EndCCPWorld.com

The Children of the Ten Marshals and the Ten Senior Generals: A Generation in Uniform

The earlier installments dealt with the families of civilian officials and of premiers and Standing Committee members. This one changes the sample: the ten Marshals and ten Senior Generals who received their ranks in 1955 — twenty professional soldiers in all — and where their children went.

Let the conclusion be stated first, because it is the opposite of the earlier installments. The second generation of these twenty families went mainly into the military itself: a rough count of named children yields five Lieutenant Generals and more than a dozen Major Generals (plus one son-in-law who reached full General), with a great many of them spending their whole lives in uniform, on salaries, retiring from military academies and research institutes. The business landscape is astonishingly thin overall: not one family replicated an industry kingdom of the Li Peng family's kind, still less an offshore structure of the Wen Jiabao family's kind. The only real exception is the family of Ye Jianying — which produced a provincial governor and a vice chairman of the CPPCC, a Major General who ran the military's liaison system and a military-background company, and a third son who genuinely went into business. But even with the Ye family, the business facts that can be pinned to public documents are far more restrained than popular lore: the most widely circulated claim, "Poly Group and the Ye family," cannot be supported by any hard evidence anywhere in the public sources — Poly Group's publicly traceable heads are Wang Zhen's son Wang Jun and Deng Xiaoping's son-in-law He Ping, as a 2001 report of the U.S. Congressional Research Service on military-owned businesses states plainly, and it has nothing to do with the Ye family. Wherever this piece touches Poly, it writes only this one sentence of separation and goes no further.

One dark thread also runs through these twenty families: among this generation, the fathers' guns and nooses did not point only outward. Lin Biao's son died in the crash of a fleeing aircraft; Luo Ruiqing's son defected to the United States in 1989 and never returned before his death; Zhu De's grandson was executed by firing squad in the "Strike Hard" campaign of 1983. The second and third generations of military families were both the inheritors of privilege and, when the machine periodically turned on its own, the people standing closest to the blade. What follows treats Marshals and Senior Generals separately, accounting for each family, none omitted.

Part One · The Ten Marshals

I. The Zhu De Family: A Professor, Major Generals, and a Grandson Executed by Firing Squad

Zhu De had two biological children who lived to adulthood. His elder son Zhu Qi (1916–1974), born to his second wife Xiao Jufang, was raised from childhood in Sichuan by his stepmother Chen Yuzhen, served in the army as a signals cadre, later transferred to civilian work, and died of illness on June 10, 1974, aged 58. His public career rests mainly on family accounts and shows no prominent post. (Source 1)

His only daughter Zhu Min (1926–2009), born to He Zhihua (He Zhihua), was born in Moscow, raised by relatives in Chengdu as a small child, went to the Soviet Union for schooling as a teenager, was at one point held in a Nazi concentration camp, continued her studies after her release, graduated from the Moscow Lenin Pedagogical Institute in 1953, and spent her whole career teaching Russian at Beijing Normal University after returning home; after retiring in 1986 she helped found the University of Military-Civilian Dual-Use Talents (now the Beijing Military-Civilian Vocational College). She died of illness in Beijing on April 13, 2009, aged 83, and her obituary was issued by official media. (Sources 2, 3) She is the most typical "professional" sample among the children of Marshals and Senior Generals: a lifetime of teaching, no military rank, no company.

The Zhu family's ranks came in the third generation. Zhu Qi and Zhao Liping had four sons and a daughter: the second son Zhu Heping (b. 1952), a Major General of the Air Force and a specialist in early warning and electronic warfare, formerly vice president of the Air Force Command College, a senior engineer and doctoral supervisor, and a member of the Eleventh and Twelfth CPPCC National Committees; a son Zhu Quanhua (1956–2021), a Major General of the Navy, formerly deputy head of the Naval Armaments Department, who died in Beijing on September 20, 2021; the eldest son Zhu Yuanchao works in music; the daughter Zhu Xinhua's public record is brief. (Sources 4, 5)

The third generation also holds an entry that must be recorded truthfully. The youngest son Zhu Guohua (1957–1983) was a technician at the Tianjin Railway Sub-bureau; he was arrested in October 1982. The charges disclosed in public reports numbered 86, with sexual offenses at their core — rape, attempted rape, sexual violation, molestation, intercepting women and the like — among which those attributed to him personally included the rape of eight women. On September 18, 1983, Zhu Guohua and five others were sentenced to death; on September 24 he was executed by firing squad in Tianjin, aged 26 — at the height of the 1983 "Strike Hard" campaign, one of the most watched death-row prisoners among high cadres' children in that campaign. The figures of the case come from contemporaneous public reporting and a February 1984 disclosure by Hong Kong's Cheng Ming (Zhengming) magazine; different sources give different victim counts (30, 50 and other figures coexist). This piece adopts only the facts of the verdict and execution recorded in common by multiple sources, and marks the detailed figures as on the caliber of reports. When the Criminal Law was revised in 1997, the catch-all offense of "hooliganism" was abolished; but the core charges in Zhu Guohua's case were specific crimes such as rape, and the case cannot simply be folded into a narrative of "wrongful hooliganism cases" — this is this piece's gatekeeping caliber, stated plainly here. (Sources 6, 7, 8) Zhu De had died in 1976 and did not live to see his grandson's trouble; according to published accounts, his daughter-in-law Zhao Liping spoke of the matter calmly in her later years, and there is no public record of any intervention in the judiciary in the family's name.

