganda and incitement." The core allegation was that he had told colleagues at the political-reform research institute of the impending decision to impose martial law — an allegation Bao denied for the rest of his life, stating that the institute's thirteen researchers testified he had never mentioned martial law (see Sections 4 and 16). Trial: held behind closed doors at the Beijing Intermediate People's Court on 21 July 1992 and decided the same day; the two counts together carried nine years, which a court official said the judges had reduced to seven by discretionary ruling, plus two years' deprivation of political rights, with pre-trial detention credited; his appeal was rejected by the Beijing Higher People's Court on 6 August 1992 (Amnesty International documents of August 1992). One conflict of record must be pinned down: the English Wikipedia entry describes a "brief show trial" in which he was "publicly convicted," whereas Amnesty International, reporting at the time, states the trial was held behind closed doors and that no official information about the proceedings or the evidence was made public; this page follows Amnesty's contemporaneous record and files the other version alongside (Section 16). Party status: expelled from the CCP (his membership is recorded as 1949–1992). His roughly one extra year of detention at Xishan after his sentence expired, and the two decades of residential surveillance that followed, rest on no published judicial document of any kind. Amnesty International designated him a prisoner of conscience from 1992 and called for his unconditional release
Status
Deceased. Bao Tong died in Beijing on 9 November 2022, aged 90, four days after his ninetieth birthday. The cause of death is given in conflicting accounts: the New York Times obituary, citing his son Bao Pu, says acute leukemia; his friend Gao Yu said he had myelodysplastic syndrome; the two accounts are filed side by side (Section 16). His wife Jiang Zongcao had died of cancer two and a half months earlier, on 21 August 2022. The subject himself is gone and the case is closed as biography, but its core facts are unchanged at the last check: the 1989 verdict has never been officially revisited, his writings have never been permitted publication in mainland China, and mourning for him was still being policed in November 2022. Last verified: November 2026 (on the basis of the November 2022 obituaries and funeral reporting; no public record found of any official restatement of his case since)
Bao Tong at home
Bao Tong at home in Beijing | Source: Voice of America | Public domain (U.S. federal government work)

1. From Haining to Shanghai: born 1932, a teenage party member

Bao Tong was born on 5 November 1932 in Haining, Zhejiang, the third of six children (per the New York Times obituary), and grew up in Shanghai. At Nanyang High School he met his future wife, Jiang Zongcao, who by biographical accounts was already an active member of the Communist underground and had been expelled from several schools for organising student demonstrations. Bao joined the Chinese Communist Party in 1949; sources phrase the timing slightly differently — "at age 16" in McClatchy's 2015 profile, "an underground member before the 1949 seizure of power" in the Associated Press obituary — and this page uses the cautious form: he joined the party's underground around 1949. One detail is preserved in several biographical accounts: he was recruited to work for the new government during the lunch break on the day he was sitting his university entrance examinations. He never entered a university classroom; he walked straight into the party-state apparatus instead, sent to Beijing to work in the Central Organization Department under An Ziwen, who became an important mentor. That starting point explains everything that followed. Bao was never an outside observer of the system; he was cadre material the system had trained from day one. The severity and the sheer duration of his punishment after 1989 only make sense against that background: in the authorities' eyes this was not an outsider's offence but one of their own turning against them.

The Organization Department years ended abruptly with the Cultural Revolution. Bao and An Ziwen were purged together. According to McClatchy's 2015 profile, in 1970 Bao Tong and Jiang Zongcao were labelled "capitalist roaders," split apart and sent down separately to villages in Henan and Jiangxi for "re-education"; Bao worked on a tobacco farm in Henan while their son Bao Pu lived with his grandparents and only occasionally saw his father. The couple spent most of the Cultural Revolution apart, in the countryside and in factories. Bao rarely dramatised this period in his later writing, but it laid down two threads: a first-hand knowledge of how the system's campaign-style machinery worked, and a marriage that had already survived one long political punishment — which matters for understanding the shove in 2005 and the decades of surveillance the family later endured together.

2. Rehabilitation: the Science and Technology Commission, Zhao Ziyang, political secretary

After the Cultural Revolution Bao was rehabilitated and restored to work. The New York Times obituary records that in 1980 he was working at the State Science and Technology Commission when Zhao Ziyang, a provincial leader with a reformist reputation, was promoted to the central leadership in Beijing; Bao was recommended to Zhao and became his secretary, advising him on policy and helping him navigate the political currents of the post-Mao, market-oriented era. Zhao was premier from 1980 to 1987 and CCP general secretary from 1987 to 1989, and throughout that decade Bao remained one of his core policy staff: attending top-level meetings and drafting documents and speeches was the shape of his working life. From November 1987 to May 1989 he also served as political secretary to the Politburo Standing Committee, and he was elected to the 13th Central Committee — the inner layer of the ruling party's power structure, the highest point a secretary of his kind could reach.

