EndCCPWorld.com

China: Archive of Communist Crimes & Victims
ARCHIVE / MEMORY / EVIDENCE

让历史被看见
让受害者被铭记
Let History Be Seen
Let Victims Be Remembered

第174案 | 高全福Case 174 | Gao Quanfu

高全福,1957年生,陕西西安人,原西安话剧院公职人员,早年辞职投身福音传播,是西安原锡安山教会与现锡安之光教会的监督和牧师——这间未登记的独立家庭教会历史近四十年,2000年代中期已发展至数百人,靠信徒自愿奉献运转;他力主拍摄《从西安到锡安》《西北灵工团历史》两部福音纪录片,为《牧者联署:为基督信仰的声明》签署人之一;2023年11月29日,锡安山教会遭西安市民政局明文通告取缔,教会改名锡安之光继续聚会;2025年5月16日,他被碑林区兴庆路派出所警方从家中带走,次日多名牧者同工被陆续刑拘,最初罪名均为涉嫌利用迷信破坏法律实施罪,其妻庞羽被监视居住,7月24日八名同工取保释放、只剩他与唐秉义续押;2025年9月,碑林区检察院批捕并将罪名改为诈骗罪,庞羽9月3日被再次逮捕;起诉书(落款2025年12月31日,2026年9月由对华援助公开)指控诈骗奉献款共二千五百五十万元,其中仅二百三十万元对应二百三十五名列名被害人,其余约二千三百二十一万元无对应被害人,仍建议对高全福判处十二至十三年并处罚金;2026年1月9日案件移送碑林区法院后被拆分为三个案件,8月10日庭前会议上家属称检察官多次威胁辩护律师,9月15日唐秉义案庭前会议当天包龙军律师被推出法院、王宇律师手机被没收;11月11日晚,其子高朴在美国代表全体亲友致信最高人民法院院长张军与最高人民检察院检察长应勇控告程序违法;2026年11月12日上午九时三十分,高全福案在碑林区法院第三法庭开庭、庭审约十小时未当庭宣判,法院外数百名警察拦截旁听者,王宇、卢思位、彭永和等律师被带走,卢思位的传唤证记载其九时四十五分到太白路派出所、晚八时五十一分离所;11月17日上午九时三十分,庞羽案在同一法庭开庭,无任何亲属获准旁听、其姐庞辉被挡在门外,未见宣判结果报道;唐秉义案原定11月23日开庭已延期、新期两说并列——截至2026年11月18日,三人仍羁押于西安市碑林区看守所,两案已开庭均未宣判,本案未决。Gao Quanfu, born in 1957 in Xi'an, Shaanxi, a former staff member of the Xi'an Drama Theatre who left public employment for evangelism, is the overseer and pastor of the former Mount Zion Church and the present Light of Zion Church — an unregistered independent house church with a history of nearly forty years that had grown to several hundred members by the mid-2000s and runs on congregants' voluntary offerings. He drove the production of the documentaries From Xi'an to Zion and History of the Northwest Spiritual Workers' Group and signed the Pastors' Joint Statement: A Declaration for the Christian Faith. On 29 November 2023 Mount Zion Church was publicly banned by the Xi'an Civil Affairs Bureau; the congregation renamed itself Light of Zion and kept meeting. On 16 May 2025 police from the Xingqing Road station took him from his home; the next day multiple pastors and co-workers were criminally detained in succession, all initially on suspicion of using superstition to undermine the implementation of the law, while his wife Pang Yu was placed under residential surveillance; on 24 July 2025 eight co-workers were released on bail, leaving only Gao and Tang Bingyi in custody. In September 2025 the Beilin District Procuratorate approved arrests and changed the charge to fraud, and Pang Yu was re-arrested on 3 September. The indictment (dated 31 December 2025, published by ChinaAid in September 2026) alleges fraud totalling RMB 25.5 million in offerings, of which only RMB 2.3 million corresponds to 235 named victims, the remaining roughly RMB 23.21 million having no corresponding victim — yet recommends 12 to 13 years in prison plus a fine for Gao. Transferred to the Beilin District Court on 9 January 2026, the case was split into three separately tried cases; at the 10 August 2026 pretrial conference the family says the prosecutor repeatedly threatened the defence lawyer, and on 15 September 2026, the day of Tang Bingyi's pretrial conference, lawyer Bao Longjun was shoved out of the court and Wang Yu's phone was confiscated. On the evening of 11 November 2026 their son Gao Pu, writing from the United States for the whole family, sent an open letter to Supreme People's Court President Zhang Jun and Procurator-General Ying Yong alleging serious procedural violations. On 12 November 2026 at 9:30 a.m. Gao's case was tried in Courtroom 3 of the Beilin District Court for about ten hours with no verdict announced, while hundreds of police outside blocked observers and lawyers Wang Yu, Lu Siwei and Peng Yonghe were taken away — Lu's summons records his arrival at the Taibai Road police station at 9:45 a.m. and departure at 8:51 p.m. On 17 November 2026 at 9:30 a.m. Pang Yu's case was heard in the same courtroom with no family member allowed to observe — her sister Pang Hui was turned away at the gate — and no verdict had been reported. Tang Bingyi's hearing, set for 23 November, has been postponed, with the new date filed in two versions. As of 18 November 2026 all three remain held at the Beilin District Detention Centre, both completed hearings await verdicts, and the case is undecided.

