EndCCPWorld.com

Deng Xiaoping (1904–1997)

China's de facto supreme leader from 1978 to 1992, celebrated as the "architect of reform and opening." He also ordered the 1983 "Strike Hard" campaign and the 1989 Tiananmen military crackdown. Deng's rule established a pattern that endures to this day: open up the economy, never loosen political control. This page documents his major decisions of repression — their causes, course, and consequences.

Lifespan

August 22, 1904 (Guang'an, Sichuan) – February 19, 1997 (Beijing)

In power

December 1978 – October 1992 (14 years as de facto supreme leader; gradually handed over power after the 1992 Southern Tour)

Positions

Chairman of the Central Military Commission (1981–1989, the real seat of power); Chairman of the Central Advisory Commission; never held the top Party title

Key crimes

"Strike Hard" campaign (1983–1987, mass death sentences); June Fourth military crackdown (1989, ordered troops to fire)

1. Three falls and three rises

Deng Xiaoping was born in 1904 in Guang'an County, Sichuan, to a small landlord family. He went to France on a work-study program in 1920 and joined the CCP in 1924. During the Long March he served as secretary-general of the Red Army's General Political Department; after 1949 he ran the Southwest region, then moved to Beijing, serving as Vice Premier and General Secretary of the CCP (1956–1966, handling day-to-day work).

His career is famous for "three falls and three rises": purged in 1933 for supporting Mao (first fall); purged during the Cultural Revolution in 1966 and sent to Jiangxi in 1969 (second); purged again after the April Fifth Movement in 1976, then rehabilitated in 1977 (third). This experience gave Deng an almost obsessive fixation on "stability" — he had personally felt how political turmoil devours individuals, and concluded that any challenge to Party rule must be crushed at any cost.

In December 1978, at the Third Plenary Session of the 11th Central Committee, Deng effectively replaced Hua Guofeng as supreme leader. But he never took the top nominal Party post (General Secretary), instead ruling through the chairmanship of the Central Military Commission. This "rule from behind the curtain" became his mode of governance for the next decade and more.

Sources: Ezra Vogel, Deng Xiaoping and the Transformation of China; Yang Jisheng's writings on the Deng era; Chronology of Deng Xiaoping (1904–1974), Central Party Literature Press.

2. "Strike Hard" (1983–1987): swift and severe

Causes: After the Cultural Revolution, social order was in chaos. From 1979 to 1982, criminal cases surged, and hooligan gangs appeared in some areas. In the summer of 1983, a knife attack in Tangshan, Hebei was amplified by the media, and combined with political considerations about "spiritual pollution," Deng decided to launch a campaign of "severely striking serious criminal offenses."

Course: In July 1983, at the Beidaihe meeting, Deng said: "Strike hard against criminal offenses — kill a batch of them." On August 25, the CCP Central Committee issued the Decision on Severely Striking Criminal Activities. The NPC Standing Committee then passed resolutions temporarily amending the criminal law and criminal procedure law: death penalty review authority was delegated downward (for some cases), appeal deadlines shortened, and "severity and swiftness" became the guiding principle.

The campaign ran in three waves: August 1983–July 1984 (first wave), August 1984–end of 1985 (second), 1986–1987 (third). Public security organs, pressured to meet quotas, arrested vast numbers of people. Many minor offenses — even mere "hooligan behavior" (a catch-all crime at the time) — drew heavy sentences.

Consequences: The authorities never published complete death-penalty figures for the campaign. According to internal Ministry of Public Security statistics that later leaked, plus scholarly research, the first wave alone saw 1.027 million arrests, of which 24,000 were sentenced to death (immediate execution). Some researchers (e.g., Su Xiaokang) estimate that over 30,000 people were executed during the entire campaign (1983–1987). Widespread torture to extract confessions and "verdict first, trial later" practices meant many cases were later proven wrongful — but the victims were already dead.

Sources: Su Xiaokang's reporting on the 1983 campaign; China Law Yearbook (1984–1988); research on judicial procedure during "Strike Hard" by Tan Yifei et al.

3. June Fourth (1989): the man who ordered the shooting

Causes: On April 15, 1989, Hu Yaobang died. Beijing university students took to the streets in mourning, and the movement grew into mass protests demanding democracy and an end to corruption. On April 26, the People's Daily editorial "It Is Necessary to Take a Clear-Cut Stand Against Disturbances" labeled the movement "turmoil," escalating the confrontation. On May 13, students began a hunger strike in Tiananmen Square. On the evening of May 19, Li Peng declared martial law in parts of Beijing, but troops entering the city were blocked.

The decision: The decisive meeting took place in mid-to-late May. According to Zhao Ziyang's memoir Prisoner of the State, at an enlarged Politburo Standing Committee meeting at Deng's home on May 17, Deng said: "We have no way out. If we don't take decisive measures, the Party and the state will be finished." He advocated bringing in the army to enforce martial law. Zhao Ziyang objected, insisting on resolving the crisis within democratic and legal channels. The meeting decided on martial law by 5 to 1 (Zhao the lone dissenter).