His institutional title needs pinning down because transcriptions vary. The office he directed is rendered in Chinese as the Central Political System Reform research office (the "Central Political Reform Office" in shorthand); English reporting variously calls it the Office of Political Reform of the Central Committee or the Research Centre for Reform of the Political Structure, and an early Amnesty document once mistranscribed it as a centre for the "Return" of the political structure. He was the director of that office and the operator of Zhao Ziyang's political-reform agenda. That, in turn, explains his place near the top of the purge list after 1989: the accounts for economic reform could be settled slowly, but the man who ran political reform had to be taken first.

3. Running political reform: the 1986 package and the 13th Congress report

In 1986 Zhao tasked Bao with designing a package of reforms. Bao served as a director of the drafting committee for the 13th Party Congress report, and the Congress, held in October 1987, adopted a political-reform package whose published contents included separating party and state functions and an attempt to end nepotism. That report later became an unavoidable reference point in every discussion of Chinese political reform: it was the last time a full political-reform programme was written into a formal party document, and nothing like it has appeared in the three and a half decades since. Bao's role in it is consistent across the obituaries: he was the principal drafter of Zhao's speeches and editorials and one of the shapers of the reform camp's policy language. He was also involved in another period piece of work: in 1986 he and Zhao helped the Hungarian-American investor George Soros establish a Beijing-based Fund for the Reform and Opening of China. After 1989 that episode was used as material for attacks on the Zhao–Bao circle as colluding with foreign capital; this page records it only as documented fact, and whether it was formally cited at his trial is a matter of no public record.

Seen from 1988, Bao's position was double: he was both a beneficiary of reform and the most concrete pair of hands through which its documents passed. Every clause of the 13th Congress package — party-state separation, discussion of competitive elections, social dialogue — needed someone to turn an idea into text, and to a large extent that someone was Bao Tong. This is also the ground of his later criticism's confidence: when he attacked the subsequent retreat, he was not invoking abstract ideals but a text he had written himself and seen adopted by a party congress. The road China actually took ran in the opposite direction from the 13th Congress report, and that was the constant theme of his commentary for the rest of his life.

4. April–May 1989: the protests, Zhao's resignation draft, and where the "leak" charge came from

In April 1989 students poured into Beijing's streets, mourning Hu Yaobang, protesting corruption and demanding political reform. What the public record supports about Bao Tong's position in those weeks must be drawn strictly: he was Zhao Ziyang's political secretary and the drafter of his speeches and editorials, and Zhao, in the split at the top, argued for handling the movement through dialogue and legal means and opposed the use of force; the English Wikipedia entry, citing sources, describes Bao as one of the very few senior officials to express understanding for the demonstrating students. Anything beyond that — for instance, private contacts with student representatives — is not supported by any reliable public record this page could find, and nothing has been invented to fill it. The New York Times obituary supplies a key scene repeated by many accounts: on the night of 17 May 1989 Zhao called Bao into his office and told him to draft Zhao's resignation letter. Eleven days later Bao was summoned to party headquarters, where a car with police plates was waiting to take him straight to Qincheng Prison; the obituary, drawing on his memoirs, quotes the guard's words to him: "From now on you're called 8901."

The alleged "leak" was that he had passed to colleagues the leadership's impending decision to impose martial law. His denial of that charge never changed in thirty-three years, and he gave it a checkable detail: in a long memoir essay published by Radio Free Asia, he wrote that Li Peng had complained to the State Council side that Bao had leaked a classified military decision of the Politburo Standing Committee to thirteen researchers at the central political-reform research institute — whereas in fact, he wrote, all thirteen testified that he had never mentioned martial law at all; he had told them he himself was about to be investigated, and asked them to observe party discipline and keep quiet. That is Bao's own side of the story, and its completeness cannot be independently verified by this page; it is filed as his account. But the other side of the ledger must be pinned down too: the trial was closed, and the authorities never published the evidence behind the charge — Amnesty International's 1992 document states plainly that no official information had been made public about the proceedings or the evidence on which the charges were based. So the question "what exactly did he leak?" has, in the public record to this day, only one side's specific narrative and the other side's charge-sheet headline. That asymmetry is itself part of the evidentiary record of this case.

5. 28 May 1989: the arrest

Bao Tong was arrested in Beijing on 28 May 1989, six days before the crackdown began. He was the highest-ranking official arrested over the Tiananmen events, and in the end the only Central Committee-level figure formally charged and sentenced; his superior Zhao Ziyang was placed under house arrest for life and never tried. The manner of the arrest, per the New York Times: summoned to party headquarters, a police car waiting, driven directly to Qincheng Prison. One date discrepancy must be pinned: a March 2000 Human Rights Watch statement says he was detained on 26 May 1989 on his way to a Central Committee meeting — two days earlier than the 28 May date used consistently by Amnesty International, Wikipedia and all the obituaries. This page adopts 28 May and files 26 May alongside (Section 16). His colleague Gao Shan of the political-reform research office was arrested the same day; Amnesty's August 1992 document states clearly that both men were arrested on 28 May 1989 for allegedly leaking the martial-law decision.