Time
Gao Quanfu, born in 1957 in Xi'an, Shaanxi, a former staff member of the Xi'an Drama Theatre who left public employment for evangelism, is the overseer and pastor of the former Mount Zion Church and the present Light of Zion Church in Xi'an, a congregation with a history of nearly 40 years that had grown to several hundred members by the mid-2000s. He drove the production of two evangelical documentaries, From Xi'an to Zion (released free online from 2012) and History of the Northwest Spiritual Workers' Group, was one of the second group of signatories to the 2018 Pastors' Joint Statement: A Declaration for the Christian Faith (per ChinaAid's October 2025 report), and in 2021 also signed a pastors' joint statement of the same name with Pastor Wang Yi of Chengdu's Early Rain Covenant Church and others (per Weiquanwang's biographical sketch — the two signing-year accounts are filed in parallel, see Section 14). On 29 November 2023 the Xi'an Civil Affairs Bureau publicly banned Mount Zion Church; the congregation renamed itself Light of Zion Church and continued to meet. On 16 May 2025 police from the Xingqing Road station in Beilin District took Gao from his home; the next day multiple pastors and co-workers were summoned and criminally detained (the headcounts diverge — see Section 4), all initially on suspicion of 'using superstition to undermine the implementation of the law', while his wife Pang Yu was placed under residential surveillance shortly afterwards. On 24 July 2025 eight of the pastors and co-workers were released on bail, leaving only Gao and Tang Bingyi in custody. In September 2025 the Beilin District Procuratorate approved arrests and changed the charge to fraud; Pang Yu was re-arrested on fraud charges on 3 September (per Weiquanwang's sketch of her). The indictment, dated 31 December 2025 (published by ChinaAid in September 2026), alleges fraud totalling RMB 25.5 million in offerings, of which only RMB 2.3 million corresponds to 235 named 'victims', leaving roughly RMB 23.21 million with no corresponding victim. On 9 January 2026 the three-person case was transferred to the Beilin District Court and later split into three separately tried cases. At a pretrial conference on 10 August 2026, family members say the prosecutor repeatedly threatened the defence lawyer. On 15 September 2026, the day of Tang Bingyi's pretrial conference, seven lawyers pressed their complaints at the courthouse entrance; Bao Longjun was shoved out of the court and Wang Yu's phone was confiscated. On the evening of 11 November 2026 their son Gao Pu, writing from the United States on behalf of the whole family, sent an open letter to Supreme People's Court President Zhang Jun and Procurator-General Ying Yong accusing the Beilin procuratorate and court of violating statutory procedure. On Thursday 12 November 2026 at 9:30 a.m., Gao's case was tried in Courtroom 3 of the Beilin District Court; the hearing lasted about ten hours, prosecutors recommended 12 to 13 years in prison plus a fine, and the court announced no verdict. The same day, hundreds of police and plainclothes officers outside blocked observers, and lawyers Wang Yu, Lu Siwei and Peng Yonghe were taken away; Lu's summons records his arrival at the Taibai Road police station at 9:45 a.m. and departure at 8:51 p.m. (HRIC's weekly brief summarises this as about eight hours of questioning; Focus China counts nearly twelve hours from his stop at about 9 a.m. to his release at about 9 p.m. — all three accounts are filed, see Section 9). On Tuesday 17 November 2026 at 9:30 a.m., Pang Yu's case was tried in the same courtroom; no family member was allowed to observe, her sister Pang Hui was turned away at the court gate, and no verdict had been reported as of this site's check on 18 November 2026. Tang Bingyi's trial, originally set for 23 November 2026, has been postponed — ChinaAid's 13 November report says no new date was set, while Focus China on 14 November gave 30 November; both accounts are filed. All three remain held at the Beilin District Detention Centre; the case is undecided.
Place
Xi'an, Shaanxi (the church's city; where Gao was taken, held and tried); the Beilin District Detention Centre, Xi'an (where all three are held — Weiquanwang and the US Commission on International Religious Freedom agree); Courtroom 3 of the Beilin District People's Court (the 12 November 2026 trial of Gao and the 17 November trial of Pang Yu; presiding judge Luo Yixian); the Taibai Road police station, Beilin District (where Lu Siwei was summonsed and questioned on 12 November 2026); the Xingqing Road police station, Beilin District (the station whose officers took Gao on 16 May 2025, per Weiquanwang; ChinaAid's October 2025 report separately says Pang Yu was taken for investigation by the National Security Brigade of the Beilin District Public Security Bureau — both accounts filed); the Xi'an Intermediate People's Court (where the lawyers' team filed complaints on 14 September 2026); Jerusalem (the destination of the documentary From Xi'an to Zion — church-ministry background only)
People
Gao Quanfu (born 1957 in Xi'an; former Xi'an Drama Theatre staff member; overseer and pastor of Mount Zion Church and Light of Zion Church; first defendant); Pang Yu (born 1958; his wife; a church co-worker who for years handled reception, visits and administrative work and never drew a church salary; suffers from heart disease, low blood pressure and severe anxiety; second defendant, tried separately on 17 November 2026); Tang Bingyi (born 8 September 1986 in Huazhou District, Weinan, Shaanxi; a Light of Zion pastor who has preached and done pastoral work since 2010; his wife is Liu Junli and they have one daughter; third defendant); Gao Pu (son of Gao and Pang, living in the United States; speaking publicly since August 2026; on 11 November 2026 he sent the family's open letter to the Supreme People's Court and the Supreme People's Procuratorate); the couple's daughter (her name has no public record; in October 2025 she filed the petition for a review of the necessity of her mother Pang Yu's detention); Pang Hui (Pang Yu's sister, refused entry when she came to observe the 17 November hearing); Jiao Yong, Wang Yibo, Guo Ru, Li Qing, Du Juan and Liu Ce (church pastors and co-workers summoned and detained on 17–19 May 2025, per Weiquanwang's named list; eight co-workers were released on bail on 24 July 2025, but the correspondence between the named list and the bail figure has no complete public record); Wang Yu, Bao Longjun, Jiang Tianyong, Wang Quanzhang, Lu Siwei, Chang Weiping and Peng Yonghe (the lawyers who travelled to Xi'an agencies on 14–15 September 2026 to file complaints and who sought to observe the hearings; Lu Siwei is a disbarred lawyer summonsed on 12 November); Zhang Kai (a member of Pang Yu's legal team; ChinaAid's October 2025 report says police once tried across provinces to obtain his engagement agreement with his client); Xiao Yidan (a defence lawyer whom Focus China says could not take part normally in the 12 November hearing — single-source account); Luo Yixian (presiding judge of the Beilin District Court in this case, per the family letter and defence accounts); Zhao Qian and Zhao Yuying (congregants named in the indictment as 'victims' — Zhao Qian's interview record is said to be missing from Pang Yu's case file, and Zhao Yuying retained her own lawyer to take part in the proceedings; both appear in the family's open letter)
Institutions
Beilin District People's Court, Xi'an (the trial court; neither the 12 November nor the 17 November hearing produced a verdict in court); Beilin District People's Procuratorate, Xi'an (the prosecuting authority; approved the arrests on fraud charges in September 2025; its indictment is dated 31 December 2025 and recommends 12 to 13 years for Gao); the Beilin Branch of the Xi'an Public Security Bureau, its Xingqing Road station and its National Security Brigade (the arresting authorities of May 2025); the Beilin District Detention Centre (place of custody); the Xi'an Civil Affairs Bureau (which publicly banned Mount Zion Church on 29 November 2023); the Taibai Road police station, Beilin District (which summonsed Lu Siwei on 12 November 2026 on suspicion of 'disrupting the work order of a unit'); the Supreme People's Court and the Supreme People's Procuratorate (addressees of the family's open letter of 11 November 2026; no public response as of this check); the US Commission on International Religious Freedom (which has entered Gao Quanfu and Pang Yu separately in its religious prisoners of conscience database, both listed as not released); ChinaAid (which published the indictment and has reported the case continuously; its founder Bob Fu has commented repeatedly); Human Rights in China, HRIC (whose weekly brief carried the 12 November trial and the roughly eight-hour questioning of Lu Siwei); Weiquanwang and the Rights Movement (publishers of the 9, 11, 12 and 17 November bulletins and of the three biographical sketches); Christian Solidarity Worldwide, CSW (this check located no public CSW statement on this case, stated as such)