II. The Peng Dehuai Family: A Family with No Biological Children

Peng Dehuai was the only one of the ten Marshals to remain without biological children his whole life. Neither of his two marriages — to Liu Kunmo and to Pu Anxiu — produced children; the "children" field of his personal data reads, in the public record, simply "none." (Source 9) This piece's format accounts for each family's descendants; what this family has to account for is this fact itself: no second generation, and naturally no family landscape to speak of.

The closest by blood, and the one who went furthest, was his niece Peng Gang (1938–2014). She was the daughter of Peng Dehuai's younger brother, the martyr Peng Ronghua, raised by her uncle from childhood; she enlisted in 1959, rose from engineering and technical posts to become head of the Cadre Department of the Political Department of the General Logistics Department and deputy secretary of the General Logistics Commission for Discipline Inspection, served from 1990 as deputy head and then head of the Discipline Inspection Department of the General Political Department, was conferred the rank of Major General in June 1991, sat on the Thirteenth Central Commission for Discipline Inspection and as a standing member of the Fourteenth and Fifteenth, and concurrently served as a vice chairwoman of the All-China Women's Federation; she died of illness on June 24, 2014. (Source 10) Peng Dehuai was toppled after the 1959 Lushan Conference and died in 1974 with his case unredressed; the first half of Peng Gang's military career was walked in the shadow of her uncle's designation as the head of an "anti-Party clique," and her position in the General Political Department's discipline inspection system was gained step by step only after Peng Dehuai's rehabilitation in 1978. This niece's line is the Peng family's sole "descendants" record.

III. The Lin Biao Family: A Crash, a Defection, and a Low Profile

Lin Biao had three children who lived to adulthood, and their three endings, within one family, write out this system's three ways of dealing with "its own."

The elder daughter Lin Xiaolin (b. 1941), born to his former wife Zhang Mei, was born in Moscow, returned to China in 1950, and in 1958 was banished by her stepmother Ye Qun to Shenyang to live with her birth mother; in 1960 she entered the Xi'an Military Telecommunications Engineering Institute, later transferring to the missile engineering department of the Harbin Military Engineering Institute. Her public record thereafter is sparse; she remained low-key all her life, with no post or business activity in public sources. (Source 11, compilation)

The second daughter Lin Liheng (b. 1944), nicknamed Doudou, born to Ye Qun, served as an editor at the Air Force News (Kongjun Bao). After the September 13 Incident of 1971 she was placed under examination and at one point attempted suicide with sleeping pills, surviving; on July 31, 1974, by Mao Zedong's instruction, the examination was lifted. Afterward she and her husband Zhang Qinglin worked at the Zhengzhou automobile plant, later transferring to the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences; in 1989 she helped found the China Modern Culture Society, and in 2012 she co-edited the Selected Military Writings of Lin Biao. On November 1, 2014, she appeared and spoke publicly at a symposium of descendants of the Red Army's East Route Army, drawing media attention — one of her very few public activities in more than forty years. (Source 12, compilations and media reports)

His only son Lin Liguo (1945–1971), nicknamed Laohu ("Tiger"), entered the physics department of Peking University in 1964, dropped out in the Cultural Revolution, joined the Air Force in 1967 as a secretary in the office of the Air Force Command, and in October 1969 was appointed deputy director of that office and concurrently deputy head of its operations department — at the age of 24, mocked at the time as "one year a soldier, two years a Party member, three years a deputy director." According to the official characterization and disclosures in later trials, in 1970 he organized a secret group, the "Joint Fleet," and in March 1971 took part in drafting the "Outline of Project 571," a plan to assassinate Mao Zedong. When the plot failed, in the early hours of September 13, 1971, he fled with Lin Biao, Ye Qun and seven others aboard a Trident aircraft from Shanhaiguan Airport; the plane crashed near Öndörkhaan in Mongolia, killing everyone aboard; he was 25. (Source 13) After September 13, Lin Biao was branded a "traitor and defector," and the family's very name became part of an offense; the two daughters' decades of low profile afterward are the direct aftershock of that branding.