What followed was detention in stages, documented by Amnesty International's January 1995 medical-concern file: after his arrest he was held in solitary confinement at Qincheng for a year; in May 1990 he was released into house arrest at home; on 21 January 1992 he was re-arrested at home and held at Qincheng from then on. In other words, by the time he stood trial in July 1992 he had already been deprived of liberty for more than three years, including a full year of solitary confinement without charge or trial. Of the interrogation itself the public record is extremely thin: the New York Times records that he refused to turn on Zhao Ziyang, and that at trial the prosecutors shifted the charge, accusing him of spreading word of Zhao's resignation, an allegation he also fought. The content of interrogation sessions, transcripts, and any use of coercion are matters of no public record, and this page offers no speculative reconstruction. What can be fixed is the outcome: he never supplied the testimony against Zhao that the authorities wanted, and Zhao, in his sixteen years of house arrest, was never charged either — the two men between them turned the case into an isolated one with no "accomplice confession" at its centre.

6. The Qincheng years: solitary confinement, failing health, family visits

Qincheng is the prison reserved for senior political prisoners, some 80 km north of Beijing (per Amnesty International's 1995 file). The keyword the public record gives for Bao's time there is "solitary": the English Wikipedia entry and the introduction to Ian Johnson's 2012 New York Review of Books interview both say he served his full sentence in isolation at Qincheng, while McClatchy's profile says the seven years were spent "mostly" in solitary confinement — a small discrepancy between "throughout" and "mostly," filed in Section 16. Recalling those years to a reporter late in life, he was strikingly calm: being alone in a room with no distractions, he said, had let him think many questions through quietly and thoroughly. The remark was widely quoted; this page files it as a reporter's relay of his words and does not dress it up as prison enlightenment. A man in his sixties held alone for seven years is the substance of the punishment, and a calm retrospect does not change that.

His health is the other documented thread of the Qincheng years. On 24 January 1995 Amnesty International issued a medical-concern action: Bao Tong, aged 62, was experiencing a serious deterioration in his health; he was then being held at Beijing First Hospital and was returned to Qincheng Prison, 80 km north, for monthly family visits; the document confirms Amnesty's position that he was a prisoner of conscience and calls for his unconditional release. The phrasing preserves a detail of great archival value: family visits did not happen at the hospital or at will — they happened once a month, at Qincheng. Visitation itself had been made part of the machinery of control. What illness he had and what treatment he received are matters of no further public record. Between his re-arrest in 1992 and the expiry of his sentence in 1996, almost nothing else about his daily life in prison can be checked: no published collection of prison letters, no systematic family memoir. This page records that thinness honestly rather than filling it with imagination.

7. 27 May 1996: sentence served — and the Xishan year

27 May 1996 was the day Bao Tong's seven-year sentence expired — counted from his arrest in 1989 with pre-trial detention credited, which is why the legal release date falls in 1996 rather than 1999. What happened that day is the single most instructive scene in the whole case for understanding punishment beyond punishment: he did not go home. He was transferred to a government compound at Xishan, in Beijing's western hills, and held there for roughly another year. PEN's action alert of June 1996, distributed via IFEX, was headlined plainly: an author who remains under "house arrest" after release from prison. Amnesty International's update of April 1997 records how that detention ended: on 26 April 1997 Bao Tong was finally released from "house arrest," conditional on his family moving out of the central-Beijing apartment allocated to him as a senior official and into a specially prepared apartment in Shijingshan, a western district about 10 km from the centre (the Amnesty text misspells the district's name; it is Shijingshan).

The configuration of that apartment, as summarised by the English Wikipedia entry from multiple reports, was specific: a gate guarded around the clock and surveillance cameras installed; visitors screened; the home telephone tapped or cut off entirely; and the moment Bao stepped out of his home, an entourage of men followed him. When he later moved to another apartment in Beijing, the whole system — screening, phone interference, tailing — moved with him. Which is to say: what ended in 1996 was only his "sentence"; what ended in 1997 was only his "detention"; what actually ran until the end of his life was a third layer of disposition with no name, no document and no term — surveillance. This page keeps the three layers separate on purpose, because conflating them is the commonest distortion in cases like this: a newspaper line saying "released in 1996" leads an ordinary reader to assume the story ended there. In fact, after 1996 there was a full second half, twenty-five years long.

8. Home after 1997: six followers, and an open letter

After returning home in April 1997, Bao lived in west Beijing with his wife Jiang Zongcao, his daughter Bao Jian and his granddaughter Bao Yangyang. His political rights remained deprived until May 1998; according to Human Rights Watch, once they were restored he began speaking out against government and party policies. The intensity of the surveillance has a first-person record in his own hand: on 13 March 2000, just before the annual session of the UN Commission on Human Rights in Geneva, Bao wrote an open letter to the Beijing Public Security Bureau and to the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, which Human Rights Watch published in full on 29 March 2000 while condemning the stepped-up harassment. In the letter he wrote that day and night, whenever he stepped out of his home, six people followed him closely — when he took his granddaughter to school, and when he went to the hospital, the bank or the shops — and that his rights had been further limited and violated since the beginning of that year. The letter's value is that it is a signed, named, formally addressed document by the person concerned, not a journalist's paraphrase: the starting configuration of two decades of surveillance was pinned to paper in 2000 by the surveilled man himself.

