EndCCPWorld.com

中国共产主义历史罪证与受害者记录
China: Archive of Communist Crimes & Victims
ARCHIVE / MEMORY / EVIDENCE

让历史被看见
让受害者被铭记
Let History Be Seen
Let Victims Be Remembered

The China Tribunal Judgment (17 June 2019): A London People's Tribunal Finds Forced Organ Harvesting a Crime Against Humanity

This record documents the China Tribunal in London: its seven members, five days of hearings in December 2018 and April 2019, its witness and statistical evidence, its 17 June 2019 judgment finding crimes against humanity, and its citation in later UK, Canadian and US legislation.

This page is currently available in Chinese and English only.

International Official Record · The China Tribunal JudgmentBody: an independent people's tribunal seated in London, convened in 2018 by the International Coalition to End Transplant Abuse in China (ETAC)Key documents: Short Form Conclusion and Summary Judgment, 17 June 2019; full Judgment published 1 March 2020

The China Tribunal, formally the Independent Tribunal into Forced Organ Harvesting from Prisoners of Conscience in China, was a non-governmental people's tribunal seated in London. Convened by the International Coalition to End Transplant Abuse in China and chaired by Sir Geoffrey Nice QC, the former lead prosecutor of Slobodan Milosevic at the UN tribunal for the former Yugoslavia, its seven members held five days of public hearings in London on 8 to 10 December 2018 and 6 to 7 April 2019, hearing more than fifty fact witnesses, experts and investigators and reviewing a large body of written material. In December 2018 the Tribunal issued an interim judgment finding that forced organ harvesting had been practised over a substantial period involving a very substantial number of victims. On 17 June 2019 it released its Short Form Conclusion and Summary Judgment, unanimously concluding that forced organ harvesting had been committed for years throughout China on a significant scale, that Falun Gong practitioners had been one source of organ supply and probably the main source, and that these acts, proved beyond reasonable doubt, constituted crimes against humanity. On the Uyghurs, the Tribunal found concerted persecution and medical testing of more recent date, held no evidence of their forced organ harvesting at that time, and warned that their vulnerability to being used as an organ bank was obvious. The full Judgment was published on 1 March 2020. This page records, from the Tribunal's own published judgment, hearing records and charter, cross-checked against The BMJ, parliamentary records and later legislation, the Tribunal's origins, composition, evidence, judgment, Beijing's absence and response, and the judgment's afterlife in legislatures. A note on classification: the page sits in this site's international official record section because parliaments and governments later cited the judgment formally and built legislation on it; the Tribunal itself was not an official body of any state, and this page says so throughout.

1. Origins: from an investigation report to a tribunal

The China Tribunal grew out of more than a decade of investigation. In 2006, after allegations surfaced that organs were being taken from detained Falun Gong practitioners in China, former Canadian secretary of state David Kilgour and human rights lawyer David Matas conducted an independent inquiry, reporting in July 2006 and in revised form in 2007 that the allegations were credible (Grade B: the inquiry reports themselves, recorded elsewhere on this site). Investigative work continued, notably by journalist Ethan Gutmann, and in June 2016 Kilgour, Matas and Gutmann published a joint update estimating that China's true transplant volume far exceeded official figures. Also in 2016, members of the International Coalition to End Transplant Abuse in China asked Geoffrey Nice for a legal opinion on the issues; Nice advised that a body of several people would be better able to consider the facts and the law than a single opinion writer, and the idea of a tribunal was born (Grade A: the Judgment's own account of its origins). ETAC registered as an Australian charity in 2017, its founders including Gutmann, Matas and Kilgour. In 2018 ETAC convened the Tribunal and commissioned Nice as chair. That origin imposes a duty of candour on this page: the convening body was an advocacy organisation with a settled view, while the Tribunal's designer tried from the start to separate the reviewing body from its convener by composition and procedure. Both facts belong in the record.