IV. The Liu Bocheng Family: Eight Children, Four Major Generals

Liu Bocheng had eight children in all: the elder son Liu Juntai was born of his first marriage, and the other seven (Liu Taihang, Liu Huabei, Liu Jiexian, Liu Miqun, Liu Taichi, Liu Meng, Liu Yanling) were born to Wang Ronghua. (Source 14)

Liu Juntai (1912–1969), born to Cheng Yizhi, did not grow up at his father's side and lived an ordinary life, dying in 1969. (Source 15, narrative sources) The elder daughter Liu Huabei (1939–1945) was sent in the spring of 1940 into the Yan'an Central Nursery (the "Los Angeles Nursery"); on the night of August 18, 1945, she was murdered in the nursery's cave dwelling, six years old, her abdomen cut open with a sharp weapon; the case was investigated by the Central Organization Department and remains unsolved to this day — one of the most famous unsolved cases of the Yan'an period. (Source 16)

Of the six who lived to adulthood, five served in the military. Liu Taihang, Major General, formerly deputy head of an operations department in the armored forces; Liu Taichi, Major General, formerly deputy head of the Air Force Armaments Department; Liu Meng, Major General, formerly a member of the Science and Technology Committee of the General Armaments Department; the second daughter Liu Miqun (b. 1946), a Major General of the Air Force, formerly vice president of the Air Force Command College; the elder daughter (Wang Ronghua's eldest daughter) Liu Jiexian, a Senior Colonel, deputy director of an outpatient department in the General Logistics hospital system; the third daughter Liu Yanling, who worked professionally in nuclear medicine. (Sources 17, 18, compilations cross-checked against entries) This family's composition is the cleanest specimen of this piece's theme: children in a row, ranks in a row, but all of it positional — not one company, not one traceable business asset.

V. The He Long Family: An Only Son a Lieutenant General, an Elder Daughter a Major General

Five of He Long's children appear in the public record: the elder daughter He Jinlian (born to Xu Yuegu; her public record is extremely brief and her early circumstances cannot be verified); the daughter He Jiesheng (born to Jian Xianren), who as an eighteen-day-old infant went on the Long March with the Red Army and is called the only infant to complete the entire Long March, later joined the army and was conferred the rank of Major General; (Sources 19, 20) his only son He Pengfei (1944–2001), born to Xue Ming, joined the army after graduating from Tsinghua University, worked for a long time in the General Staff armaments system, headed the General Staff Department's Armaments Department in the 1980s, transferred in 1992 to become a deputy commander of the Navy in charge of armaments construction, and was promoted to Lieutenant General in 1994; he was one of the senior military supporters of the late-1990s purchase of the unfinished aircraft carrier Varyag (later rebuilt as the Liaoning), a matter on public record. He died in Beijing on March 28, 2001, aged 56, and Xinhua issued an obituary. (Sources 21, 22) The daughters He Liming and He Xiaoming (both born to Xue Ming) have brief public records of posts; in recent years He Xiaoming has mostly taken part in commemorative activities as a descendant of He Long, and in 2022 assembled characters from her father's handwriting to inscribe the name of the He Long Bridge on the Jinsha River. (Source 23)

He Long himself was persecuted to death in the Cultural Revolution (1969), and his children likewise spent the first half of their lives under the branding of "black gang offspring"; He Pengfei's rise to deputy commander of the Navy came more than twenty years after rehabilitation.

VI. The Chen Yi Family: A Deputy Mayor, a Major General, and a Line to Be Drawn with Anbang

Chen Yi and Zhang Qian had three sons and a daughter.

The elder son Chen Haosu (b. 1942) graduated from the University of Science and Technology of China, worked early on at the Second Academy of the Seventh Ministry of Machine Building and at the Academy of Military Science, became a secretary of the Secretariat of the Communist Youth League Central Committee in 1981, standing deputy secretary of the Party committee of Beijing's Fengtai District in 1983, a deputy mayor of Beijing in 1984, deputy minister of the Ministry of Radio, Film and Television in 1987, and from 1990 worked at the Chinese People's Association for Friendship with Foreign Countries, serving as its president from 2000 to 2011, concurrently presiding over associations including the China-Russia Friendship Association and the China-EU Association. (Source 24) The second son Chen Danhuai, a Major General, worked for a long time in the military research system (his public career rests mainly on compilations, and details are kept brief). (Source 25, compilation) The daughter Chen Shanshan has a brief public record; this piece records only her name.

The youngest son Chen Xiaolu (1946–2018) is the most commercially colored person in this family — and in the whole of Part One — and must therefore be written with the greatest care. The finding of the checking comes first: that he served for a long time as a director of Anbang Insurance Group from its founding in 2004 is supported; the claims that he was "Anbang's actual controller" or "the real boss" rest on no hard source, have been publicly apologized for by the reporting outlet, and were expressly denied by Chen Xiaolu himself; this piece does not adopt them. The hard facts are these: on September 13, 2004, Anbang Property & Casualty Insurance was founded in Ningbo, and Chen Xiaolu attended the founding assembly as one of the representatives of the founding shareholders, witnessing it together with Hu Maoyuan, general manager of SAIC Motor, among others; Hu Maoyuan became the first chairman; the list of Anbang's founding shareholders included Standard Infrastructure Investment Group. Chen Xiaolu had resigned his military post in 1992 with the rank of colonel (shangxiao), having previously worked at institutions such as the Central Research Office for Political System Reform; after entering business, besides the Anbang directorship he also appears on the director lists of institutions including Bosera Funds and Jiangxi Changyun (compilations). On January 29, 2015, Southern Weekend (Nanfang Zhoumo) reported that he was Anbang's "real boss"; Chen Xiaolu immediately denied it publicly, saying of himself at Anbang that he was "just an adviser — first, consulting; second, lending my presence; no shares." On February 2, 2015, Southern Weekend published an apology for the report, acknowledging that "the verification of information contained inaccuracies." On February 23, 2018, the China Insurance Regulatory Commission announced its takeover of Anbang Group, and Wu Xiaohui was later sentenced for fundraising fraud and misappropriation of office funds; five days later, on February 28, Chen Xiaolu died in Sanya, Hainan, aged 71. The two dates are merely adjacent, and this piece draws no causal inference of any kind. (Sources 26, 27, 28)

Chen Xiaolu's wife was Su Yu's daughter Su Huining — the marriage between a Marshal's family and a Senior General's family will be met again in the Su Yu section of Part Two.