The gate regime at his home was still being recorded by journalists fifteen years later. McClatchy's 2015 profile describes visitors who were permitted entry having to show identification to a clerk behind a desk in the cold, scruffy lobby of his apartment tower; the authorities monitored his calls and blocked those they did not approve; visitation was limited. The same profile records that in "sensitive periods" he would be taken out of Beijing — for instance around the 25th anniversary of the June 4 crackdown in 2014. This practice of enforced "travel" became a fixture of his calendar: around every June 4 anniversary, major meeting and sensitive commemoration, he was either silenced in place or removed from the capital. According to the summary in the English Wikipedia entry, since his arrest in 1989 he was permitted to leave Beijing only three times, the last in 2009 — a holiday from 22 May to 7 June under Public Security escort. That item rests on Wikipedia's synthesis alone, with no second source found to confirm it independently, and is flagged unverified in Section 16.

9. The daily mechanics of silencing: cut phone lines, screened interviews, nowhere to publish

Bao Tong did not fall silent after prison. He wrote regular commentaries for Radio Free Asia's Mandarin service on a wide range of Chinese and international subjects, including a column whose very title invoked his condition — rendered in English reporting as "Under House Arrest." He received foreign journalists, spoke at the Beijing dissident circle's dinners, and was described by Gao Yu as that circle's "spiritual leader," whose keynote remarks were always the highlight of those gatherings (Voice of America, November 2022). But inside mainland China's public space he did not exist: his writing was never permitted in mainland publications, and his name rarely appears in the official record (Radio Free Asia). The tools of silencing were mundane and daily: the home telephone was tapped and periodically cut off, especially when overseas callers asked to speak to him (per Wikipedia's synthesis of Reuters and other reporting); on 1 January 2007 Reuters used China's newly relaxed rules on foreign reporting to make a test visit to his home, nominally to interview him about the 2008 Olympics — and recorded that the guards sometimes attempted to intimidate or deny visitors, though most foreign reporters with prior arrangements were let in. That sentence deserves a slow reading: the fact that "most foreign reporters could get in" had to be established by a test under a new rule tells you that in the normal run of things, entry depended entirely on the discretion of the men at the gate.

The publishing blockade is clearest in the affair of Zhao Ziyang's memoir (Section 10). Bao's own recollections of 1989 could appear only outside the mainland: his long memoir and commentary essays ran on Radio Free Asia and other overseas outlets, and as late as June 2022 RFA was still publishing his multi-part commentary on the Li Peng diaries and the decision-making of 1989. His position in mainland publishing can be stated in one sentence: no public record has been found of any mainland publisher or newspaper printing a signed piece by him after 1989. A man who went from drafting a party congress report to being unable to publish a single character in his own country — that parabola is the most complete footnote to the word "silencing" that this case offers.

10. The Zhao Ziyang memoir affair: what he said, and what it cost

Under house arrest, Zhao Ziyang secretly recorded some thirty cassette tapes recounting his life and the inside story of 1989. After Zhao's death on 17 January 2005, the tapes were passed out hand to hand and turned into a book. On 19 May 2009 the English edition, Prisoner of the State, was published to coincide with the twentieth anniversary of June 4 (the Chinese edition, Journey of the Reforms, was released in Hong Kong by New Century Press on 29 May); the editor-publisher was Bao Pu, Bao Tong's son. Bao Tong's own role must be stated as the record gives it: he was not the editor, but he was one of the insiders and promoters of Zhao's recording project — the recordings had to be made without alerting the guards, and Bao explained to outsiders how it worked (if the guards had heard Zhao talking to himself they would have been alerted; the sound of friends visiting and conversing was the cover). Around publication he gave extensive interviews and wrote commentary in his capacity as Zhao's former political secretary, vouching for the memoir's authenticity and using its appearance to put the 1989 decision-making process back into public discussion. The core judgement he repeated in memoir-related writing and interviews was consistent: Zhao had argued for resolving the student movement by democratic and legal means, had opposed martial law and the use of force, and on the night of 17 May had him draft a resignation letter — an account that interlocks with Zhao's own narration on the tapes.

The cost of the affair is also documented. A US State Department cable of 18 June 2009 (later released via WikiLeaks) recorded Bao Pu saying he had been followed and watched by mainland operatives in Hong Kong in the two weeks before the memoir's release — his first such experience there — and noted that New Century Press was his creation and that Bao Tong himself was under police surveillance in Beijing. In Beijing, Bao's situation in that sensitive season only tightened; the one escorted "holiday" out of the capital attributed to him in that period ran from 22 May to 7 June 2009, spanning 4 June itself (Section 8; the item rests on Wikipedia's synthesis, and this page notes the overlap of dates without asserting causation on that basis alone). The archival significance of the affair is this: Zhao was dead and Bao was gagged, but the tapes, a publisher in the next generation, and Hong Kong's publishing space together punched a hole in the blockade — a breakout completed jointly by two generations of the Bao family.