2. Composition and the independence arrangements

The Tribunal had seven members (Grade A: the Judgment's title pages). The chair, Sir Geoffrey Nice QC, a barrister of England and Wales, served as a prosecutor at the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia from 1998 to 2006 and led the prosecution of Slobodan Milosevic. The other six were Professor Martin Elliott, professor of cardiothoracic surgery at University College London and a paediatric thoracic transplant surgeon; Andrew Khoo, advocate and solicitor in Kuala Lumpur and co-chair of the Malaysian Bar Council's Constitutional Law Committee; Regina Paulose, an American human rights lawyer; Shadi Sadr, an Iranian human rights lawyer; Nicholas Vetch, a British businessman; and Professor Arthur Waldron, Lauder Professor of International Relations at the University of Pennsylvania and a historian of China. Counsel to the Tribunal organised the evidence and the questioning, and all members and counsel worked without payment. The Judgment states expressly that none of the Tribunal's members, its counsel, its editor or its volunteer lawyers was a Falun Gong practitioner or had any special interest in Falun Gong; that only a minority of those working in and for ETAC were practitioners; and that the members maintained distance and separation from ETAC to ensure independence (Grade A: the Judgment's own statements). The Judgment is equally candid that the evidence was submitted largely by ETAC. Convening, evidence supply and adjudication are therefore all on the face of the document, and this page records the independence claim and the convening structure side by side, leaving readers to weigh the judgment's authority for themselves.

3. The mandate: what the Tribunal was asked to decide

The Tribunal's charter gave it a precise mandate: to consider the evidence regarding forced organ harvesting from prisoners of conscience in China and to determine whether international crimes had been, and continued to be, committed (Grade A: the Charter). It posed three groups of questions. First, on the available evidence about past and continuing forced organ harvesting, had international crimes been committed? Second, if so, what legal and other actions should the international community take, including whether alleged perpetrators could be named under relevant legislation and how sovereign immunity affected civil suits against wrongdoers? Third, what were the responsibilities of international hospitals, universities, doctors, professional societies, medical researchers, pharmaceutical and biotech companies, journals and publishers in collaborating with Chinese counterparts and transplant professionals, whether such collaboration could amount to complicity, what constraints should govern future collaboration, and what professional and legal sanctions should apply? The Charter committed the Tribunal to transparency about the evidence it examined and the sources it consulted. On questions of law it received submissions from Edward Fitzgerald QC and Datuk N. Sivanathan, among others. In other words, the Tribunal was designed from the outset not merely to find facts but to address responsibility and consequences, which is precisely why legislators later found its output usable.

4. The hearings: five days in public

The public hearings ran over five days in two rounds in London: 8, 9 and 10 December 2018, and 6 and 7 April 2019 (Grade A: the Judgment's evidence section and the Tribunal's hearings pages). Between the rounds the Tribunal issued its interim judgment. More than fifty fact witnesses, experts and investigators testified; all witnesses but one were heard in public, and videos of their evidence were posted on the Tribunal's website (Grade A: the Judgment). Those who testified included detained Falun Gong practitioners and Uyghurs, family members of victims, medical experts, data analysts, and journalists and lawyers who had investigated the subject for years; David Kilgour gave evidence on 7 April 2019. After the hearings the members deliberated by internet conference. One procedural fact deserves emphasis: before reaching any conclusions, the Tribunal invited the Chinese government at every stage to submit material and take part, and also invited people who had publicly expressed scepticism about the harvesting allegations to give evidence; the invitations and correspondence are archived on its website. No response was received from the Chinese government before judgment (Grade A: the Judgment and the archived correspondence; Grade B: The Guardian, 17 June 2019, to the same effect). The Tribunal also reviewed exculpatory material available in public, including transplant official Haibo Wang's filmed response to the 2016 update report, the Chinese government's written submission to the UN Committee Against Torture, and the evidence of international transplant figures Francis Delmonico before a US congressional body and Jeremy Chapman before the Australian Senate, both of whom had collaborated with Chinese transplant authorities. Material capable of undermining the allegations was thus expressly inside the review, a point any fair assessment of the judgment should not omit.

5. The evidence, part one: witnesses

Fact witness testimony was the first pillar. Falun Gong and Uyghur witnesses described forced medical testing in detention, including blood tests, ultrasound and organ scans, alongside torture, sexual violence and psychological abuse (Grade A: hearing records and the Judgment's evidence survey). The Tribunal's reasoning about this testimony is set out plainly in the Judgment: repeated organ-function testing of ordinary detainees has no plausible explanation in routine custodial medicine, and its fit with donor screening is what made the testimony probative. The witness evidence also included accounts connected to medical personnel, among them the much-cited public account of Uyghur surgeon Enver Tohti, who said he had been required in the 1990s to remove organs from a prisoner who was still alive; his account recurs through the hearing record as one piece of evidence among many, not as a load-bearing single proof (Grade B: his account as relayed in media and hearing materials). The Tribunal's method with human testimony is worth recording: it treated no single witness as decisive, and allowed testimony into its conclusions only where it converged with the statistical evidence and the recorded telephone evidence. That method, explained in the Judgment's evidence chapters, is a principal reason this page archives the case rather than merely repeating its conclusion.

