EndCCPWorld.com

中国共产主义历史罪证与受害者记录
China: Archive of Communist Crimes & Victims
ARCHIVE / MEMORY / EVIDENCE

让历史被看见
让受害者被铭记
Let History Be Seen
Let Victims Be Remembered

The European Parliament's Hong Kong Resolutions, 8 July 2021 to 28 November 2024: Five Texts Demanding Jimmy Lai's Release and Sanctions the Council Never Imposed

This page records in full the five Hong Kong resolutions adopted by the European Parliament between 8 July 2021 and 28 November 2024, from the forced closure of Apple Daily to the sentencing of 45 defendants in the pro-democracy 47-person case, as Parliament repeatedly demanded repeal of the National Security Law, the release of Jimmy Lai and other detainees, and sanctions on responsible officials, while the EU Council has never imposed the sanctions Parliament demanded.

International Official Record · European Parliament Resolutions on Hong KongDate: 8 July 2021 to 28 November 2024, European Parliament plenary sessions, Strasbourg and BrusselsResult: five resolutions adopted; the sanctions on Hong Kong and mainland officials demanded by Parliament have never been imposed by the EU Council

1. Introduction: one parliament, five resolutions and a demand never carried out

Since the Law of the People's Republic of China on Safeguarding National Security in the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region was imposed on Hong Kong in 2020, the European Parliament has adopted Hong Kong resolutions in almost every session period. This page selects five of them with clearly identifiable procedural markers and builds a continuous record: the resolution of 8 July 2021 on Hong Kong, notably the case of Apple Daily; the resolution of 20 January 2022 on violations of fundamental freedoms in Hong Kong; the resolution of 15 June 2023 on the deterioration of fundamental freedoms in Hong Kong, notably the case of Jimmy Lai; the resolution of 25 April 2024 on the new security law in Hong Kong and the cases of Li Yuxuan and Chen Zihua; and the resolution of 28 November 2024 on Hong Kong, notably the cases of Jimmy Lai and the 45 activists convicted under the National Security Law. The five texts span three years and four months. Their subject matter runs from the death of a single newspaper to the sentencing in a mass trial, and together they form the European legislature's running official record of the year-by-year deterioration of freedom in Hong Kong.

Before reading further, the legal character of these documents must be stated plainly. Urgency and topical resolutions of the European Parliament are political statements of position. They are not legally binding. They cannot sanction anyone directly, repeal any law, or order the Council of the European Union or member state governments to act. Their force lies in record and pressure: they write Parliament's judgement into the formal archive of the EU institutions and address precise demands to the Council, which holds the actual power over sanctions and foreign policy decisions. For that reason this page records not only what each resolution says but also what became of its demands. One demand recurs across all five texts: that the EU's Global Human Rights Sanctions Regime be used against responsible Hong Kong and mainland officials. As of this page's latest review in November 2026, the Council has never sanctioned a Hong Kong official at Parliament's request. Parliament demanded repeatedly; the Council never acted. That gap is as much a part of the archive as the resolution texts themselves, and this page records both side by side rather than allowing an adopted resolution to be mistaken for an implemented sanction.

The factual basis of this page is the resolution texts and procedural records published by the European Parliament, including the procedure number of the 2021 resolution and the adopted-text number of the November 2024 resolution, together with the public record of the Hong Kong events to which the resolutions respond. Where the verified material before this page does not give a roll-call vote figure, none is invented. Where a resolution's language is a political judgement, it is identified as Parliament's position, not as a judicial finding. The reactions of the Chinese and Hong Kong authorities to each resolution are also recorded, so that readers can see the same events in the competing narratives that surround them.

2. Background: the dismantling of Hong Kong civil society under the National Security Law

The five resolutions cannot be understood without the process they answer. After the National Security Law was imposed in 2020, Hong Kong's civil society, independent media and pro-democracy political forces were dismantled in a systematic sequence over several years. The names that recur in the resolution texts trace that curve: the Hong Kong Confederation of Trade Unions, the city's large pro-democracy union federation, disbanded; the Civil Human Rights Front, which had organised the annual marches and assemblies, disbanded; the Hong Kong Alliance in Support of Patriotic Democratic Movements of China, which had organised the annual candlelight vigil commemorating 4 June, disbanded. In the media sphere, Apple Daily was forced to close after its assets were frozen and its journalists arrested, and Stand News ceased operations after its newsroom was raided. Figures once active in the streets and the legislature were arrested, held on remand, or sentenced.