11. The family's price (I): Jiang Zongcao — from underground activist to the wife pushed to the ground

Jiang Zongcao's life is half of this family's archive in its own right. As a teenager she was already active in the Communist underground and was expelled from several schools for organising demonstrations (biographical accounts); she met Bao at Nanyang High School, and together they went through the Cultural Revolution's rustication and separation — in 1970 both were labelled "capitalist roaders" and sent down separately to Henan and Jiangxi. After her husband's imprisonment in 1989 she carried the seven years of prison visiting alone; Amnesty International's 1995 document catches the shape of those visits from the side: her husband was held at Beijing First Hospital, yet was returned to Qincheng once a month, and it was there the family saw him. After he came home, she lived with the family for more than twenty years in the apartment with the 24-hour guarded gate and the cameras, next to a tapped telephone.

The most concrete and best-documented price this family paid came in 2005. After Zhao Ziyang died on 17 January 2005, Bao Tong and his wife tried to leave home to pay their respects at the Zhao family home. The Washington Post reported on 19 January 2005 that more than twenty plainclothes security agents attacked the couple and both were injured; Jiang Zongcao was pushed to the ground by a policeman, suffered a fracture in her spine, and was hospitalised for three months. McClatchy's 2015 profile and Radio Free Asia's 2022 reporting agree: pushed down, a fractured vertebra, three months in bed or in hospital. A woman in her seventies, whose only act was trying to bow before the portrait of her husband's old superior — the man for whose sake her husband had served seven years — had a vertebra broken by the plainclothes men of the state. Thereafter every Zhao anniversary required a calculation: McClatchy records that in January 2015, on the tenth anniversary of Zhao's death, Bao made no attempt to leave home for a memorial — not because he did not want to go, but because the family had already paid for that errand once, in spine. Another record of Jiang's later years comes from Radio Free Asia: in 2015 she described how, around the June 4 anniversary, Bao — by then over eighty — was suddenly taken out of Beijing, and she was left at home alone. In the annual citywide clampdown, this was how the family was split: the husband removed, the elderly wife left behind.

12. The family's price (II): Bao Pu, Bao Jian, and a policed funeral

After Bao Tong's imprisonment, his son Bao Pu went to the United States and studied computer engineering and public administration at Princeton (McClatchy), then settled in Hong Kong and founded New Century Press, specialising in books banned on the mainland — memoirs of former leaders and exposés of inner-party struggles. McClatchy spelled out the risk embedded in that choice: Bao Pu travelled to the mainland once or twice a year to visit his parents, each trip carrying a risk of arrest, while the publishing house and his profile in turn added a layer of pressure over his parents in Beijing. Bao Tong himself was lucid about the arithmetic: McClatchy records that he had to weigh every action against its possible repercussions for his family. Of his daughter Bao Jian the public record is thin: she lived with her parents and was the daily caregiver inside the surveilled apartment. His granddaughter Bao Yangyang appears in his 2000 open letter — then still a schoolchild he walked to school, with six followers trailing even that short journey.

In 2022 the family held two policed funerals in three months. Jiang Zongcao died of cancer on 21 August 2022, aged 90; her farewell was set for the morning of 25 August at the Mei Hall of Babaoshan Revolutionary Cemetery, as a small ceremony. Radio Free Asia's reporting that day preserved the mechanics of the control: Gao Yu said police came to her home at 10 p.m. on 24 August to tell her that "the higher-ups" at Chaoyang district police had instructed that she could not attend; police set a cap of 30 attendees, at least half of them officials from Jiang's former work unit, the Central Compilation Bureau; actual relatives numbered only about fourteen; friends could not get in at all, and armed police stood at the gates with a list. And Bao Tong himself did not appear at his wife's farewell — Radio Free Asia reported he was believed to be already in a Beijing hospital by then. A husband of more than seventy years absent from his wife's funeral: no source explains it any other way. A family surveilled for a lifetime completed even its last farewells inside a quota and a name list.

13. International response: from prisoner-of-conscience appeals to the obituary pages

The international response to Bao Tong's case left a complete institutional paper trail. Amnesty International was the earliest recorder: an urgent action in January 1992; documents of 22 July and 11 August 1992 recording his sentencing and the rejection of his appeal and designating him, Gao Shan and Wu Jiaxiang as prisoners of conscience; a medical-concern action in January 1995 on his deteriorating health; and an April 1997 update to its eighth-anniversary report recording the conditions of his release. PEN issued an action alert via IFEX in June 1996 protesting his transfer into house arrest after his sentence expired. Human Rights Watch's statement of 29 March 2000 condemned the escalating harassment and published his open letter to the Beijing Public Security Bureau and the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights in full. A 2009 US State Department cable (released via WikiLeaks) recorded the surveillance of Bao Pu in Hong Kong, showing that the memoir affair registered inside the US diplomatic system. The common thread must be recorded plainly: all of it stayed at the level of appeal, condemnation and documentation. No international action shortened his Qincheng years by a day, his Xishan year by a day, or his two decades of surveillance by a day. This archive records that impotence as it was, without inflating the effect of international attention.