6. The evidence, part two: numbers and statistics

The second pillar was arithmetic. The core problem before the Tribunal was a gap that could not be closed: between China's officially reported transplant and voluntary donation figures on one side, and the actual scale of transplant activity visible in hospital data on the other. Analyses submitted to the Tribunal, built from bed utilisation rates, surgical team sizes, hospital revenues and hospitals' own publicity, estimated actual transplant operations at between 60,000 and 100,000 a year, against an official figure of roughly 10,000; the update-report line of analysis produced an estimate of 60,000 to 90,000 (Grade A: the analyses as adopted in the Judgment; the figures are the submitters' estimates, and the Tribunal endorsed the method rather than inventing its own numbers). The Tribunal gave particular attention to a statistical study by Matthew Robertson and colleagues of China's official deceased-donor data, published in BMC Medical Ethics in November 2019, which found that the official donation figures followed mathematical patterns consistent with fabrication; the Tribunal had the study independently reviewed by the British statistician Sir David Spiegelhalter (Grade A: the journal article and the Tribunal's archived commentary). On this basis the Tribunal found that the accumulated numerical evidence, excluding spurious official data, showed both a very large number of transplant operations and the impossibility of anything like sufficient eligible donors under the recently formed voluntary scheme to supply them, and that the massive build-out of transplant facilities and personnel had often begun before any voluntary donor system was even planned. Waiting times formed a separate evidentiary point: the extraordinarily short waiting times promised by Chinese doctors and hospitals for organs to become available cannot occur in a genuine voluntary system, where a specific organ cannot be produced on demand within days or weeks; supply on demand was itself treated as evidence of a living donor bank.

7. The evidence, part three: telephone recordings and forensic testing

The third pillar was recorded investigation calls. Investigators telephoned hospitals across China posing as relatives of patients; in the recordings, hospital staff discussed the availability of organs, and some calls referred to organs from Falun Gong practitioners (Grade A: as adopted in the Judgment; Grade B: The BMJ's March 2020 report on this evidence). The Tribunal did not take the recordings at face value: it had them reviewed by independent academic commentators, and one key call was subjected to forensic examination. In that call, the speaker identified as Bai Shuzhong, former head of the health department of the PLA's General Logistics Department, was recorded stating that Jiang Zemin, the former CCP general secretary, had directly ordered the killing of Falun Gong practitioners for their organs; the Judgment records this in the limited form that the submitted recording contains that statement (Grade A: the forensic examination report archived by the Tribunal in February 2020; the content is the recorded speaker's assertion, never confirmed by the person accused). This page keeps the limitation attached, because that call is routinely quoted in circulation stripped of its qualifiers; an archive that repeats the claim without its evidentiary status would be failing its basic duty.

8. The interim judgment and the final judgment

After the first round of hearings in December 2018, the Tribunal issued an interim judgment, recorded in the Short Form Conclusion in these terms: its members were certain, unanimously and beyond reasonable doubt, that forced organ harvesting from prisoners of conscience had been practised in China for a substantial period of time involving a very substantial number of victims (Grade A: the interim text as quoted in the Short Form Conclusion, excerpted within this site's fifty-word quotation limit). On 17 June 2019 the Tribunal released its Short Form Conclusion and Summary Judgment in London. Its holdings were these. First, forced organ harvesting had been committed for years throughout China on a significant scale, and Falun Gong practitioners had been one source of organ supply, and probably the main source. Second, there was no evidence the practice had been stopped; the Tribunal was satisfied it continued, noting no evidence that the significant transplant infrastructure had been dismantled and, absent a satisfactory explanation of the source of readily available organs, concluding that harvesting continued to that day. Third, the concerted persecution and medical testing of the Uyghurs was more recent; the Tribunal had no evidence of forced organ harvesting of that group at that time, but the scale of medical testing could allow them, among other uses, to become an organ bank, and evidence might emerge in due course. Fourth, the Tribunal concluded that crimes against humanity against Falun Gong practitioners and Uyghurs had been proved beyond reasonable doubt. Fifth, on genocide, accepting legal advice about proving the specific intent required, the Tribunal could not be certain the requisite intent was proved and so could not be certain genocide itself was proved; but it held that those with the power to institute investigations and proceedings at international courts or at the United Nations had a duty to act immediately to test whether genocide had been committed. The judgment was unanimous. The full Judgment was then finalised and published on 1 March 2020 (Grade A: the Tribunal's judgment page and the University College London library record, ISBN 978-1838165314). The commissioning brief for this page spoke of a final judgment in December 2019; the Tribunal's own record shows no December 2019 judgment document: the conclusions and summary were released on 17 June 2019 and the full Judgment on 1 March 2020, and this page follows the primary record, with the correction noted in its verification section.