1. First, the year: this trial happened in 2026, not 2025

The easiest fact to get wrong in this case is the year, so this file fixes it first. Gao Quanfu was taken on 16 May 2025. The charge was changed from 'using superstition to undermine the implementation of the law' to fraud in September 2025. The indictment is dated 31 December 2025. The case was transferred to the court on 9 January 2026. The pretrial conferences fell in August and September 2026. And the Beilin District Court's trial of Gao Quanfu took place on Thursday 12 November 2026 — ChinaAid's report of 13 November 2026, HRIC's subsequent weekly brief and Weiquanwang's bulletins of 9 and 12 November 2026 all agree; no source gives 2025. This site confirms the brief's date of 12 November 2026 as correct. Pang Yu's hearing date needs the same care: Tuesday 17 November 2026, 9:30 a.m., Courtroom 3 of the Beilin District Court, per Weiquanwang's same-day report and overseas relays. The two hearings, five days apart, are the split-case trials of one prosecution, and neither produced a verdict in court.

2. The man: a pastor who came out of the Xi'an Drama Theatre

Gao Quanfu was born in 1957 in Xi'an, Shaanxi. According to the biographical sketch carried by Weiquanwang, he came to Christian faith early, felt called, left his public post at the Xi'an Drama Theatre, and devoted himself to evangelism; through his leadership and the joint work of fellow pastors and co-workers, his church had grown to several hundred members by the mid-2000s. He also founded a company whose business income supported the church's development, missions and the filming of evangelical documentaries. The most prominent items in his public record are two documentaries: From Xi'an to Zion, which records in documentary form his evangelism team's journey from Xi'an to Jerusalem and was released free online from 2012, and History of the Northwest Spiritual Workers' Group, about the group founded in the 1940s to carry the gospel westward — especially into Xinjiang — and about how its members and descendants restored house-church activity after China's reform and opening. Anna Liu of Beijing Zion Church told ChinaAid that Gao was very active in cross-cultural mission work and that the 'Xi'an to Zion' journey he organised drew wide attention in China's Christian community. For years he kept a monthly pastors' fellowship and later organised a pastors' prayer association. His family life, in his son Gao Pu's August 2026 public account, is one of lifelong simplicity. Of his birth month, the details of his ordination and his early years, the public record beyond the sketch says nothing further, and this site states that plainly: no public record.

3. The church: nearly forty years, several hundred people, one ban, a new name

Light of Zion Church began as Xi'an's Mount Zion Church. Sources agree on the length of its history: nearly forty years (multiple ChinaAid reports and Gao Pu's statements concur). It is an unregistered, independent house church, outside the state-sanctioned Three-Self Patriotic Movement, sustained by the voluntary offerings of its congregants — the starting point for understanding everything that follows. Two documented links connect it to the national house-church network. First, Gao was among the second group of signatories to the 2018 Pastors' Joint Statement: A Declaration for the Christian Faith (per ChinaAid's October 2025 report; Weiquanwang's sketch instead dates his joint signing with Wang Yi and others to 2021 — both year accounts are filed in parallel and not merged). Second, co-worker Tang Bingyi spent two years in further study at Beijing Zion Church — a namesake with no organisational affiliation to the Xi'an church, a distinction this file states expressly to prevent confusion. Weiquanwang's sketch says Gao and the church were repeatedly subjected over the years to disruption and admonition by Xi'an police and the city's religious affairs bureau — a summary account whose specific occasions and dates have no public record. USCIRF's database entry likewise says authorities repeatedly harassed Gao for years before his arrest over the church's refusal to register under official oversight. On 29 November 2023 the Xi'an Civil Affairs Bureau publicly banned Mount Zion Church; the congregation then took the name Light of Zion Church and continued to worship and minister. The ban did not end the church, but it pre-wrote the footnote to the criminal case that came eighteen months later: once a group has been administratively banned, none of its subsequent gatherings or collections carries, in the investigators' eyes, the shell of 'lawful religious activity'.

4. 16 May 2025: the arrests of the '5·16 case' and the original charge

On 16 May 2025, police from the Xingqing Road station in Beilin District took Gao Quanfu from his home. The next day, 17 May, multiple pastors and co-workers of the church were summoned and criminally detained in succession. The named lists diverge, and this site files them in parallel. Weiquanwang's three biographical sketches name those summoned on 17 May as Pastor Jiao Yong, Pastor Tang Bingyi, Elder Wang Yibo, Preacher Guo Ru, and two women co-workers, Li Qing and Du Juan — six people, seven with Gao, all criminally detained on suspicion of 'using superstition to undermine the implementation of the law'; on 19 May Preacher Liu Ce was also summoned and detained, bringing the named total to eight. ChinaAid's November 2026 reporting instead says ten further pastors and co-workers were detained the next day, and its October 2025 report says police criminally detained ten people on suspicion of fraud — the totals cannot be reconciled at eight, ten or eleven, so this site takes the named list as its base and files the overall headcount as divergent, not fixed. What can be fixed is the shared node that follows: on 24 July 2025, eight of the pastors and co-workers were released on bail pending trial, after which they continued to face frequent summonses and questioning (per ChinaAid's October 2025 report); only Gao Quanfu and Tang Bingyi remained in custody. Pang Yu's position is recorded separately: she was taken shortly after her husband and transferred to residential surveillance (Weiquanwang's account; ChinaAid's October 2025 report says she was taken for investigation on 16 May itself, together with her husband, by the National Security Brigade of the Beilin District Public Security Bureau — both accounts filed). Under residential surveillance her movements were severely restricted, her identity documents confiscated, and she could not meet or communicate normally with her family. 'Using superstition to undermine the implementation of the law' was the original charge of this sweep — a charge aimed at religious activity itself. It lasted barely three months.

5. September 2025: the charge becomes 'fraud', and the wife is arrested again

In September 2025 the case turned decisively: the Beilin District Procuratorate approved arrests, and the charge was changed from 'using superstition to undermine the implementation of the law' to fraud. The authorities' logic, as relayed by the family and the defence, was to classify the church's years of ordinary tithes, congregants' donations and book-purchase money as 'proceeds of fraud'. The same month, Pang Yu was arrested again: Weiquanwang's sketch of her gives the exact date — on 3 September 2025 Beilin police formally arrested her on suspicion of fraud, the same day the charges against her husband and Tang Bingyi were changed, and the three were made one case. Pang was taken without any prior notice to her family or lawyers. Her daughter then filed a Petition for Review of the Necessity of Detention with the Beilin District Procuratorate, making three arguments: at key stages such as arrest approval the procuratorate had failed, as the law requires, to inform defence counsel and hear their views, and documents the lawyers repeatedly submitted through the '12309' system were all rejected as 'unable to review', with no oral notification either; during residential surveillance Pang's health had deteriorated and she had once suffered sudden cardiac discomfort without timely treatment, so the police's quiet request for arrest approval at that moment looked like an attempt to shift responsibility; and Pang had not fled, colluded or obstructed the investigation, was in poor health and posed no risk of reoffending, so bail or other non-custodial measures would suffice — while the sequence of first converting her status to residential surveillance because the 'detention period had expired' and then re-approving arrest to extend detention contradicted Article 77 of the Criminal Procedure Law (the petition's points as reported by ChinaAid on 2 October 2025; they are the defence side's account and are labelled as such). The outcome of the petition has no public record. Pang Yu never drew a church salary — a fact on which Weiquanwang's sketch and Gao Pu's public statements agree — and it did not keep her out of the 'fraud case'.