After his death in November 2022 came the second wave of international record — the obituary pages of the world's major media: the New York Times (a full obituary on 22 November, describing him as the highest-ranking Chinese official imprisoned over Tiananmen who became an acerbic critic of the party), the Associated Press, BBC reporting, Agence France-Presse, Radio Free Asia and Voice of America all carried obituaries or memorial coverage within days. The obituary treatment itself measures his historical standing: a man nearly erased from his own country's official record had his death announced by his son on overseas social media and confirmed in relay by the world's wire services and great newspapers. In mainland China's public media, this page found no report of his death at all. The obituaries exist on one side of a wall, and not on the other — and that wall was the subject of everything he wrote in his second life.

14. 9 November 2022: his death, and a farewell his friends were forbidden to attend

Bao Tong died in Beijing at 07:08 on 9 November 2022, aged 90 — four days after his birthday on 5 November 1932. His son Bao Pu posted the notice that evening: his father had passed away peacefully at 7:08 a.m. on 9 November 2022, at the age of 90. The cause of death is given in conflicting accounts, filed here side by side: the New York Times obituary, citing Bao Pu, says acute leukemia; Gao Yu said on social media that he had myelodysplastic syndrome. The two are not medically unrelated — the latter can progress to the former — but as public record they are two different statements, and this page does not merge them on its own authority (Section 16). His wife had died two and a half months before him. China Heritage's memorial collection after his death carried Bao Pu's long biographical essay "My Father Bao Tong," and recorded one small unresolved matter: the Beijing artist Ai Song had made a portrait of Bao Tong in barbed wire for his "Wall of Ice" installation, and the collection called on Beijing police to return the portrait to Bao's children — no public record has been found that the whereabouts of that work have been resolved.

The farewell ceremony took place on Tuesday 15 November 2022 at Babaoshan Revolutionary Cemetery. Radio Free Asia reported on 16 November: the ceremony was held in the Plum Hall — a hall open to the general public, not one reserved for state leaders or VIPs; around 100 people attended, including his closest relatives (per journalist Ye Bing's social-media post); numerous pro-democracy activists and dissidents were barred from attending and mourned online instead, or managed to send wreaths; and those who were barred were not permitted even to sign their names on wreaths. Gao Yu, herself among the banned, said their group had been marked "absolutely no way" — they could neither bid Elder Bao farewell on his last journey nor place their elegiac couplets in the Babaoshan hall; she declined Radio Free Asia's interview request and agreed only to have her social-media posts quoted, which the report read as a sign she had been warned off speaking to media about the funeral. Rights lawyer Shang Baojun also confirmed to RFA that he had been barred. Gao Yu told Voice of America that Bao had been "essentially our spiritual leader." A man was dead; attendance at his mourning still required approval, and the names on wreaths still required vetting. The farewell was the last frame of the portrait of his life: the state could no longer imprison him, but it could still decide who was allowed to stand before his photograph.

15. Aftermath: the blank in China's official record, and the open questions

From Bao Tong's death to the present, there has been no official restatement of his case: no rehabilitation, no record of any review of his trial, no mainland media account of his life. Within the reach of this page's searches, his presence in China's official record remains close to a blank — the meetings he attended as a Central Committee member and the documents he drafted have been lifted whole out of the public official narrative, leaving only the 1989 charge-sheet, which surfaces now and then as a point of contrast in overseas reporting. At least four questions remain open as blanks in the public record rather than suspensions by this page: first, the specific evidence behind the "leaking state secrets" charge was never published, and the record of the closed trial is not publicly accessible; second, no published document has ever stated the legal basis for his year of detention at Xishan after his sentence expired, or for the two decades of surveillance that followed; third, beyond the pieces published overseas, the survival and publication arrangements of his complete manuscripts are a matter of no public record; fourth, the whereabouts of objects connected with him, such as Ai Song's barbed-wire portrait, are a matter of no public record.

His historical standing, by contrast, was settled repeatedly during obituary season and needs no embellishment from this page: he was the most senior official sentenced over 1989; a principal operator and drafter of the 13th Congress political-reform programme; one of the most important outside witnesses to Zhao Ziyang's house-arrest years; and one of the very few figures from inside the system who, after prison, criticised that system publicly, continuously and under his own name into his nineties. He and Zhao Ziyang, superior and secretary, one held under house arrest until death and the other imprisoned for seven years and then watched for twenty-six, together form the most complete specimen of the wholesale removal of the reform camp from the centre of power after 1989. What he left behind — his RFA columns, his long memoir essays on the decision-making of 1989, his commentaries on Zhao's memoir — constitutes a layer of primary material for the study of 1989, which his mainland compatriots can still read only by climbing the firewall.