9. Beijing's absence and Beijing's answer

The Chinese government never took part. Invitations were issued at every stage and went unanswered; the Tribunal stated that it drew no adverse inference from the silence and that its conclusions rested only on the evidence it actually examined (Grade A: the Judgment). Beijing's public position on the Tribunal matches its position on all harvesting allegations: official statements have consistently denied that organs are taken from prisoners of conscience, maintain that China's donation and transplant system is lawful and transparent and that the use of executed prisoners' organs ended entirely in 2015 in favour of voluntary citizen donation, and dismiss the Tribunal as a tool manipulated by anti-China forces whose conclusions are lies (Grade B: the general line of official statements and state media over the years; this page does not reproduce individual statements at length). This page records both halves without embroidery: the invitations and the non-response are procedural facts, and the denial and dismissal are positions of record. Between them lies the structural point most worth archiving: China's substantive defence material did enter the review in written form, through its UN submissions and its transplant officials' filmed responses, but by choosing absence Beijing left that material untested by questioning. The archive records this not to score a point but so that later readers understand the judgment's evidential architecture.

10. After the judgment: the United Nations and Washington

The judgment's afterlife is what turned a non-official document into a working reference. On 18 June 2019 The BMJ reported the finding under the headline that China's forced organ harvesting constitutes crimes against humanity (Grade A: The BMJ 2019;365:l4287). In September 2019 the Tribunal's legal counsel presented its findings during the UN Human Rights Council session in Geneva and called for a UN investigation, and the Tribunal's supporters wrote formally to the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights transmitting the judgment's conclusions (Grade A: the archived letter; Grade B: SBS News, 25 September 2019). When the full Judgment appeared in March 2020, The BMJ reported again, on the Tribunal's forensic handling of the telephone evidence. In June 2021 twelve UN special procedures experts issued a joint statement expressing extreme alarm at the harvesting allegations and calling on China to respond; that statement is not part of the Tribunal's judgment, but it sits on the same evidentiary chain, and this page notes the connection without merging the two (Grade A: OHCHR records, covered in this section's United Nations pages). In the United States, the judgment was cited in Congressional-Executive Commission on China materials and congressional research; it was invoked in debate on the Stop Forced Organ Harvesting Act passed by the House in 2023 as H.R.1503, and on S.4009, the Falun Gong and Victims of Forced Organ Harvesting Protection Act passed by the Senate in 2026 (Grade A: congressional records and bill texts; for the current legislative status see this site's organ-harvesting dossier and its daily checks rather than this page).

11. After the judgment: legislation that cited it

Britain, the Tribunal's home jurisdiction, moved first. In January 2021 the House of Lords, with government support, passed an amendment moved by Lord Hunt of Kings Heath to the Medicines and Medical Devices Bill, empowering ministers to make regulations keeping forcibly harvested human tissue and cells out of the UK medicines supply chain; the Act received Royal Assent on 11 February 2021 and was the first UK legislation directed at forced organ harvesting, with peers citing the Tribunal's judgment repeatedly in debate (Grade A: Hansard records of the Lords debates). Lord Hunt then promoted an organ tourism and body exhibitions bill to amend the Human Tissue Act; in 2022 the Health and Care Act carried related prohibitions into law, extending criminal liability for UK residents to certain transplant activity abroad involving payment or coercion (Grade A: the statute and parliamentary records; for clause detail consult the official text). In Canada, parliamentary debate on the organ-trafficking legislation enacted as Bill S-240, which received Royal Assent in 2022 and criminalised travelling abroad to receive an organ removed without consent, likewise drew on the Tribunal's conclusions (Grade A: Canadian parliamentary records). In Australia, the 2018 Senate inquiry report Compassion, Not Commerce predated the judgment and was itself reviewed by the Tribunal; later Australian debate on overseas transplant disclosure attached the Tribunal's Short Form Conclusion as an annex to a submission on the migration amendment bill (Grade A: Australian parliamentary document store, listed in this page's sources). None of these statutes purports to enforce the Tribunal's judgment, which no one had power to enforce; what their debates collectively show is that legislators needed exactly what the Tribunal supplied, a fact-finding text produced through public hearings and adversarial testing that they could cite, quote and build on.