6. Anatomy of the indictment: RMB 25.5 million, 235 'victims', and a RMB 23.21 million gap

The whole weight of the substantive dispute in this case rests on one document. In September 2026 ChinaAid published the Beilin District Procuratorate's indictment, dated 31 December 2025. As reported, the indictment alleges that Gao and others fraudulently obtained a total of RMB 25.5 million (about US$3.6 million) in offerings; only RMB 2.3 million of that corresponds to the 235 'victims' named in the indictment, while the remaining roughly RMB 23.21 million has no corresponding victims at all — yet the procuratorate classifies the full amount as proceeds of fraud and on that basis recommends 12 to 13 years in prison plus a fine for Gao. The indictment's characterisation of Gao is that in 2008 he established the 'Zion Light' religious group without government approval, impersonated a religious clerical identity and set up religious venues without authorisation; it alleges that church leaders deceived believers into making offerings and used the money for personal expenses, property purchases and other outlays; the evidence it cites includes bank and payment records, cash ledgers, property documents, witness testimony and victim statements; and the legal basis charged is fraud under Article 266 of the Criminal Law. The family's rebuttal is equally specific. In his public statement of 17 August 2026 Gao Pu pointed out that the RMB 23.21 million discrepancy has no corresponding victims and that 'bank transaction records alone cannot presume fraud'; the offerings were believers' voluntary acts of worship, and some believers listed as 'victims' had expressly said they were not deceived yet remained listed; Gao is no 'fake pastor' as the indictment calls him, but was ordained by the church community and has pastored for decades; and he did not personally control church finances — he received a fixed preaching salary, a dedicated team managed the finances, and major decisions were made by the boards of elders and deacons. This file also fixes a numerical divergence: ChinaAid's report of 21 August 2026 put the disputed funds at 'approximately RMB 2 million' — broadly matching the RMB 2.3 million victim-attributed portion later disclosed with the indictment, evidently a rounded figure for the same layer, and an entirely different number from the RMB 25.5 million charged total; the two must never be conflated. Under the fraud statute, sentencing bands turn on the amount: RMB 25.5 million and RMB 2.3 million are two different sentencing worlds — which is exactly why the family and the defence fight so hard over the victimless RMB 23.21 million.

7. Split into three cases: transfer, severance, and ten months of waiting

On 9 January 2026 the three-person case was transferred by the Beilin District Procuratorate to the Beilin District Court for prosecution review (the family's open letter dates the filing with the court to 31 December 2025 — the nine-day difference evidently reflects the indictment date versus the transfer date, and both are filed). The case was then split into three separately tried cases — one each for Gao Quanfu, Pang Yu and Tang Bingyi, each with its own file. The family's and defence's criticism of the severance runs through the whole case: after Pang Yu's hearing, lawyer Wang Yu stated publicly that the case has profound problems both procedurally and substantively, particularly the court's decision to split co-defendants into separate cases 'solely to facilitate unlawful verdicts' (as relayed by Red Censor); Gao Pu's open letter argues that severance deprived the defendants of access to the complete evidence and left the three files with different materials — the missing Zhao Qian record in Pang's file came to light only because of the split (see Section 8). The case then sat in the court for more than ten months before trial: the family letter says the court delayed the hearing without informing the lawyers of any extension of the trial time limit, and the lawyers' September 2026 complaints allege detention beyond legal limits and breaches of statutory deadlines. The only procedural steps in that period were two rounds of pretrial conferences. On 10 August 2026 the Beilin court held a pretrial conference in Gao's case at which prosecutors first made the 12-to-13-year recommendation explicit; the family says the prosecutor repeatedly threatened Gao's defence attorney during the conference, and the defence objected. In early September it became known that each of the three cases would hold its own pretrial conference, with Tang Bingyi's set for 15 September — the day of the most violent confrontation before trial.

8. Before the trial: complaints, approaches, and the shoving at the courthouse door on 15 September

On 14 September 2026, seven lawyers — Wang Yu, Bao Longjun, Jiang Tianyong, Wang Quanzhang, Lu Siwei, Chang Weiping and Peng Yonghe — together with three Christian clients, visited five government offices in Xi'an, including the Xi'an People's Procuratorate, the Xi'an Intermediate People's Court and the city's petitioning centre, to submit complaints alleging improper case assignments, missed statutory deadlines and detention beyond legal limits, and accusing the Beilin Branch of the Public Security Bureau of having 'manufactured victims in batches' by identifying multiple believers as fraud victims; the team said it would release supporting evidence at an appropriate time. According to the legal team's statement, staff at the petitioning office of the Xi'an Municipal Supervisory Commission refused to accept the materials, citing lack of jurisdiction or the need for evidence of a crime, while procuratorate staff eventually agreed to forward the materials to the procurator-general, who was unavailable in person. On 15 September, the day of Tang Bingyi's pretrial conference, the seven lawyers went to the Beilin District Court to raise concerns about the conference's handling: court officers stopped them at the entrance; Bao Longjun, although he had passed security, was shoved by police and forcibly removed from the courthouse; and when Wang Yu tried to record the officers' conduct on her phone, police confiscated the device. In the discussions that followed, the presiding judge, surnamed Luo, acknowledged that an extension of the proceedings had been approved, but when asked about the failure to notify the defence as the law requires, he reportedly said the court had 'no obligation to notify'. ChinaAid founder Bob Fu commented that the authorities interpret religious offerings as fraud and use tactics such as splitting cases and delaying proceedings to dismantle the organisational networks of underground churches while making legal remedies harder for defendants and families (per ChinaAid's report of 20 October 2026). On 6 November, meeting presiding judge Luo Yixian, the defence discovered that Pang Yu's case file contained no interview record for Zhao Qian, a 'victim' named in the indictment, while the same record appeared in Gao's file; according to the family letter, Luo checked the court's own copy of Pang's file on the spot, confirmed the record was indeed missing, and promised an answer by 9 November — by the afternoon of 11 November the court had given no answer and its phones were said to be unreachable. Also per the letter, when Zhao Yuying — a congregant listed as a 'victim' — learned that victims may instruct lawyers to appear in court, her family urgently retained counsel, whose approaches to the court on 9 and 11 November to file papers, review the files and apply for a postponement met more than ten unanswered phone calls and an office with no one to receive him; and on 10 November the defence learned that the Beilin court had written to the judicial administrative departments where the lawyers practise, asking them to send officials to attend the trial and 'supervise' the lawyers' courtroom conduct.