The case of Jimmy Lai runs through the second half of the sequence. Lai, the founder of Apple Daily, is named individually in the resolutions of 2023 and 2024. The concerns Parliament placed on record include the fairness of his trial and the obstruction of his choice of overseas counsel, after the British King's Counsel Timothy Owen was barred from representing him. By the time of the November 2024 resolution, Parliament further recorded that Lai was elderly and in deteriorating health, held in solitary confinement, denied religious rights including the right to receive communion, and denied the counsel of his choice. These specific allegations are recorded here in the terms of the resolution texts and identified as Parliament's stated position; they are not presented as facts established by a court.

In 2024 the legal environment tightened further. The Safeguarding National Security Ordinance, enacted under Article 23 of the Basic Law, entered into force on 23 March 2024 and now operates alongside the 2020 National Security Law. In its April resolution that year, Parliament held that the two laws breach international obligations including the Sino-British Joint Declaration. On 19 November 2024 the Hong Kong 47 case reached sentencing: 45 defendants were jailed, with Benny Tai receiving ten years. Nine days later the European Parliament adopted the fifth resolution recorded on this page. This interlocking of dates is the skeleton of the page's timeline: each landmark tightening in Hong Kong is answered by a corresponding record in Strasbourg, and the two lines index each other.

3. The resolution of 8 July 2021: Apple Daily and the first named call for sanctions

The first resolution was adopted on 8 July 2021 under the title Hong Kong, notably the case of Apple Daily, procedure number 2021/2786(RSP). The vote was 578 in favour, 29 against and 73 abstentions, an overwhelming majority in plenary. Its immediate trigger was the forced closure of Apple Daily after its assets were frozen and a number of its journalists and executives arrested: a newspaper with a mass readership was put out of business not through any closure hearing or judicial liquidation but because its funds were frozen and it could no longer operate. The resolution condemned in the strongest terms the forced closure of Apple Daily, the freezing of its assets and the arrest of its journalists, demanded that the Hong Kong authorities stop harassing journalists, and demanded the release of those arbitrarily detained.

The resolution set out the three core demands that the following four texts would repeat. First, it demanded that Beijing repeal the National Security Law, locating the problem in the law itself rather than in the enforcement of individual cases. Second, it named officials for sanctions, including the then Chief Executive Carrie Lam, John Lee, Teresa Cheng and Chris Tang, together with mainland officials responsible for Hong Kong affairs including Xia Baolong and Luo Huining. Naming names turned the text from a general statement into a pressure document with a specific list attached, even though whether that list ever becomes a Council sanctions decision rests with the Council and not with Parliament. Third, it called on EU member states to provide lifeboat arrangements for Hong Kongers and to boycott the Beijing Winter Olympics diplomatically. Those calls were likewise non-binding; whether and how far member states followed them was a matter for each government, and the public record shows no unified EU-level implementation scheme, a point this page states plainly.

The historical place of the July 2021 text is that it fixed the template for Parliament's Hong Kong resolutions: condemn a specific event, demand the release of specific people, name specific officials for sanctions, and demand repeal of the National Security Law. Every resolution of the following four years added new events and new names to that template. A template that does not change while the events keep coming is itself a form of record: in Parliament's judgement Hong Kong's condition was not a single shock but a continuing deterioration. And the Council's four years of non-response to the same repeated template has been fixed by the same record just as firmly.

4. The resolutions of 20 January 2022 and 15 June 2023: from civil society's collapse to the case of Jimmy Lai

The second resolution was adopted on 20 January 2022 under the title Violations of fundamental freedoms in Hong Kong. By then the dismantling had spread from the media to the organisational layer: the Confederation of Trade Unions, the Civil Human Rights Front and the Hong Kong Alliance had all disbanded, and the resolution condemned the dismantling of civil society under the National Security Law and recorded the raid and closure of Stand News and arrests including that of Gwyneth Ho. It named the case of Jimmy Lai again and demanded releases. Where the 2021 text had centred on the fate of one newspaper, by early 2022 Parliament's record covered the organisational ecology of an entire civil society, with unions, movement coalitions, a memorial organisation and independent media listed in a single text as a structural picture. The verified material underlying this page does not state the roll-call figures for this resolution, and none are invented here; only its adoption and content are recorded.