VII. The Luo Ronghuan Family: One Lieutenant General, the Rest Left Blank

Seven of Luo Ronghuan's children appear in public lists: the sons Luo Beitun and Luo Dongjin, and the daughters Luo Yuying, Luo Lin, Luo Nanxia, Luo Beijie and Luo Ning. (Source 29, name-list compilation) Of these, only one has a complete public career.

Luo Dongjin (b. 1939), born to Lin Yueqin, was admitted to the Harbin Military Engineering Institute in 1959, joined the army after graduating, was promoted to Lieutenant General in 1999, served as deputy political commissar of the Second Artillery Corps, was elected a member of the Eleventh CPPCC National Committee in 2008, and authored My Father Luo Ronghuan (Liaoning People's Publishing House, 2003). (Source 30) Of the other six children, apart from their names there is no verifiable public career record, and this piece leaves them blank, truthfully.

A widely circulated confusion of persons must be corrected expressly here: the public-welfare figure Luo Diandian (whose original name is Luo Yuping) is often misrecorded as a daughter of Luo Ronghuan — she is in fact the daughter of Senior General Luo Ruiqing in Part Two below, as the February 2022 cover story of China Newsweek and the series of reports on Shenzhen's writing of advance directives into law can jointly establish. The Luo Ronghuan family has no such person as Luo Diandian. (Source 31)

VIII. The Xu Xiangqian Family: One Lieutenant General, Three Daughters with No Record

Xu Xiangqian had one son and three daughters: the son Xu Xiaoyan, the elder daughter Xu Songzhi, the second daughter Xu Luxi, and the third daughter Xu Xiaotao. (Source 32)

Xu Xiaoyan (b. 1947), a graduate of Beijing No. 4 Middle School and the computer science department of Tsinghua University, became head of the General Staff Department's Informatization Department in December 1999, was promoted to Lieutenant General in 2006, served as deputy director of the Science and Technology Committee of the General Armaments Department, and from 2008 served as a deputy to the National People's Congress. (Source 33) As to the occupations and public activities of the three daughters, the materials checked for this series contain no verifiable record; marked truthfully: none found.

IX. The Nie Rongzhen Family: An Only Daughter, the First Woman Lieutenant General; a Son-in-Law a Full General

Nie Rongzhen had only one daughter. Nie Li (b. 1930) graduated from the Leningrad Institute of Precision Mechanics and Optics in the Soviet Union, worked after returning home in the defense science and technology system, served as deputy director of the Science and Technology Committee of the Commission for Science, Technology and Industry for National Defense (COSTIND), was conferred Major General in 1988 and promoted to Lieutenant General in July 1993 — she was China's first woman Lieutenant General; she also served as a member of the Standing Committee of the Eighth (by-election) and Ninth National People's Congresses. (Source 34)

Her husband Ding Henggao (b. 1931) went further than the daughter: an expert in inertial technology and precision machinery and an academician of the Chinese Academy of Engineering, he directed COSTIND from 1985 to 1996, was conferred Lieutenant General in 1988, promoted to full General in June 1994, and served as an alternate member of the Twelfth Central Committee and a member of the Thirteenth and Fourteenth. (Source 35) In this piece's tally of "second-generation ranks," Ding Henggao is the sole exception in a footnote: the highest-ranking person of the children's generation across the twenty families entered by marriage, as a son-in-law. The Nie family has no third person to record, and no business record to check.

X. The Ye Jianying Family: The Exception among the Twenty

Ye Jianying had many children; six lived to adulthood: the elder son Ye Xuanping, the elder daughter Ye Chumei, the second son Ye Xuanning, the daughter Ye Xiangzhen, the third son Ye Xuanlian, and the daughter Ye Wenshan. This is the only family among the twenty to grow at once a provincial-level political figure, a chief of the military system, and businessmen who went to sea — and the only one in this piece that calls for the word "landscape" — but every block of that landscape must still be verified source by source.