9. 12 November 2026: a ten-hour trial, and the lawyers taken away outside the court

On Thursday 12 November 2026 at 9:30 a.m., Gao Quanfu's case opened in Courtroom 3 of the Beilin District Court. The defence had applied to postpone the hearing to allow more time to gather evidence; the application was not granted and the trial went ahead. It lasted about ten hours and no verdict was announced. The prosecution's recommendation — 12 to 13 years in prison plus a fine — was stated again in court. Of the debate inside the courtroom, no source discloses any detail, and this site states that plainly: the proceedings inside the hearing have no public record. The day outside the court, by contrast, is comparatively well documented. According to Weiquanwang's on-site reports and ChinaAid's eyewitness accounts, hundreds of uniformed and plainclothes officers were deployed around the courthouse, barring Christians and lawyers who had come to observe; Focus China reported that the roughly thirty observer seats in Courtroom 3 were already occupied by persons already seated, while the lawyers and church members who wished to observe could not get in. At about 9 a.m. that day, lawyers Bao Longjun, Wang Yu, Jiang Tianyong, Peng Yonghe and Lu Siwei were stopped some thirty metres from the court. Wang Yu and Lu Siwei lost contact with the outside world for a time. Wang later said police stopped her for an identity check and took her to the lobby of a nearby building, where she witnessed officers dragging and kicking Lu; police then took her to a station and issued her an administrative summons on suspicion of 'disrupting public order'. Lu Siwei's timeline is finer-grained: stopped at about 9 a.m. some thirty metres from the court and asked for identification, he asked the officers to identify themselves and state their legal basis, an argument followed, and he was taken away; he says an officer struck his lower back and hip with a knee during the removal, causing pain, and that his request for Wang Yu, who was present, to call an ambulance was not dealt with promptly; at 1:20 p.m. he managed to send a brief distress message to a friend saying he was being held at the Taibai Road police station in Beilin District and could not communicate normally; the exiled journalist Su Yutong, based in Germany, checked with the station, and the duty officer confirmed Lu was being questioned but said he did not know Wang Yu's whereabouts. The summons issued by the Taibai Road station, citing suspicion of 'disrupting the work order of a unit', records Lu's arrival at 9:45 a.m. and his departure at 8:51 p.m. — about eleven hours by the summons itself. HRIC's weekly brief summarises the episode as detention for questioning of about eight hours; Focus China counts from the stop at about 9 a.m. to release at about 9 p.m., nearly twelve hours in all. The three figures describe one process from different starting points, and this site files them in parallel: the stop at about 9 a.m., the recorded arrival at 9:45 a.m. and the departure at 8:51 p.m. are mutually consistent fixed points. After his release Lu accused the authorities of fabricating the pretext in order to stop the lawyers observing the trial, and said officers had beaten him while taking him away. Peng Yonghe was also reported taken away by police; the details of his detention and release have not been independently confirmed (per ChinaAid — filed as unverified). The controls of the night before are also on record: according to Focus China, a woman church member in her seventies said that at about 8 p.m. on 11 November some eight people from the police, state security, the street office, the religious-affairs and united-front departments and the neighbourhood committee came to her home and told her plainly not to go to the court the next day, and that when she prepared to leave at 5:30 the next morning, people were already waiting near her home. Defence lawyer Xiao Yidan was said to have been unable to take part normally in that day's hearing (Focus China, single source). As of the reports' publication, neither the Beilin District Court nor the Taibai Road police station had made any public statement about the hearing, the sentencing recommendation or the lawyers taken away.

10. The open letter of 11 November: a son in America writes to the Supreme Court and the Supreme Procuratorate

On the eve of the trial, the evening of 11 November 2026, Gao Pu, the son of Gao Quanfu and Pang Yu, together with the whole family, issued from the United States an open letter to Procurator-General Ying Yong of the Supreme People's Procuratorate and President Zhang Jun of the Supreme People's Court (carried by Weiquanwang on 11 November). The letter alleges that the investigators used threats and inducements to force believers to admit that their offerings to the church were defrauded property; that a single joint case was artificially split into three cases with separately manufactured file materials; that at the prosecution-review stage the procuratorate failed to question the 'victims' as required and accepted the police's views wholesale; that after indictment the court delayed the trial for a long period without informing the lawyers of any extension of the time limit; that the procuratorate had not prepared the list of victims with contact details as required, and when the lawyers asked the court to press for it, the presiding judge replied only orally that the victims recognised by the procuratorate were the 235 named in the audit report; and the specific episodes of the missing Zhao Qian record, the obstructed filing by Zhao Yuying's counsel, and the court's letters asking justice bureaus to 'supervise' the lawyers (details in Section 8, all from the letter). The letter asks the Supreme People's Court and the Supreme People's Procuratorate to intervene urgently and investigate. This site's characterisation of the letter is stated as usual: everything in it is the family's account, not independently verified by this site — but the procedural nodes it names, the severance, the sentencing recommendation, the 235 victims and the Zhao Qian record, can be read against the published indictment and the defence team's other public statements. Gao Pu's public voice is not confined to this letter: on 10 August 2026, the day of the pretrial conference, he posted that the authorities' treatment of his elderly parents was unconscionable and inhumane; on 17 August he issued his statement on the victimless RMB 23.21 million; and after the indictment was published in September he wrote that it labels his father a 'fake pastor' and treats nearly twenty years of church offerings as fraudulent funds, calling the treatment 'utterly malicious'. As of this site's check, any public response to the letter from the Supreme People's Court or the Supreme People's Procuratorate has no public record.