16. Disputes and unverified items

This section pins down the case's conflicts of record and single-source items under one rule: set them side by side, do not adjudicate, and grade the evidence. (1) Cause of death: the New York Times obituary, citing his son Bao Pu, says acute leukemia; Gao Yu said myelodysplastic syndrome. Filed in parallel; the two are medically compatible as stages but are distinct statements in the public record, and this page does not merge them. (2) Form of the trial: the English Wikipedia entry describes a "brief show trial" and a public conviction; Amnesty International's 1992 documents state the trial was held behind closed doors and that no information about the proceedings or the evidence was made public. This page's text follows the contemporaneous institutional record (Amnesty); the other version is filed alongside. (3) Date of arrest: most sources agree on 28 May 1989; Human Rights Watch's March 2000 statement gives 26 May and says he was detained on his way to a Central Committee meeting. This page adopts 28 May; the other version is filed. (4) Extent of solitary confinement: Wikipedia and the New York Review of Books say he served his sentence in solitary throughout; McClatchy says "mostly" in solitary. Filed in parallel. (5) The item that since 1989 he was allowed to leave Beijing only three times, the last being an escorted holiday from 22 May to 7 June 2009, rests on the English Wikipedia entry's synthesis alone, with no independent second source found — flagged unverified. (6) A Times obituary listing gives his birth date as 6 November 1932, one day later than the 5 November given by the consistent majority of sources; this page adopts 5 November and files the variant. (7) The factual core of the "leak" charge: the authorities never published evidence; Bao denied the charge for life and stated that thirteen researchers testified he had never mentioned martial law — on this point the public record holds only Bao's specific account on one side and a charge-sheet headline on the other, and this page asserts neither side's factual version, recording the standoff itself. (8) The details of the Cultural Revolution rustication (the year 1970; the Henan tobacco farm; Jiangxi) rest mainly on McClatchy's 2015 profile alone — single-source, filed as such. (9) Details of his early acquaintance with Jiang Zongcao and their underground work rest on biographical accounts and the citations in the Wikipedia entry, without item-by-item confirmation from a second independent source — filed as biographical record.

17. Full timeline

5 November 1932: born in Haining, Zhejiang; raised in Shanghai. Around 1949: joins the CCP underground; recruited to work for the new government on the day of his university entrance examinations; works in Beijing in the Central Organization Department under An Ziwen. Cultural Revolution: purged together with An Ziwen; around 1970 he and Jiang Zongcao are labelled "capitalist roaders" and sent down separately to Henan and Jiangxi (single-source, Section 16). After rehabilitation, around 1980, while at the State Science and Technology Commission, he is recommended to Zhao Ziyang and becomes his secretary. Thereafter: Zhao's political secretary; director of the Central Political System Reform research office; in 1986 tasked by Zhao with designing a package of reforms and serves as a lead drafter of the 13th Congress report; October 1987, the 13th Congress adopts a political-reform package including party-state separation; November 1987 to May 1989, political secretary to the Politburo Standing Committee and member of the 13th Central Committee. Night of 17 May 1989: drafts Zhao Ziyang's resignation letter at Zhao's instruction (New York Times obituary). 28 May 1989: arrested in Beijing; his colleague Gao Shan is arrested the same day. 1989 to May 1990: held in solitary confinement at Qincheng Prison, then released into house arrest at home. 21 January 1992: re-arrested at home and held at Qincheng. 21 July 1992: tried behind closed doors at the Beijing Intermediate People's Court and sentenced the same day — seven years' imprisonment on the combined counts of leaking state secrets and counter-revolutionary propaganda and incitement, plus two years' deprivation of political rights, pre-trial detention credited; expelled from the party the same year. 5 August 1992: Gao Shan sentenced to four years in a closed trial. 6 August 1992: the Beijing Higher People's Court rejects Bao's appeal. 24 January 1995: Amnesty International issues a medical-concern action on his seriously deteriorated health, recording that he was held at Beijing First Hospital and returned to Qincheng for monthly family visits. 27 May 1996: on the day his sentence expires he is transferred to a government compound at Xishan and held there. June 1996: PEN, via IFEX, protests that he remains under house arrest after completing his sentence. 26 April 1997: released home, conditional on the family moving into a specially prepared apartment in Shijingshan. May 1998: deprivation of political rights ends; he begins commenting publicly on current affairs. 13 March 2000: his open letter to the Beijing Public Security Bureau and the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights describes six people following him whenever he leaves home; 29 March 2000, Human Rights Watch condemns the escalating harassment. 17 January 2005: Zhao Ziyang dies; 19 January 2005, the Washington Post reports that Bao and his wife were attacked by more than twenty plainclothes agents while trying to go and mourn Zhao, and that Jiang Zongcao was pushed down, fracturing her spine and spending three months in hospital. 1 January 2007: Reuters makes a test visit under the new foreign-reporting rules. 19 May 2009: Zhao Ziyang's memoir is published in English (Chinese edition 29 May), edited and published by Bao Pu, with Bao Tong commenting publicly in support; in the same period Bao Pu is followed in Hong Kong for two weeks (US State Department cable). June 2012: Ian Johnson's long interview with Bao appears in the New York Review of Books. 2014: around sensitive periods such as the 25th anniversary of June 4 he is taken out of Beijing (McClatchy, 2015). June 2022: Radio Free Asia is still publishing his essays on 1989. 21 August 2022: Jiang Zongcao dies of cancer, aged 90; her farewell on 25 August at Babaoshan is held under a police-imposed cap of 30 attendees, many friends are barred, and Bao Tong himself does not attend (reportedly already in hospital). 9 November 2022, 07:08: Bao Tong dies in Beijing, aged 90; his son Bao Pu announces the death. 15 November 2022: the farewell ceremony is held in the Plum Hall of Babaoshan Revolutionary Cemetery, attended by about 100 relatives and others, while Gao Yu, Shang Baojun and numerous other friends are expressly barred, and the barred are not permitted even to sign wreaths.