Ye Xuanping (1924–2019), the elder son, graduated from the mechanical engineering department of the Yan'an Academy of Natural Sciences and rose as an engineer, successively serving as deputy director and chief engineer of Shenyang No. 1 Machine Tool Plant and Beijing No. 1 Machine Tool Plant and as director of the Third Bureau of the State Science and Technology Commission; in the early 1980s he returned to Guangdong as a vice governor and director of the provincial science commission, served as Mayor of Guangzhou from 1983 to 1985, as Governor of Guangdong from August 1985 to May 1991, and from April 1991 as a vice chairman of the CPPCC National Committee (ranked first in the Eighth and Ninth terms); he was an alternate member of the Twelfth Central Committee and a member of the Thirteenth and Fourteenth. He died in Guangzhou on September 17, 2019, aged 94, and the specifications of the official obituary matched vice-national-level treatment. (Source 36)

Ye Chumei, the elder daughter: her husband Zou Jiahua was a Vice Premier of the State Council — this is an in-law line, and this piece records only this one stroke. Ye Xiangzhen, a daughter, is a film director; her husband was the pianist Liu Shikun.

Ye Xuanning (1938–2016), the second son, was born in Hong Kong, wrote under the pen name Yue Feng, and lost his right arm to an injury, earning the name "the one-armed general." He joined the army in 1984, served as deputy director of the Liaison Department of the General Political Department, was conferred Major General in 1988, and directed the General Political Department's Liaison Department from 1990 to 1998; from 1993 he concurrently served as chairman and president of China Kaili Industrial Co., Ltd. As far as Kaili is concerned, what public claims can pin down ends here: according to the public material cited in his résumé entry, Kaili Industrial was responsible for raising funds for the General Political Department's Liaison Department and also had a Taiwan-work background — a typical form of a company run by a military liaison system itself before the military was comprehensively ordered out of business in 1998; Kaili's concrete assets, projects and transaction scale have no publicly checkable documentation, and this piece estimates nothing and quotes no rumors. Ye Xuanning transferred to civilian status in 1997 and died of lung cancer in Guangzhou on July 10, 2016; Caixin and other media issued obituaries. (Sources 37, 38)

Ye Xuanlian (b. 1952), the third son, formerly a pilot, is the one person in this family who appears in the public record genuinely in a businessman's capacity: chairman of Shenzhen Guoye Industrial Co., Ltd. and president of Guoji Holdings Co., Ltd., both posts seen in public résumé entries; his companies' scale and equity details have no public disclosure documents, and this piece records only the posts. (Source 39) Ye Wenshan, a daughter, has no verifiable public record beyond her name and family relationship.

The third generation is visible in fragments: Ye Xuanning's daughter Ye Jingzi (b. 1975) is a council member of the Soong Ching Ling Foundation and managing director of Hong Kong's Xingji (Interstellar) Culture Group; her husband Wang Jingyang is Wang Zhen's eldest grandson — the Ye and Wang families intermarried in the third generation; Ye Xuanlian's daughter Ye Mingzi works in fashion design; Ye Xuanping's grandson Ye Zhonghao (b. 1983) served as secretary of the Communist Youth League's Yunfu municipal committee (a division-level post), and his whereabouts after 2016 have no public tracking reports. (Source 40, compilations)

The Ye family's exception needs its boundary stated clearly: it produced a governor, a CPPCC vice chairman, a Major General who ran the military's Liaison Department and concurrently its self-run company, and a third son in business — a density without peer among the twenty families. But compared with the families of premiers and Standing Committee members in later installments, the Ye family has no listed-company control, no offshore record, and no industry-monopoly position in the public documents. The exception holds, and its magnitude is limited — both sentences must hold at the same time.

Part Two · The Ten Senior Generals

XI. The Su Yu Family: An Elder Son a Lieutenant General, a Second Son to an Ocean Shipping Company

Su Yu and Chu Qing had two sons and a daughter — the most orderly set of careers among the ten Senior General families; all three stayed inside the system, and all can be checked through public résumés. (Source 41)

The elder son Su Rongsheng (b. 1942), a graduate in missile control from the Harbin Military Engineering Institute, became commander of the 200th Division in 1983, chief of staff of the Army's 67th Group Army in 1985 and led troops in the Liangshan rotation battles, later served as commander of the 24th Group Army and deputy commander of the Beijing Military Region, was promoted to Lieutenant General in 1999, and retired in 2006. (Sources 41, 42) The second son Su Hansheng (b. 1947) enlisted in 1968 for naval vessel work, later transferred to the Ministry of Transport and China Ocean Shipping (COSCO), serving as a deputy manager of the ocean shipping company — a state-enterprise managerial post, not a landscape of his own, and recorded here as a post. The daughter Su Huining (b. 1949) served in the military, with the rank of Senior Colonel (in the Second Artillery system), and in 1975 married Chen Yi's youngest son Chen Xiaolu, joining the Su and Chen families by marriage. As for the title "general manager of Zhuoyue International Investment" that some overseas compilations attach to Su Huining, it is corroborated by no other source; this piece marks it unverified and does not use it.

XII. The Xu Haidong Family: A Son Who Rose to Vice Minister of Culture

Three of Xu Haidong's children appear in the public record: the elder daughter Xu Wenjin (1925–2009, born to his former wife Tian Dezhai; separated from her father for more than twenty years as a small child, she continued to live in the countryside after being found, and the public accounts rest mainly on family history); the second daughter Xu Wenhui (born to Zhou Dongping; her public record is brief); and the son Xu Wenbo (1937–2020), born to Zhou Dongping, who enlisted in 1962, worked early on in the Seventh Ministry of Machine Building system, served as Vice Minister of Culture from May 1990 to January 1999, and after retiring presided over the construction of the China Digital Library project, dubbed by media "the first network minister"; he died in Beijing on January 25, 2020. (Sources 43, 44) He is a rare purely civilian trajectory among Senior Generals' children: no military rank (after an enlistment episode he moved into the local system), rising as far as vice minister of a State Council ministry, with no business record.