11. Pang Yu: a defendant who never drew a church salary, and the 17 November hearing with no family in it

Pang Yu was born in 1958 and is nearly seventy. Her role in the church, per Weiquanwang's sketch, was years of assisting with hospitality, reception, visits and administrative work; Gao Pu's account adds that she volunteered cooking meals and caring for church members. Her temperament is described as quiet and steady. She never drew a church salary — a fact attested both by Weiquanwang's sketch and by Gao Pu's public statements — yet she was placed in the fraud case all the same: residential surveillance in May 2025, formal arrest on 3 September 2025, and custody at the Beilin District Detention Centre ever since. Her health is the family's sharpest anxiety: she suffers from heart disease, low blood pressure and severe anxiety; her children have repeatedly reported that in detention she lacks effective medication for her heart condition, often suffers severe pain during night duty, to the point of affecting her basic daily life; and during residential surveillance she once suffered sudden cardiac discomfort without receiving timely treatment (per ChinaAid's October 2025 report). From October 2025 onward the defence has sought bail for medical treatment and a review of the necessity of her detention; applications were still being pursued before the November 2026 hearings, and their outcome has no public record. Two further claims come from church sources relayed by overseas media (TNT Times, 18 November 2026 — a single relayed source, filed as such): that the pretrial conference scheduled for Pang Yu's case was never held, the court having first contacted the lawyers to arrange one and then abruptly cancelled it; and that Pang took no part in the church's governance, with 80 to 90 percent of the amount she is accused over said to be lawyers' fees paid from church offerings. If that second claim holds, the bulk of the sum a salary-less, non-governing pastor's wife is accused of 'defrauding' would be the fees the church paid to defend this very case — this site cannot verify the proportion independently and files it as a relayed account. On Tuesday 17 November 2026 at 9:30 a.m., Pang Yu's case was heard in Courtroom 3 of the Beilin District Court. According to Weiquanwang's same-day report, no family member at all was allowed to observe: her sister Pang Hui came to observe and was turned away at the court gate, the judge explaining that Pang Yu's son was not in China and that others did not qualify; Weiquanwang notes that a sister is a close relative under the law and that the rules require close relatives to be given priority for observer seats. According to overseas relays, Jiang Tianyong and Peng Yonghe had applied in writing on 16 November to observe and were still blocked by police outside the court on the 17th, Jiang being taken away by plainclothes officers and stability-maintenance personnel from Henan; Jiang said a court officer with badge number 610187 refused him entry for lacking a hearing pass, while others were admitted without issue. Of the proceedings and outcome of Pang Yu's hearing, nothing had been reported as of this site's check: no verdict, and no public record of the hearing's length or argument — stated as such.

12. Tang Bingyi: the third defendant, in a forty-square-metre public-rental flat

Tang Bingyi was born on 8 September 1986 in Huazhou District, Weinan, Shaanxi, into an ordinary farming family in which both parents were Christians. After high school he was admitted to a second-tier university but left after one year, for family finances and his own direction, to work; Gao Quanfu then introduced him to three years of systematic theological training in Xi'an, and from 2010 he took up preaching, pastoral care and visiting work in the church, later spending two further years studying at Beijing Zion Church before returning to Xi'an to serve. In 2018 he married a Christian woman, Liu Junli, and they have one daughter. His wife worked for a local bus company and was later laid off when the company ran into difficulties; the family of three lives in Xi'an in a forty-square-metre public-rental flat and gets about on a two-wheeled electric scooter; Tang's personal income was for a long time only RMB 350 to 800 a month, and only rose to RMB 3,800 shortly before his arrest in 2025 (all of these family-circumstance details come from Weiquanwang's sketch of Tang, the church and family's account, filed as given). A man accused of taking part in a 'fraud' of RMB 25.5 million, whose monthly income began at RMB 350 and who lives in a forty-square-metre rental flat — the tension between those figures and the indictment's total is material this file places before the reader to judge, setting both sides down on paper. Tang has been in custody since he was taken on 17 May 2025, one of only two men left inside when the eight were bailed on 24 July. The 15 September 2026 pretrial conference was his case's conference — the very day the lawyers' team was shoved and had a phone confiscated at the courthouse door. His trial was originally scheduled for 23 November 2026 and has been postponed: ChinaAid's report of 13 November says it was postponed with no new date, while Focus China's report of 14 November gives a rescheduled date of 30 November. Both accounts are filed in parallel; as of this site's check no later report settles the point, and this site does not fix it.

13. The international record: a prisoners-of-conscience database, a weekly brief, continuing coverage — and official silence throughout

The international record of this case, as of 18 November 2026, can be fixed at four levels. First, official listing: the US Commission on International Religious Freedom has entered Gao Quanfu and Pang Yu separately in its religious prisoners of conscience database, both with the status 'not released'; the Gao entry records his arrest at home in May 2025, the initial charge of 'using superstition to undermine law enforcement', his confinement in the Beilin District Detention Centre and the denial of due process, and the Pang entry records her arrest in September 2025 on charges built on the church's collection of voluntary tithes. Second, human-rights digest coverage: Human Rights in China's weekly brief summarised the 12 November trial, the 12-to-13-year recommendation, the roughly ten-hour hearing with no verdict, and Lu Siwei's roughly eight hours of questioning, noting that the use of fraud charges allows the authorities to prosecute independent religious activity as a financial crime without explicitly confronting religious freedom. Third, sustained tracking: ChinaAid has reported the case in a series since October 2025 — the daughter's detention-necessity petition, the publication of the indictment, the pretrial-conference confrontation, the hearing arrangements, and the lawyers taken away on trial day, at least six reports — with founder Bob Fu repeatedly characterising the case as criminalising 'the basic life of the church itself' and setting a dangerous precedent for other unregistered churches, calling for continued international scrutiny and for the three defendants' access to counsel and appropriate medical care. Fourth, relay coverage by church and overseas Christian media (ingrace, Focus China, Red Censor, TNT Times) of the details outside the courtroom. This site also records two blanks honestly: no public statement by Christian Solidarity Worldwide on this case was located in this check — no public record to cite; and no Chinese official body — the Beilin District Court, the Beilin District Procuratorate, Xi'an public security or the Taibai Road police station — has made any public statement on the trial, the sentencing recommendation, the lawyers taken away or the family barred from observing, as of this check: no public record. Nor is this case isolated: in the same reporting, ChinaAid set alongside it the case of four Christians of a house church in Kaili, Guizhou, charged with fraud and other offences over activities including Sunday school, whose case has reached the court — noting that fraud prosecutions over offerings against unregistered-church pastors have appeared in multiple places in recent years. That is background context, filed as a juxtaposition only; this file does not develop other cases.