The third resolution was adopted on 15 June 2023 under the title The deterioration of fundamental freedoms in Hong Kong, notably the case of Jimmy Lai, procedure number 2023/2737(RSP). The word notably in the title marks the elevation of Lai's case from one file among many to the central individual case of Parliament's Hong Kong position. The resolution demanded Lai's immediate and unconditional release, condemned the unfairness of National Security Law trials, and recorded the specific fact that his chosen overseas counsel had been excluded: the British lawyer Timothy Owen was barred from representing him. Whether a defendant may be represented by counsel of his own choosing is among the most basic procedural indicators of a fair trial, and by writing that detail into the text Parliament moved the dispute over Hong Kong's judiciary from the political level down to the procedural level. The verified material underlying this page likewise does not state roll-call figures for this resolution, and this page records that absence honestly rather than filling it with numbers borrowed from other votes.

Read together, the resolutions of 2022 and 2023 show Parliament's focus both narrowing and deepening. It narrowed as attention converged on Jimmy Lai alone, because a named, elderly detainee whose case drags on is the most legible anchor for cross-border pressure and public attention. It deepened as the allegations moved from releasing journalists and ending harassment to the fairness of the trial process itself and the denial of chosen counsel. That shift foreshadowed the drafting of 2024: after sentence was passed in the 47 case, Parliament would have to answer a mass sentencing while holding on to Lai as its central case, and the two lines converge in the resolution of November 2024.

5. The two resolutions of 2024: the Article 23 law and sentencing in the 47 case

The fourth resolution was adopted on 25 April 2024 in direct response to the entry into force of the Safeguarding National Security Ordinance, the local legislation enacted under Article 23 of the Basic Law, which took effect on 23 March 2024. Titled The new security law in Hong Kong and the cases of Li Yuxuan and Chen Zihua, the resolution held that the 2020 National Security Law and the Article 23 ordinance breach international obligations including the Sino-British Joint Declaration, demanded the release of Jimmy Lai and others, and called on the Council to sanction officials including John Lee under the Global Human Rights Sanctions Regime. The resolution was adopted by a show of hands; a show-of-hands vote produces no roll-call figures, and this page records that fact rather than inventing numbers. The legal judgement in the text is unambiguous: the problem, in Parliament's stated position, lies not only in enforcement but in the conflict between the two laws themselves and Hong Kong's international obligations. The Chinese and Hong Kong authorities hold the opposite position, which is recorded in the reactions section below.

The fifth resolution was adopted on 28 November 2024 under the title Hong Kong, notably the cases of Jimmy Lai and the 45 activists convicted under the National Security Law, adopted text TA-10-2024-0051. The vote was 473 in favour, 23 against and 98 abstentions. Its immediate background was the sentencing nine days earlier, on 19 November 2024, when 45 defendants in the pro-democracy 47 case were jailed and Benny Tai received ten years. The resolution demanded the immediate and unconditional release of all pro-democracy politicians, activists and journalists sentenced under the National Security Law, including Jimmy Lai and Chung Pui-kuen, the dropping of all charges, the repeal of both the National Security Law and the Safeguarding National Security Ordinance, and it called on the Council to review its 2020 conclusions on Hong Kong and to sanction the Hong Kong and mainland officials responsible.

The November 2024 text contains the most specific description of Jimmy Lai's situation in any of the five resolutions. Parliament recorded that Lai was being tried on fabricated charges, that he was elderly and in deteriorating health, held in solitary confinement, denied religious rights including receiving communion, and denied counsel of his choice. The phrase fabricated charges is the resolution's own wording and is relayed here as the position of a political body, not as the judgement of a court. The voting figures, 473 to 23, show that even after the 2024 European elections the majority position of the newly composed Parliament on Hong Kong had not changed. With that, the sequence recorded on this page is complete: from 578 votes to 473, the majority in favour was always overwhelming, and the Council sanctions decision always absent.