On May 20, Li Peng signed the martial law order. But the first troops entering the city — the 38th Army under Xu Qinxian — refused: the army commander disobeyed the order to suppress (he was later sentenced to five years). Deng then mobilized the 27th Army, the 38th Army (after replacing its commander), the 15th Airborne Corps, and others — an estimated 150,000 to 300,000 troops (estimates vary) converging on Beijing.

The crackdown: On the night of June 3, troops advanced on Tiananmen Square from multiple directions — Chang'an Avenue from the west, Fuxingmen, and others. Around Muxidi on West Chang'an Avenue, soldiers fired on civilians blocking their path, killing large numbers. In the early hours of June 4, the Square was cleared. Tank columns crushed obstacles on Chang'an Avenue — the famous "Tank Man" photograph was taken that day (the man's fate remains unknown).

Death tolls (competing estimates):

Sources: Zhao Ziyang, Prisoner of the State; Zhang Liang (ed.), The Tiananmen Papers; U.K. National Archives declassified files (2017); U.S. State Department declassified cables; Tiananmen Mothers testimonies.

4. Southern Tour (1992) and "stability overrides everything"

After June Fourth, Deng was internationally isolated, with Western sanctions following one after another. Party conservatives (Chen Yun, Li Xiannian and others) argued for slowing reform and returning to the planned economy. From January 18 to February 21, 1992, the 88-year-old Deng toured Wuchang, Shenzhen, Zhuhai, and Shanghai, delivering a series of talks whose core message was: "Development is the hard truth" — and "whoever doesn't reform steps down."

The Southern Tour restarted economic reform, but Deng added a caveat: "Stability overrides everything." That phrase became the supreme principle of Chinese politics for the next three decades: the economy could be opened, political reform was unthinkable. At the 14th Party Congress in October 1992, Jiang Zemin formally took over, but Deng continued to wield influence through the spirit of the Southern Tour until his death in 1997.

This model — economic opening plus political lockdown — was inherited intact by his successors. It brought growth, but also staggering inequality, rampant corruption, and total political suffocation.

Sources: Vogel, Deng Xiaoping and the Transformation of China, ch. 19; Selected Works of Deng Xiaoping, Vol. 3; Su Xiaokang's essays.

5. How it worked: rule from behind the curtain

Deng's style of rule had a distinctive feature: he never held the top nominal Party post (General Secretary), but exercised ultimate decision-making power through the CMC chairmanship and his status as a revolutionary elder. After "retiring" in 1987, he set up the Central Advisory Commission with himself as chairman, continuing to "steer."

This "elder politics" peaked in 1989: the decision to crush June Fourth was made not by the sitting General Secretary Zhao Ziyang (who opposed it), but by the "retired" Deng plus a handful of octogenarian elders — Chen Yun, Li Xiannian, Peng Zhen, Wang Zhen — in the living room of Deng's house. They decided the movement of hundreds of thousands of troops and the order to fire.

The consequence: formal institutions were hollow. Zhao Ziyang, as General Secretary, could not stop a military crackdown he explicitly opposed. Under Deng, "collective leadership" was a fig leaf; the will of the paramount leader was law.

Sources: Zhao Ziyang, Prisoner of the State; Wu Guoguang on Zhao Ziyang and political reform; research on "elder politics" by Cheng Xiaonong et al.

6. Controversies: two Deng Xiaopings

The official line ("architect of reform and opening"): The CCP hails Deng as the "architect of reform and opening," crediting him with ending the chaos of the Cultural Revolution and driving economic takeoff. June Fourth is unmentionable in official discourse — textbooks say nothing, and "June Fourth" and "Tiananmen" are censored online.

Liberal critics: Figures like Liu Xiaobo and Yu Ying-shih called Deng the "unfinished reformer" — he opened the door to the economy but personally slammed shut the window of political reform. Liu Xiaobo once said: "Deng's greatest crime was not what he did, but what he prevented — he blocked China's path to democracy."

Maoist critics: Maoists denounce Deng as a "capitalist roader" and "traitor," blaming his "privatization" and "let some get rich first" for inequality. This view has some currency among the grassroots, but it sidesteps a fact: the "equality" Maoists miss was built on universal poverty.

7. Historical impact

Deng died on February 19, 1997, at 93. His greatest legacy is the ruling logic of "stability overrides everything": as long as the economy grows, anything goes politically. Jiang Zemin, Hu Jintao, and Xi Jinping inherited it intact — only the methods of repression kept "upgrading."

After June Fourth, Chinese intellectuals fell permanently silent. The "1989 generation" either fled abroad or fell silent at home. Through patriotic education, the authorities erased June Fourth from young minds. Many Chinese college students today have no idea what happened in 1989.

And the "crony capitalism" Deng pioneered — power fused with capital, officials in bed with businessmen — became the root of three decades of corruption. He let some get rich first; those who got rich first were, invariably, the ones holding power.