18. Sources and verification

This page is based on the following public sources, cross-checked in November 2026: the New York Times obituary of 22 November 2022 (biography; the 17 May resignation draft; the "8901" number; his refusal to turn on Zhao; cause of death as given by Bao Pu); the Associated Press obituary wire of 9–10 November 2022 (party membership, service to Zhao, sentence and house-arrest career); BBC obituary reporting of November 2022 (checked via multiple republications and quotations); Radio Free Asia — the death report of 9 November 2022, the funeral report of 16 November 2022, the report of 25 August 2022 on the policing of Jiang Zongcao's farewell (attendance cap, police name list, Gao Yu barred, Bao's absence), and Bao Tong's own memoir and commentary essays published by RFA (the thirteen researchers' testimony); Voice of America's memorial report of 16 November 2022 (Gao Yu's "spiritual leader" remark); Amnesty International documents — the urgent-action follow-ups of 22 July and 11 August 1992 (closed trial; nine years combined reduced to seven; appeal date and court), the medical-concern action of 24 January 1995 (the stages of his detention; deteriorating health; hospital and visiting arrangements), and the update of 30 April 1997 (release on 26 April 1997 and the relocation condition; political rights until May 1998); PEN's June 1996 alert via IFEX (post-sentence transfer to house arrest at Xishan); Human Rights Watch's statement of 29 March 2000 with the full text of Bao's open letter of 13 March 2000 (the six followers; the statement's arrest date of 26 May conflicts with the majority record and is filed in parallel); the Washington Post report of 19 January 2005 (cross-checked via the Wikipedia entry and McClatchy: the 2005 mourning attack; Jiang Zongcao's fractured spine and three months in hospital); Reuters' test interview of 1 January 2007 (checked via the Wikipedia entry); McClatchy's 2015 profile (Cultural Revolution rustication; lobby ID checks; removal from Beijing in sensitive periods; Bao Pu's position); Ian Johnson's interview in the New York Review of Books, 14 June 2012 (solitary confinement at Qincheng; surveillance after the 1996 release); the US State Department's Hong Kong cable of 18 June 2009 (WikiLeaks release: Bao Pu followed in Hong Kong); China Heritage's November 2022 memorial collection and Bao Pu's "My Father Bao Tong" (family background; Ai Song's barbed-wire portrait); and the English Wikipedia entries on Bao Tong and on Prisoner of the State (used for cross-comparison only; every item resting on them alone is flagged as filed or unverified in Section 16). Verification note: items on which two or more sources agree are stated in the text as the settled record; conflicts are set side by side; single-source items are flagged one by one. For matters where nothing could be found — interrogation transcripts, the evidence behind the charge, prison medical records, any legal instrument behind the surveillance, the whereabouts of his complete manuscripts — this page writes "no public record" and offers no speculative filling.

19. Our Take

What makes the Bao Tong case singular is that it runs one man through the complete ladder of the party-state's methods for disposing of dissent. First came solitary confinement without trial; then a closed trial and a seven-year sentence; then, the sentence served, no release — a further year at Xishan; then "release" itself was converted into a relocation order, the whole family moved into an apartment fitted with cameras and a permanently manned gate; and finally more than twenty years of surveillance with no name, no document and no term, lasting until death. Each step precisely avoided the legal appearance of the one before: the prison term was real, so "punished according to law" could be said aloud; the detention and surveillance after it had no paperwork, so there was nothing to appeal against, nothing to sue over, no court at any level to ask on what authority this was done. A man who had drafted the clause on separating party and state spent the last quarter-century of his life in a situation for which not a single citable legal provision exists — and that is not a defect of the design. It is the design: punishment continued in the form of administrative routine, arranged so that it looks as though nothing is happening.

What deserves equal permanence in the record is this case's structure of evidence. A Central Committee member was charged with "leaking state secrets"; the trial was closed, the evidence never published, the transcript never made public, and more than three decades later the public can retrieve only the name of the charge and the defendant's denial. A regime that can dispose of its own former Central Committee member and director of political reform in this way does not leave much to the imagination as to how it disposes of ordinary people. Everything Bao Tong wrote in his second life had, in essence, a single purpose: to recount the decision-making rooms of 1989 again and again and pin them to paper, so that "no record" itself became impossible. He achieved the part that was his to achieve: Zhao Ziyang's tapes got out; his commentaries survive in overseas archives; his obituary ran in the great newspapers of the world. The part he could not achieve is equally plain: his own country still does not permit his compatriots to read a word of his in any open channel, and even his funeral required the names on the wreaths to be vetted. This site enters his case as Persecution Record No. 155 for exactly that reason: the end point of the persecution was not Qincheng, and it was not Xishan — it was the "absolutely no way" list at the door of the Plum Hall at Babaoshan on 15 November 2022. A regime's fear of a dead man of ninety is the most precise available measure of the weight of what that man spent his life saying.

分享本页Share this page

电报Telegram 𝕏 推特𝕏 Twitter 脸书Facebook