14. Filed in parallel: divergences between sources and unverified items

First, the trial year: this check's conclusion is 12 November 2026 for Gao's trial and 17 November 2026 for Pang Yu's, consistent across ChinaAid, Weiquanwang and HRIC; the commissioning brief's dates are correct. Second, the May 2025 headcount: Weiquanwang's named list gives Gao plus six people on 17 May and Liu Ce on 19 May, eight named in total, while ChinaAid's accounts speak of ten further co-workers detained the next day and of ten people criminally detained, and the 'eight released on bail' of 24 July cannot be fully matched to the named list — the total is filed as divergent. Third, when and by whom Pang Yu was first taken: Weiquanwang says shortly after her husband, into residential surveillance; ChinaAid's October 2025 report says she was taken on 16 May itself, with her husband, by the National Security Brigade of the Beilin Public Security Bureau — both filed. Fourth, the date of Pang's re-arrest: most sources give September 2025 by month; Weiquanwang's sketch of her gives 3 September, which this file adopts as the specific account with its source named. Fifth, the layers of the amount: a charged total of RMB 25.5 million, of which RMB 2.3 million corresponds to 235 victims and roughly RMB 23.21 million has no corresponding victim (per the indictment as published by ChinaAid in September 2026); ChinaAid's August 2026 figure of 'approximately RMB 2 million' evidently rounds the victim-attributed layer, and the two layers must not be conflated. Sixth, the transfer date: most sources give 9 January 2026 for the transfer for prosecution review, the family letter dates the filing with the court to 31 December 2025 — nine days apart, evidently the indictment date versus the transfer, both filed. Seventh, the length of Lu Siwei's control on 12 November: the summons records arrival at 9:45 a.m. and departure at 8:51 p.m., about eleven hours; HRIC's brief summarises about eight hours of questioning; Focus China counts nearly twelve hours from the stop at about 9 a.m. to release at about 9 p.m. — all three filed, the fixed time points being mutually consistent. Eighth, Tang Bingyi's hearing date: ChinaAid says postponed with no new date, Focus China gives 30 November — filed in parallel, pending verification. Ninth, the year Gao signed the pastors' joint statement: ChinaAid makes him a second-batch signatory of the 2018 statement, Weiquanwang's sketch dates a joint signing with Wang Yi and others to 2021 — both filed. Tenth, the episodes of Peng Yonghe being taken away on 12 November, Xiao Yidan's inability to attend, the claim that 80 to 90 percent of the sum attributed to Pang Yu was lawyers' fees, and the visit to the elderly congregant's home are each single-source or party accounts, labelled where they appear and not independently verified by this site. Eleventh, the internal argument of Gao's 12 November hearing and of Pang Yu's 17 November hearing, and the latter's length, have no public record. Twelfth, Gao's birth month, the details of his ordination, any specific record of the church's earlier disruptions, and the daughter's name and present situation have no public record, and this site does not fill them in.

15. Complete timeline

1957: Gao Quanfu is born in Xi'an, Shaanxi; he works at the Xi'an Drama Theatre and later leaves public employment for evangelism. By the mid-2000s the church he leads has grown to several hundred members, and he founds a company to support the church and documentary work. 2008: the indictment alleges he established a religious group without approval in this year (the prosecution's account). 2012: From Xi'an to Zion begins free online release; he later also drives the production of History of the Northwest Spiritual Workers' Group. 2018: he is among the second batch of signatories to the Pastors' Joint Statement: A Declaration for the Christian Faith (ChinaAid's account; Weiquanwang separately gives a 2021 joint signing — both filed). 29 November 2023: the Xi'an Civil Affairs Bureau publicly bans Mount Zion Church; the church renames itself Light of Zion Church and continues to meet. 16 May 2025: Gao is taken from his home by Xingqing Road station police; Pang Yu is taken shortly afterwards into residential surveillance. 17 May 2025: Jiao Yong, Tang Bingyi, Wang Yibo, Guo Ru, Li Qing, Du Juan and other co-workers are summoned and criminally detained in succession; on 19 May Liu Ce is detained; the initial charge in every case is suspicion of using superstition to undermine the implementation of the law. 24 July 2025: eight pastors and co-workers are released on bail; Gao and Tang remain in custody. 3 September 2025: Pang Yu is formally arrested on fraud charges (per Weiquanwang's sketch of her); the same month the Beilin District Procuratorate approves arrests and changes the whole case's charge to fraud. 2 October 2025: ChinaAid reports the daughter's petition for a review of the necessity of Pang Yu's detention. 31 December 2025: the indictment is dated (per ChinaAid's publication), alleging fraud of RMB 25.5 million and recommending 12 to 13 years for Gao. 9 January 2026: the three-person case is transferred to the Beilin District Court and later split into three cases. 10 August 2026: pretrial conference in Gao's case; the family says the prosecutor repeatedly threatened the defence lawyer; Gao Pu speaks publicly the same day. 17 August 2026: Gao Pu issues his statement on the RMB 23.21 million with no corresponding victims. 21 August 2026: ChinaAid reports the three facing heavy sentences, with the disputed funds put at approximately RMB 2 million in that report's layer of the figures. 14 September 2026: seven lawyers file complaints at five Xi'an agencies. 15 September 2026: pretrial conference in Tang Bingyi's case; Bao Longjun is shoved out of the court and Wang Yu's phone is confiscated. September 2026: ChinaAid publishes the indictment's main points. 20 October 2026: ChinaAid reports the 15 September confrontation in detail. 6 November 2026: meeting judge Luo Yixian, the defence finds the Zhao Qian record missing from Pang Yu's file. 9 November 2026: Weiquanwang bulletins the three hearing dates. 10 November 2026: the defence learns the court has written to justice bureaus to send officials to supervise the lawyers. 11 November 2026: ChinaAid reports the hearing arrangements, the sentencing recommendation and the defence's postponement application; that evening Gao Pu issues the family's open letter to Zhang Jun and Ying Yong; that evening, personnel from multiple departments visit an elderly congregant's home to tell her not to go to court the next day (Focus China's account). 12 November 2026, 9:30 a.m.: Gao's case is tried in Courtroom 3 of the Beilin District Court; the hearing lasts about ten hours with no verdict; prosecutors recommend 12 to 13 years plus a fine. The same day from about 9 a.m., lawyers Wang Yu, Lu Siwei, Peng Yonghe and others are intercepted and taken away outside the court; Lu's summons records arrival at the Taibai Road station at 9:45 a.m. and departure at 8:51 p.m.; Wang Yu receives an administrative summons on suspicion of disrupting public order. 13 November 2026: ChinaAid reports the trial and the lawyers' detention in full. 17 November 2026, 9:30 a.m.: Pang Yu's case is heard in Courtroom 3; no family member is allowed to observe and her sister Pang Hui is turned away at the gate; Jiang Tianyong and Peng Yonghe are blocked; no verdict had been reported as of publication. 23 November 2026: Tang Bingyi's original hearing date (postponed; the new date is filed in two versions — unset / 30 November). 18 November 2026: this site's check — all three remain held at the Beilin District Detention Centre; both completed hearings await verdicts; the case is undecided.

16. Latest status: two hearings held, no verdicts, all three still in the detention centre

As of this site's check on 18 November 2026, the latest verifiable status of the Gao Quanfu case is as follows. Gao Quanfu, Pang Yu and Tang Bingyi are all held at the Beilin District Detention Centre in Xi'an, and USCIRF's database lists both Gao and Pang as not released. Procedurally: Gao's first-instance trial was completed on 12 November 2026 with no verdict announced and a prosecution recommendation of 12 to 13 years plus a fine; the date of judgment has no public information. Pang Yu's case was heard on 17 November with no verdict reported, and the outcome of her applications for medical bail has no public record. Tang Bingyi's hearing has been postponed, with the new date filed in two irreconcilable versions. The three have been in custody since May 2025 — more than eighteen months, with Pang's period including a phase of residential surveillance. On that basis this site classifies the case as ongoing in the category 'in custody, tried and awaiting verdict': the defendants remain detained, no judgment has been issued, and the third defendant's hearing has not yet taken place. This site draws no inference about the verdicts from any silence. The case is not closed.