8. Strike Hard: the launch chain and the numbers, source by source

Section 2 outlined the campaign; this section fills in how it was launched and how its toll should be stated. In the summer of 1983, after several notorious violent crimes were amplified by state media, Deng Xiaoping told public-security leaders at the Beidaihe resort that serious crime had to be punished swiftly and severely, with offenders rounded up in one sweep. On August 25, 1983, the Party Central Committee issued its decision on severely cracking down on criminal activity. On September 2, the National People's Congress Standing Committee passed a package of decisions that amended court-organization rules, devolved approval of many death sentences from the Supreme People's Court to provincial high courts, and shortened appeal windows in capital cases. That single step loosened, by design, the one institutional brake on executions. The first "battle" opened in September 1983: mass arrests, mass sentencing rallies, and executions carried out immediately after public trials became routine in many localities.

No complete official execution total was ever published. The figures in circulation, kept separate by what they actually count, are:

Sources: English Wikipedia, "Strike Hard Against Crime Campaign (1983)," and its Chinese published sources; Columbia Journal of Asian Law, on China's death-penalty debate (citing Tanner); Amnesty International reporting on the 1983–84 campaign.

9. Two ideological campaigns: spiritual pollution (1983) and bourgeois liberalization (1986–87)

Strike Hard policed the streets; a parallel effort policed minds. At the Second Plenum of the 12th Central Committee in October 1983, Deng delivered a speech on the Party's urgent tasks on the organizational and ideological fronts, warning against the spread of "spiritual pollution." The ensuing campaign reached into literature, art, hairstyles, clothing, and private speech; army units were set to relearning revolutionary songs. Within months it was colliding with economic and scientific work. Zhao Ziyang and Hu Yaobang pressed to rein it in, and Deng wound down its expansion around the turn of 1984 — without ever disavowing its launch. The episode is a compact sample of his method: a campaign could be started at will and braked at will, and braking it did not rehabilitate those it had hit.

The second campaign followed the student demonstrations of December 1986, which spread from Hefei — where astrophysicist Fang Lizhi's campus speeches were a direct inspiration — to Shanghai and Beijing. On December 30, 1986, Deng told senior colleagues that Hu Yaobang had been weak against bourgeois liberalization and named individuals, Fang Lizhi among them, for punishment. In January 1987 Hu was forced to resign as General Secretary — removed, in substance, by a meeting of elders rather than by any electoral procedure, though he kept his Politburo seat. An "anti-bourgeois liberalization" campaign followed, and Fang Lizhi, Liu Binyan, and Wang Ruowang were expelled from the Party. The method used against Hu — verdict first in a small circle, formalities afterward — is the same method that would be used in 1989. And when Hu died in April 1989, the grief that filled the streets drew directly on the memory of how he had been removed.

Sources: English Wikipedia, history of the PRC (1976–1989); Roderick MacFarquhar in The New York Review of Books; Human Rights in China, retrospective on the two ideological campaigns; Selected Works of Deng Xiaoping, Vols. 2–3.

10. May 17 to June 9, 1989: the martial-law decision chain, completed

Section 3 told the story of the crackdown; this section records the decision chain day by day, with the type of each source flagged. On May 17, 1989, an enlarged Standing Committee meeting was held at Deng's home. According to Zhao Ziyang's posthumously published memoir, Prisoner of the State, Deng there settled on martial law; Zhao alone opposed it. A memoir is a participant's retrospective account and must be read as such — Party archives remain closed — but its account of the meeting's timing, venue, and split is broadly consistent with other materials. At about 4:50 a.m. on May 19, it was Zhao, not Deng, who went to Tiananmen Square to address the students in his last public appearance; some secondary accounts misattribute that dawn scene, and this page separates the two men deliberately. On the evening of May 19, Li Peng and Yang Shangkun announced the martial-law decision to a rally of Party, government, and army cadres. On May 20, Li Peng signed the State Council order imposing martial law in parts of Beijing from 10 a.m. that day. The signature chain was a State Council formality; the decision itself had been taken at Deng's home on May 17. Three bodies of material — Zhao's memoir, the Tiananmen Papers compiled by Zhang Liang, and Li Peng's June Fourth diary, published in Hong Kong in 2010 — differ sharply in standpoint, and the authenticity and completeness of the latter two have been debated by scholars; on the sequence "decision first, paperwork after," they do not contradict each other.

After the clearing of the city, Deng received officers of the martial-law troops on June 9 and delivered his only public statement on the events, excerpted that evening on CCTV's Xinwen Lianbo and later collected in his Selected Works. Summarized, its points were four: the protests were a counter-revolutionary rebellion that domestic and international conditions had made inevitable sooner or later; the army's enforcement of martial law was justified, with condolences for dead and wounded servicemen; the reform-and-opening line and existing policies would not change; and ideological-political work had to be strengthened and lessons drawn. What the speech did not contain is as consequential as what it did: no figure for civilian deaths was ever given. That silence became the template for the official account for the next three decades — affirm the troops, affirm the line, and never count the dead in the streets.

Sources: Zhao Ziyang, Prisoner of the State (participant memoir); English Wikipedia, "June 9 Deng speech," and the text in Selected Works of Deng Xiaoping, Vol. 3 (official text); The Tiananmen Papers and Li Peng's diary (authenticity debated, as noted).

Contact: endccpworld@proton.me