XIII. The Huang Kecheng Family: The Children Sink, as a Whole, into Academia and Ordinary Posts

Huang Kecheng and Tang Dihua had two sons and two daughters: the elder son Huang Xu, the second son Huang Qing, the elder daughter Huang Nan, and the second daughter Huang Mei. (Source 45) Of the four, the most complete public record belongs to the elder daughter Huang Nan: a 1967 graduate of the physics department of Peking University and a researcher at the Chinese Academy of Sciences working on high-energy accelerators; her biography is found mainly in family accounts in the official "Red Family Traditions" column. (Source 46) The occupations and posts of Huang Xu, Huang Qing and Huang Mei have no verifiable record in the public materials checked for this series; marked truthfully: none found beyond their names.

XIV. The Chen Geng Family: Four Sons and a Daughter, Three Major Generals

Chen Geng had four sons and a daughter. The elder son Chen Zhifei (1929–2020), born to his first wife Wang Genying (who died a martyr in 1939), worked at the Ministry of Astronautics Industry as a professor-level senior engineer — the only one of the five not in uniform; he died in Beijing on September 13, 2020. (Source 47) The other four were born to Fu Ya: the second son Chen Zhijian (b. 1945), a Major General and Harbin Military Engineering Institute graduate, formerly chief of staff of the 14th Group Army and deputy commander of the Chongqing Garrison; the third son Chen Zhishu (b. 1954), a Major General, one of the first deputy commanders of the PLA Hong Kong Garrison in 1997, later commander of the Gansu Provincial Military District and a member of the Standing Committee of the CPC Gansu Provincial Committee, and a member of the Twelfth CPPCC National Committee; the fourth son Chen Zhiya, a Major General, who served in the People's Armed Police and in military-attaché postings abroad, later seen in the post of secretary-general of the China International Strategic Foundation (compilation sources, differing in detail, kept brief); and the daughter Chen Zhijin, who came from the ranks of military medicine, with a brief public career. (Sources 48, 49, 50, compilations and media reports)

Three Major Generals and one senior aerospace engineer in one family is the most standard look of a "military-uniform household." An in-law note in passing: Chen Geng's younger sister Chen Qiuqui was Tan Zheng's wife — the Tan Zheng family in the next section and the Chen family are in-laws.

XV. The Tan Zheng Family: Two Sons and a Daughter, No Public Record

Tan Zheng married successively Chen Qiuqui (Chen Geng's younger sister) and Wang Changde; published résumé entries record his children as: the elder son Tan Zedai, the second son Tan Jingxian, and the daughter Tan Xingming. (Source 51) The occupations and posts of all three have no verifiable record in the obituaries, personnel materials and media checked for this series. It should be noted that a compilation of high-cadre families circulating overseas labels Tan Zheng as having "no children," which conflicts with the two sons and one daughter recorded in published résumé entries; this piece follows the latter and does not use the former — but the three persons' destinations can only be written truthfully as: no public record found.

XVI. The Xiao Jingguang Family: Five Sons and a Daughter, Wholly without Findable Records of Note

Five sons and a daughter of Xiao Jingguang appear in public lists: Xiao Yongding, Xiao Boying, Xiao Zhuoneng, Xiao Ceneng, Xiao Xinhua, and the daughter Xiao Kai. (Source 52) This series checked each of them by name, post and rank as keywords and found no verifiable record of any prominent post or rank for any one of them — among the twenty families, this is one where "the gap between the father's status and the children's public presence is the largest." The Navy's first commander served for thirty years, yet his children sank, as a whole, to the level of ordinary people; the public material cannot distinguish whether this is the low profile of a family tradition or a lack of records, and this piece writes neither explanation, recording only the result of the check: none found beyond their names.

XVII. The Zhang Yunyi Family: A Second Son in the Nuclear Industry, a Third Son a Major General

Three of Zhang Yunyi's children lived to adulthood: the elder daughter Zhang Qiong (1915–2009, born to Wang Bizhen, who worked in the PLA hospital system until retirement); the second son Zhang Yuanzhi (b. 1928, born to Han Bi), who joined the army as a teenager, went south with the troops in 1949, later worked as a photojournalist at the Guangxi Daily, and after transferring to civilian life became deputy director of the Fourth Bureau of the Ministry of Nuclear Industry; and the third son Zhang Guangdong (born to Han Bi), who served in the military and attained the rank of Major General (on the caliber of public reports; specific posts are recorded inconsistently, and this piece does not expand). There were also an elder son and a second daughter who died in childhood. (Sources 53, 54, narrative sources cross-checked against entries) This family's magnitude likewise stops at posts: one deputy director of a ministry bureau, one Major General, no business record.