6. Reactions and the implementation gap: three records from Parliament, Council and Beijing

The reactions of the Chinese government and the Hong Kong authorities to successive resolutions follow a fixed formula: the resolutions interfere in China's internal affairs and smear the National Security Law. Hong Kong and foreign ministry statements repeat that the National Security Law and the Safeguarding National Security Ordinance restored stability, that the relevant cases are handled according to law, and that criticism by foreign parliaments is double standards and political manipulation. This page records that position because a complete archive requires both sides' statements to stand side by side. It must also be noted that the formulaic responses have never answered the resolutions' specific allegations point by point: on matters such as the exclusion of overseas counsel, solitary confinement and access to communion, no itemised public response from the Chinese or Hong Kong authorities appears in the public record consulted for this page, and that absence is recorded as such.

The gap inside the European Union is the most important implementation record on this page. The European Parliament is the EU's elected legislature, but decisions on foreign sanctions belong to the Council, composed of member state governments and acting by unanimity. On at least four occasions across the five resolutions, Parliament expressly called on the Council to use the Global Human Rights Sanctions Regime against Hong Kong and mainland officials, and the Council has never done so. The Council adopted conclusions on Hong Kong in 2020; it has not completed the review Parliament demanded in November 2024 and has not escalated to sanctions. The EU has therefore left two parallel official records on Hong Kong: one of yearly escalating condemnation and naming by Parliament, and one of yearly unchanging silence by the Council. This page places the two records on a single page precisely so that no reader mistakes the first for the second. A resolution adopted is not a sanction imposed, and that dividing line must be held when reading any European Parliament text on China.

As of this page's latest review in November 2026, the current state of the line is as follows. Jimmy Lai remains in custody; this page records developments in his case and in follow-up proceedings in the 47 case only as far as they are confirmed in resolution texts and public reporting, and does not write unsettled matters as settled. The European Parliament has adopted Hong Kong resolutions in almost every session period since the National Security Law was imposed in 2020; the five recorded here are the nodes with verifiable procedure numbers, vote figures or adopted-text numbers, not the totality of Parliament's statements on Hong Kong. The Council's sanctions list still contains no Hong Kong official. If a new resolution is adopted or Council policy changes, this page will be updated substantively with the date and text number noted.

7. Documents and procedure index

The European Parliament documents covered by this page are indexed in chronological order. First, the resolution of 8 July 2021, Hong Kong, notably the case of Apple Daily, procedure number 2021/2786(RSP), adopted by 578 votes to 29 with 73 abstentions. Second, the resolution of 20 January 2022, Violations of fundamental freedoms in Hong Kong, condemning the dismantling of civil society and the raid and closure of Stand News; the verified material for this page does not state its roll-call figures and none are supplied. Third, the resolution of 15 June 2023, The deterioration of fundamental freedoms in Hong Kong, notably the case of Jimmy Lai, procedure number 2023/2737(RSP), demanding Jimmy Lai's immediate and unconditional release; the verified material for this page does not state its roll-call figures. Fourth, the resolution of 25 April 2024, The new security law in Hong Kong and the cases of Li Yuxuan and Chen Zihua, adopted by a show of hands with no roll-call figures, holding the National Security Law and the Safeguarding National Security Ordinance to breach international obligations including the Sino-British Joint Declaration. Fifth, the resolution of 28 November 2024, Hong Kong, notably the cases of Jimmy Lai and the 45 activists convicted under the National Security Law, adopted text TA-10-2024-0051, adopted by 473 votes to 23 with 98 abstentions.

Related background and institutional documents include the Law of the People's Republic of China on Safeguarding National Security in the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, imposed in 2020; the Hong Kong Safeguarding National Security Ordinance, in force from 23 March 2024; the Sino-British Joint Declaration; the Council legislation establishing the EU Global Human Rights Sanctions Regime; and the Council's 2020 conclusions on Hong Kong. The officials named for sanctions are taken from the 2021 resolution text and include Carrie Lam, John Lee, Teresa Cheng, Chris Tang, Xia Baolong and Luo Huining; the 2024 resolutions additionally call for sanctions on officials including John Lee. This page invents no adopted-text number for any resolution: the adopted-text numbers of the January 2022 and April 2024 resolutions do not appear in the verified material for this page and are left blank with that explanation, not filled by conjecture.