12. Criticism, limits, and how to weigh this judgment

An archive page must record the case against its subject. First, legal authority: the Tribunal formed no part of any domestic or international court system, could compel no witness and impose no penalty, and its judgment binds no one (Grade A: the Tribunal's own description, echoed in Nature's reporting). Second, structure: it was convened by the advocacy coalition ETAC and received most of its evidence from ETAC; the Judgment answers with procedure, pointing to public hearings, published materials, the review of exculpatory evidence and the invitations to the accused state, and this page archives the answer and the objection together. Third, the nature of the proof: the core evidence is a combination of statistical inference, witness testimony and investigation recordings, without physical evidence or original internal documents from inside China's transplant system; some international transplant figures who had cooperated with China expressed reservations about parts of the allegations, and their evidence was inside the Tribunal's review, a fact also recorded here. Fourth, numbers: the estimates of 60,000 to 100,000 transplants a year come from submitted analyses whose methods and direction the Tribunal accepted; no independent channel has verified a precise figure, and every number on this page carries its source level rather than masquerading as a statistic. This site's weighing is as follows. The judgment's value lies not in finality, which it never possessed, but in having for the first time put previously scattered allegations through a public, adversarial and inspectable process, leaving complete hearing videos, an evidence catalogue and a reasoned text that parliaments, journalists and researchers can test item by item. A document that can be challenged line by line is worth more to an archive than a slogan that cannot be tested at all.

13. Document index and verification note

The core documents are these. One, the China Tribunal Short Form Conclusion and Summary Judgment, 17 June 2019, on the Tribunal's website. Two, the China Tribunal full Judgment, published 1 March 2020, full text on the Tribunal's website, library record at University College London, ISBN 978-1838165314. Three, the Tribunal's charter, hearings pages, archived invitations and correspondence, and the forensic examination report on recordings of February 2020, all on the Tribunal's website. Four, The BMJ reports of 18 June 2019 and 3 March 2020. Five, the Hansard record of the Lords debates on the Medicines and Medical Devices Bill amendment of 12 January 2021 and the Royal Assent of 11 February 2021. Verification grades: the membership, hearing dates, judgment holdings and the full Judgment's publication date are Grade A, checked against the Tribunal's website and the Judgment text itself; transplant volume estimates and the content of recordings are submitted evidence and are worded as such throughout; the Chinese government's position is Grade B general-line paraphrase. Correction: the commissioning brief for this page described a final judgment in December 2019; the Tribunal's judgment page shows the Short Form Conclusion and Summary Judgment of 17 June 2019 and the full Judgment of 1 March 2020, and no December 2019 judgment document, and this page has been written to the primary record. No single source is quoted at more than fifty words.

Our Take

What stings Beijing about the China Tribunal is not its conclusion but its procedure. Faced with five days of public hearings, more than fifty witnesses, hearing videos posted in full and a judgment that can be checked page by page, an accused regime answered with absence and the single word lies. Absence says a great deal: a side holding real exculpatory evidence does not pass up the chance to destroy its accusers in open session, and if China's transplant system truly ran entirely on voluntary donation, the complete donation and allocation data would be the strongest possible defence, data that has still never been opened in full to any independent body. The Tribunal had no police, no bailiffs and no arrest warrants; it had only the patience to put evidence on the table. That is exactly why its judgment became a stone legislators could stand on: the UK medicines amendment, Canada's organ-trafficking offences and the American sanctions bills all stepped forward from it. This site files the document in its international official record not because it says things we wish to hear, but because it demonstrates something worth preserving, that when a regime refuses all scrutiny, scrutiny can still be carried out by unpaid people in a London meeting room, and left on the record for good.

分享本文Share this page

𝕏 推特𝕏 Twitter 脸书Facebook 电报Telegram WhatsAppWhatsApp 复制链接Copy link