17. Verification and sources

The sources actually consulted in this check are as follows. First tier — party documents and official-system records: the main points of the Beilin District Procuratorate's indictment, published by ChinaAid on 14 September 2026 (the charged total of RMB 25.5 million, the RMB 2.3 million corresponding to 235 victims, the roughly RMB 23.21 million with no corresponding victims, the allegations of establishing a group without approval in 2008 and impersonating clergy, Article 266 of the Criminal Law, the recommendation of 12 to 13 years plus a fine, and the indictment date of 31 December 2025 all come from there); the USCIRF religious prisoners of conscience database entries for Gao Quanfu and Pang Yu, read in the original (the May and September 2025 detention dates, custody at the Beilin District Detention Centre and the not-released status come from there); and the Taibai Road station's summons record for Lu Siwei, as relayed by ChinaAid's report of 13 November 2026 (the ground of 'suspected disruption of the work order of a unit', arrival at 9:45 a.m. and departure at 8:51 p.m. come from there). Second tier — human-rights and religious-freedom organisations: ChinaAid's report of 12 October 2025 (the three arguments of the detention-necessity petition, the residential-surveillance details, the church's forty years and several hundred members in the 2000s, the 2018 second-batch signature, and Gao's remark that 'imprisonment is a required course for being a pastor' come from there); its report of 21 August 2026 (the 10 August pretrial conference, the family account of the prosecutor threatening the lawyer, the approximately RMB 2 million layer of the figures, and Gao Pu's 10 August post); its report of 14 September 2026 (the indictment's publication and the family's rebuttal, Gao Pu's 17 August statement, the church's financial-division account); its report of 20 October 2026 (the 14 September complaints at five agencies, the 15 September shoving of Bao Longjun and confiscation of Wang Yu's phone, Judge Luo's reported 'no obligation to notify', and Bob Fu's comments); its report of 11 November 2026 (the 12 and 17 November hearing dates, the sentencing recommendation, the defence's postponement application, Pang Yu's health and bail application, and the church's account of more than 200 congregants induced to give statements); its report of 13 November 2026 (the ten-hour hearing with no verdict, the hundreds of police, the details of Wang Yu and Lu Siwei being taken away, the missing Zhao Qian record and the judge's promised answer, the obstruction of Zhao Yuying's counsel, and the court's letters to supervise the lawyers); and HRIC's weekly brief (the summary of the 12 November trial and the roughly eight-hour questioning of Lu Siwei). Third tier — Chinese human-rights information and party reporting: Weiquanwang's bulletin of 9 November 2026 and its three biographical sketches, carried by the Rights Movement (Gao's Drama Theatre background and the two documentaries, Pang Yu's birth year of 1958 and her never having drawn a salary, her re-arrest on 3 September 2025, Tang Bingyi's birth on 8 September 1986 in Huazhou and his family's economic circumstances, the named list of those detained including Liu Ce on 19 May, the eight released on bail on 24 July, and the ban notice of 29 November 2023 all come from there); the full points of Gao Pu's open letter as carried by Weiquanwang on 11 November; Weiquanwang's trial bulletin of 12 November; and its report of 17 November on Pang Yu's hearing (no family admitted, Pang Hui refused); ingrace's report of 12 November 2026 (the lawyers stopped thirty metres from the court, Lu's 1:20 p.m. distress message, Su Yutong's verification); Focus China's report of 14 November 2026 (Lu's account of the stop and the knee strike, the summons issued only after 4 p.m., the nearly twelve-hour whole process, the thirty observer seats in Courtroom 3, the visit to the elderly congregant's home, and the 30 November date for Tang Bingyi); Red Censor's report of 17 November 2026 (Pang Yu's hearing, Jiang Tianyong's and Peng Yonghe's written application of 16 November refused, court officer badge number 610187, and Wang Yu's comment); and TNT Times' article of 18 November 2026 relaying church sources (the cancelled pretrial conference in Pang's case and the claim that 80 to 90 percent of her attributed sum was lawyers' fees — a single relayed source, labelled as such). Fourth tier — not located: no public CSW statement on this case was found in this check, and no public statement by any Chinese official body on the trial or the related allegations was seen. The check's conclusion on the official Chinese position: no public record. The image check is recorded in the metadata.

18. Our Take

What most deserves fixing in the Gao Quanfu case is a structure of numbers. Of the RMB 25.5 million charged total, only RMB 2.3 million can be matched to 235 named 'victims'; the remaining RMB 23.21 million — over ninety percent of the total — has not a single named person who was deceived. Yet the sentencing recommendation, calculated on the full amount, runs to twelve to thirteen years. This is not a flaw in the detail of the evidence; it is the character of the case itself. What has been placed inside the frame of 'fraud' is not one specific swindle but the offering ledger of this church across nearly twenty years — money believers voluntarily put in the offering box, money spent on spiritual books, and, if the account of the fees share in Pang Yu's attributed sum holds, even the money the church paid to hire lawyers for these very defendants. So long as the congregation is an unapproved group, every entry can afterwards be renamed proceeds of crime. The charge's own trajectory spells this out: when the arrests were made in May 2025 the charge was still 'using superstition to undermine the implementation of the law' — a charge that at least admitted this was a religious case. Four months later it became 'fraud', and religion vanished, leaving only a group of 'fake pastors' and a bank ledger. By handling a religious case in the shell of a financial crime, the authorities need neither discuss freedom of belief in court nor explain to anyone why a church that existed for nearly forty years, sustained by the voluntary offerings of several hundred believers, became a fraud ring overnight. And the arrangements on the trial day are the footnote outside the courtroom: at a nominally public hearing, hundreds of police stood outside the court, the observer seats in Courtroom 3 were filled by persons of unknown origin, the lawyers who came to observe were taken away thirty metres out and summonsed for the better part of twelve hours, and when the defendant's wife was tried five days later, even her own sister was kept outside the gate. A court confident of its verdict does not need to hold a hearing this way. This site fixes the case here: Gao Quanfu is sixty-nine; his wife is nearly seventy and waits in a detention centre with a heart condition; his co-worker lives in a forty-square-metre rental flat on an income that began at RMB 350 a month. If this is the fraud ring the prosecution describes, then what its RMB 25.5 million finally bought was three elderly and poor defendants in the Beilin District Detention Centre, waiting for a judgment that has not yet been written.

分享本页Share this page

电报Telegram 𝕏 推特𝕏 Twitter 脸书Facebook