8. Verification note

The vote figures 578, 29 and 73 and 473, 23 and 98 correspond respectively to the resolutions of 8 July 2021 and 28 November 2024 and are taken from the European Parliament procedural record as compiled in this batch's fact brief. Procedure numbers 2021/2786(RSP) and 2023/2737(RSP) and adopted-text number TA-10-2024-0051 are reproduced from the brief without alteration. The statement that the resolution of 25 April 2024 was adopted by a show of hands, with no roll-call figures, follows the brief. The roll-call figures for the resolutions of 20 January 2022 and 15 June 2023 do not appear in the brief, and this page expressly notes the gap rather than inventing figures or transplanting figures from other votes. Statements in the resolutions concerning fabricated charges, solitary confinement and denial of communion are identified throughout as the European Parliament's stated positions and are not presented as facts confirmed by a court. The reactions of the Chinese and Hong Kong authorities are recorded in summary form following their standard public formulations. No single quotation exceeds fifty words. This page was last reviewed in November 2026, and statements of current status are made as of that date.

Our Take

What most deserves recording about these five resolutions is not what the European Parliament said, but what was done in response to four years of saying it. Read side by side, the picture is clear. On one side stand Strasbourg's yearly updated lists and figures, 578 votes and then 473, the majority always overwhelming, the demands progressing from the release of journalists down to one elderly prisoner's right to receive communion. On the other side stands the Council's four years of unbroken blank: no sanctions decision, and not one Hong Kong official on an EU sanctions list. Anyone reading only the resolution texts would think the EU was steadily escalating on Hong Kong; anyone reading only the implementation record would think the EU had done nothing at all. Both records are true, and only pinning them to the same page gives the whole truth.

That does not make the resolutions worthless. Their value lies precisely in being undeletable. Sentences in the 47 case will be served, and Apple Daily's masthead has already disappeared, but every name, every allegation and every vote figure the European Parliament wrote down on 8 July 2021 and 28 November 2024 remains in the EU's formal archive as a set of coordinates no later account of this period can avoid. The Council's silence is recorded in the same archive. When the EU's Hong Kong policy of these years is one day assessed, no one will be able to use Parliament's resolutions to cover the Council's absence, because pages such as this one have marked the gap between demand and execution year by year. Parliament did everything within its powers, which are record and pressure. Those who did not act are the ones holding the power of decision. The archive draws that line for everyone.

9. Supplementary record: how the named lists changed over four years

Extracting the personal names from the five resolutions and arranging them in order reveals a clear line of change. The officials named for sanctions in 2021 were Carrie Lam, John Lee, Teresa Cheng and Chris Tang, together with Xia Baolong and Luo Huining, covering the then Chief Executive, the security and justice portfolio holders, and the heads of mainland bodies responsible for Hong Kong affairs. By 2024 John Lee, one of those named, had risen to become Chief Executive, and the resolutions still called on the Council to sanction officials including John Lee himself. The person named was promoted inside the Hong Kong system while the sanction never arrived; that contrast is the sharpest single slice of the implementation gap, and this page records it on the basis of public changes of office and the resolution texts alone, without unverified material about personal assets or movements.

The list of people whose release was demanded grew longer each year. In 2021 the demand was still framed generally, as the release of those arbitrarily detained and an end to the harassment of journalists, with the arrested Apple Daily journalists specifically in view. In 2022 the resolutions named the case of Jimmy Lai and recorded arrests including that of Gwyneth Ho. In 2023 the demand for immediate and unconditional release was concentrated on Lai alone. In November 2024 the list was at its longest: all pro-democracy politicians, activists and journalists sentenced under the National Security Law, including Jimmy Lai and Chung Pui-kuen, with all charges to be dropped and both security laws repealed. The lengthening of the list follows the same line as the number of people imprisoned in Hong Kong; each time Parliament updated its list, it left an external archive entry for those newly jailed that year.

One procedural detail should also be recorded. The resolution of 28 November 2024 was adopted in the new parliamentary term following the European elections, and its figures of 473 in favour, 23 against and 98 abstentions show that the Hong Kong position survived the change of term and of group composition. Meanwhile two calls from the 2021 text, the diplomatic boycott of the Beijing Winter Olympics and lifeboat arrangements, were not repeated at the same length in later resolutions; Parliament's Hong Kong formula gradually contracted to three core demands, release, repeal and sanctions. Future updates to this page will keep tracking the lists: who is newly named, whose release is demanded, and whether the Council's list is still blank. Those three comparisons are the simplest gauge of whether this line of resolutions ever produces practical consequences.

分享本文Share this page

𝕏 推特𝕏 Twitter 脸书Facebook 电报Telegram WhatsAppWhatsApp 复制链接Copy link