XVIII. The Luo Ruiqing Family: An Elder Son in the Army, a Second Son Who Defected, a Daughter Who Wrote the "Living Will"

Luo Ruiqing's children came from three marriages. The four born to Hao Zhiping — Luo Jian, Luo Yu, Luo Yutian and Luo Yuping — have the most complete public records; there is also an elder daughter Luo Yuhua and others born to a former wife, whose records are brief. (Source 55)

The elder son Luo Jian served in the military; public compilations record him as having attained the rank of Major General, but no authoritative public record of his specific posts has been found, and this piece keeps it brief. The second son Luo Yu (1944–2020) is the most unusually ended member of the second generation across the twenty families: a graduate of the automatic control department of Tsinghua University, he was implicated in the Cultural Revolution when his father was toppled; after his father's rehabilitation he enlisted, was conferred the rank of Senior Colonel in 1988, and served as head of the Aviation Equipment Division of the Armaments Department of the General Staff Department. In 1989, while in France for the Paris Air Show, he overstayed and did not return — his own public account thereafter is that he resigned and left because of his disapproval of the June Fourth crackdown; his military status and Party membership were promptly expunged. In 1990 he married the Hong Kong film star Di Na (Tina Ti) and settled in the United States; from 2015 he intervened in political commentary with memoirs and open letters, and in 2016 he published the memoir Farewell to the General Staff Department (Gaobie Zongcanmou Bu) in Hong Kong. He died on the East Coast of the United States on October 22, 2020; Radio Free Asia and other media carried the news. (Sources 56, 57) One popular claim must be kept outside the door: mainland self-media circulate a narrative of crimes by Luo Yu such as "selling weapons on the side and betraying state secrets," which is supported by no judicial document or authoritative media report whatsoever and conflicts entirely with his own public statements; this piece does not use it, recording only the verifiable facts of the defection, the expulsion and the writings.

The daughter Luo Yuping (b. 1951) is the public-welfare figure who lives under the name "Luo Diandian": a graduate of the medical department of Shanghai Medical University (the Second Military Medical University), she worked in the clinic of the Health Division of the Administration Bureau of the PLA General Staff. In 2006 she co-founded with friends the website "Choice and Dignity" (Xuanze yu Zunyan) — mainland China's first public-welfare website promoting "death with dignity" and living wills (advance directives) — which issued the text "My Five Wishes" (Wode Wuge Yuanwang); in 2013 the Beijing Living Will Promotion Association was founded; she authored Who Decides My Death (Wode Siwang Shei Zuozhu). On June 23, 2022, the Standing Committee of the Shenzhen Municipal People's Congress passed the revised Regulations of the Shenzhen Special Economic Zone on Medical Care, writing the living will into law, effective January 1, 2023 — the cause she had promoted for sixteen years became a statutory provision. (Source 31) She is the only member of the second generation of these twenty families to leave an institutional achievement in the public sphere by a path completely detached from the system. The other daughter, Luo Yutian, has a brief public record; this piece records only her name.

XIX. The Wang Shusheng Family: Three Sons and a Daughter, All without Findable Records of Note

Wang Shusheng and Yang Ju had three sons and a daughter: the elder son Wang Luguang, the second son Wang Chuhai, the third son Wang Jianchu, and the daughter Wang Jichi. (Source 58) The occupations and posts of all four, checked one by one for this series, have no verifiable public record. Wang Shusheng was deputy commander of the Fourth Front Red Army and ranked high among the Senior Generals, yet his children are nearly invisible in the public world — alongside the Xiao Jingguang family, the two most conspicuous names on this piece's "none found" list. Marked truthfully: none found beyond their names.

XX. The Xu Guangda Family: One Son and One Daughter, the Record Stops at Their Names

Xu Guangda and Zou Jinghua had one son and one daughter: the son Xu Yanbin and the daughter Xu Lingling. (Source 59) Xu Yanbin's public record appears only in the relatives column of his father's entry; mainland self-media style him a Major General, but no official career record or authoritative media report corroborates it, and this piece marks it unverified and does not use it. Xu Lingling has no public career record. Xu Guangda himself was persecuted to death in the Cultural Revolution in 1969, and his children came of age with their father no longer alive — the "none found" of this family and the "none found" of the Xiao and Wang (Shusheng) families may not have the same causes, and the public material likewise cannot distinguish them; this piece records only the result for all alike.

Conclusion: How the Account of a Military-Uniform Household Is to Be Reckoned

With the twenty families laid out, the conclusion at this piece's opening can be stated more fully.

First, this generation's privilege was mainly positional, not asset-based. Among the second generation of the twenty families, there are five Lieutenant Generals (Su Rongsheng, He Pengfei, Luo Dongjin, Nie Li, Xu Xiaoyan) and more than a dozen Major Generals (four in the Liu family, three in the Chen Geng family, He Jiesheng, Chen Danhuai, Ye Xuanning, Zhang Guangdong and others, plus the niece Peng Gang and the son-in-law full General Ding Henggao), and several vice-ministerial civilian officials (Ye Xuanping, later reaching vice-national rank; Xu Wenbo; Chen Haosu). Their names appear on appointment lists and in obituaries, not on shareholder registers or in offshore files. Against the series' other installments, the difference lies not in "whether there was privilege" but in its form: the families of premiers and Standing Committee members caught the windows of industry capitalization and financialization and converted position into equity and assets; the families of Marshals and Senior Generals kept to a closed system priced in ranks and posts, in which the things it contains — ranks, military posts, places at military academies and research institutes — cannot be listed, cannot be taken offshore, and cannot be passed directly to the third generation, but can only be conferred anew, generation by generation.

Second, the Ye family is the only exception, and the exception's magnitude is limited. The Ye family occupies at once the political line (a governor, a CPPCC vice chairman), the military line (the head of the General Political Department's Liaison Department) and the business line (Kaili Industrial, Guoye Industrial), and is the only family among the twenty to approach the form of a "landscape." But Kaili's scale has no public documentation, Guoye's equity has no public disclosure, and no listed-company control of the Ye family appears in the record. To write the Ye family up as a "military business empire" is the popular practice; under this series' evidentiary rules, one can write only as far as the posts.

Third, backlash and inheritance are two faces of the same coin. Of the fathers of these twenty families, some were persecuted to death in the Cultural Revolution (He Long, Xu Guangda), one family's whole household died in a plane crash (Lin Biao), and one, toppled, jumped from a building (Luo Ruiqing). In the second generation, Luo Yu defected to the United States and died there; Luo Diandian distanced herself from the system by promoting living-will legislation; in the third generation, Zhu Guohua was executed by firing squad in "Strike Hard." Placing these names on the same table as that row of Lieutenant Generals and Major Generals is this generation's complete account: they stood closest to power, and so rose fastest; and because they stood closest to power, whenever the machine changed direction they were the first to be run over.

Read together with the earlier installments, the series' coordinates are now clear: the Mao family is privilege without business; the Liu family is privilege interrupted; the Li Peng family is privilege fully converted into industry and capital; and these twenty families of Marshals and Senior Generals are a fourth form — privilege locked inside the uniform, unconvertible and untransferable, able only to begin again with each generation, and liable to be taken back at any time.

Gaps in the Material (Stated Candidly)

• The Luo Ronghuan family: apart from Luo Dongjin, the other six children (Luo Beitun, Luo Yuying, Luo Lin, Luo Nanxia, Luo Beijie, Luo Ning) have no verifiable public career record beyond their names; the biographical details of Luo Beitun were not verified, and this piece does not write them.
• The Xu Xiangqian family: the three daughters Xu Songzhi, Xu Luxi and Xu Xiaotao have no verifiable public career record.
• The Xiao Jingguang family: the five sons and one daughter were checked one by one; no verifiable record of post or rank was found for any of them — the family with the largest gap among the twenty; only their names are listed.
• The Wang Shusheng family: the three sons and one daughter (Wang Luguang, Wang Chuhai, Wang Jianchu, Wang Jichi) all have no verifiable public record; only their names are listed.
• The Tan Zheng family: Tan Zedai, Tan Jingxian and Tan Xingming have no verifiable public record. One compilation circulating overseas labels Tan Zheng as having "no children," which conflicts with the two sons and one daughter recorded in published résumé entries; this piece follows the entries and notes the conflict here.
• The Huang Kecheng family: Huang Xu, Huang Qing and Huang Mei are not found beyond their names; only Huang Nan has an account in an official family-traditions column.
• The Xu Guangda family: Xu Yanbin appears only in the relatives column of his father's entry; the "Major General" of self-media claims has no official career corroboration, is marked unverified and not used. Xu Lingling has no public record.
• The Luo Ruiqing family: Luo Jian's rank is seen only in compilations; his specific posts have no authoritative public record; Luo Yutian is not found beyond her name.
• The Lin Biao family: Lin Xiaolin's public record after 1961 is nearly blank; Lin Liheng's career after 1974 is pieced together from compilations and commemorative reports, of limited detail strength.
• The Ye Jianying family: Ye Xiangzhen's and Ye Wenshan's career records are brief; Kaili Industrial's assets and transaction scale and Guoye Industrial's equity structure have no public disclosure documents — this piece writes only the posts, not the scale; this is deliberate blank-leaving, not an omission.
• The Zhu De family: Zhu Yuanchao is the subject of a single-source claim in an English-language compilation that he was involved in an economic case; with no official document or second source to corroborate it, this piece does not use it and registers the doubt here only.
• Summary of attribution corrections: (1) Luo Diandian (Luo Yuping) is the daughter of Luo Ruiqing, not of Luo Ronghuan (established by two sources, Source 31); (2) Chen Xiaolu's relationship to Anbang is capped, at the verifiable limit, at "founding director / adviser"; the "actual controller" claim has been apologized for by the outlet that originally reported it, and this piece does not use it; (3) Poly Group has no association with the Ye Jianying family supported by any public source; its traceable heads are Wang Jun and He Ping (Source 60), and the popular "the Ye family's Poly" claim is not used.

Contact: endccpworld@proton.me