EndCCPWorld.com

Democracy Wall Movement (1978–1979)

From late 1978, Beijing's Xidan "Democracy Wall" carried big-character posters demanding democracy and human rights. Wei Jingsheng's "The Fifth Modernization" argued democracy was the fifth modernization beyond the Four. In March 1979 Deng Xiaoping crushed it; Wei got 15 years.

Time

November 1978 – December 1979 (peak: Nov 1978 – Mar 1979)

Place

Xidan Democracy Wall, Beijing; also Shanghai, Guangzhou

Decision-makers

Deng Xiaoping (used then crushed); Hu Yaobang (sympathetic); Wei Jingsheng, Xu Wenli, Fu Yuehua (dissidents)

Background: truth-criterion debate

In 1978 Guangming Daily's "Practice is the sole criterion of truth" ignited a debate shaking the "Two Whatevers." That December the 11th Central Committee's Third Plenum shifted focus to economic construction — "reform and opening" began.

The relatively relaxed air let accumulated reflection on the Cultural Revolution and thirst for democracy surface. In November 1978 big-character posters appeared at Beijing's Xidan, denouncing Gang of Four remnants, demanding democracy and human rights — the "Democracy Wall."

Who decided

Deng Xiaoping — first tolerating, then crushing. Tolerance: November–December 1978, Deng told foreign visitors he respected poster rights; January 1979, "set no forbidden zones." Crackdown: March 25, 1979 — Wei Jingsheng's "Democracy or a New Dictatorship?" naming Deng a dictator; March 29 — Beijing banned opposition posters and arrested Wei; March 30 — Deng's "Four Cardinal Principles" speech. The "Document No. 9" (April 8) rolled it out nationwide. November 1979 the Xidan Wall was banned; September 1980 the "four bigs" were abolished.

Who decided

Deng Xiaoping was the supreme decision-maker — first tolerating, then crushing, in two distinct phases.

Tolerance (November 1978–January 1979):

• November 26–27 and early December 1978: Deng told Japanese, American and French visitors he respected the people's right to express grievances through big-character posters.
• January 18, 1979: at the theory-work conference, Zhou Yang conveyed Deng's instruction: "set no forbidden zones, issue no bans."
• Context: Deng needed popular-opinion pressure to defeat Hua Guofeng's "whateverists" and establish the reform line.

Crackdown (March–April 1979):

• March 25, 1979: Wei Jingsheng posted "Democracy or a New Dictatorship?" at Xidan, naming Deng as walking "the road of dictatorship," an "out-and-out dictator" — the turning point.
• March 29: the Beijing Revolutionary Committee banned all posters and publications opposing socialism, the dictatorship of the proletariat, party leadership, or Marxism-Leninism-Mao Zedong Thought; the public security bureau banned rallies and posters; the same day, Wei Jingsheng and Chen Lü were arrested.
• March 30: Deng's "Uphold the Four Cardinal Principles" speech — the socialist road, the dictatorship of the proletariat, party leadership, Marxism-Leninism-Mao Zedong Thought. The arrests and the speech ended the movement.
• April 8: the "Document No. 9" — 7 of 87 spontaneous organizations nationwide were "controlled by a tiny handful of bad elements"; the order: "strike the ringleaders, split and dissolve" — but "do not label them reactionary organizations." (Text unverified.)
• November 1979: the NPC banned the Xidan Wall; September 1980: the "four bigs" (speaking out, airing views, big-character posters, great debates) were abolished.

No public record exists of Deng's internal decision process. Scholars read it as: Deng's tolerance ended where criticism pointed at himself — "first welcome, then crush," mirroring Mao's 1957 handling of the Hundred Flowers.

Detailed timeline: four phases

Rise (Nov–Dec 1978). Posters multiplied; crowds gathered. Deng initially endorsed the Wall as "a good thing," using popular sentiment against the "Whateverists."

Peak (Jan–Feb 1979). On December 5, 1978, Wei Jingsheng posted "The Fifth Modernization." In January 1979 journals like Exploration and April Fifth Forum launched. On January 8, Fu Yuehua's "Chinese Human Rights Alliance" marched for human rights.

Crackdown (March 1979). On March 16 Deng told a central meeting the Wall endangered "stability and unity." Wei was arrested March 29. In April the Wall was abolished, replaced by a designated posting spot in Yuetan Park (a de facto ban).

Prison aftermath (1979–1981). In October 1979 Wei got 15 years for "counterrevolution." In 1981 Xu Wenli, Wang Xizhe and other journal figures were arrested and sentenced. The movement ended.

Wei Jingsheng and "The Fifth Modernization"

Wei Jingsheng (b. 1950), a Beijing Zoo electrician, posted "The Fifth Modernization: Democracy and More" on December 5, 1978: "Without democracy, the Four Modernizations are empty talk." He called Deng Xiaoping a "dictator," demanding democracy and human rights.

The poster shook China and the world. Arrested March 29, 1979, Wei got 15 years for "counterrevolution" on October 16. Released 1993, rearrested 1994, exiled to the US 1997.

Dissident journals

Exploration: Wei's, most radical — democracy, human rights. April Fifth Forum: Xu Wenli's, milder, pro-rule-of-law. Beijing Spring: Wang Juntao et al. Today: Bei Dao and Mang Ke's literary journal, home of Misty Poetry — less political, banned all the same. Voice of the People: Huang Xiang et al.

These were post-reform China's first independent journals; all banned 1980–1981, editors arrested.

Who executed

Chain: Deng → Beijing Public Security Bureau arrests → "Document No. 9" nationwide → courts. Wei Jingsheng: 15 years (1979, incl. the disputed "military intelligence" charge). Liu Qing: ~11 years. Xu Wenli: 15 years (1982). Wang Xizhe: 14 years (served 12).

Who executed

Execution chain: Deng set the line → Beijing Revolutionary Committee/Public Security Bureau made arrests → the Public Security Ministry's "Document No. 9" rolled it out nationwide → courts sentenced.

• Beijing Public Security Bureau: arrested Wei Jingsheng and Chen Lü on March 29; Ren Wanding (China Human Rights League) seized April 4 while posting; hundreds washed posters off city walls in April–May.
• Trials: October 16, 1979 — Wei Jingsheng sentenced to 15 years for "counterrevolution," including the charge of "selling Sino-Vietnamese war military intelligence to foreign journalists" (widely seen as fabricated — noted as disputed). Liu Qing: 3 years' labor reeducation, then +8 years after his prison memoir was smuggled out — ~11 years total. Xu Wenli: arrested April 9, 1981; 15 years in 1982; paroled 1993. Wang Xizhe: arrested 1981, 14 years, served 12.
• Nationwide (after Document No. 9): 10+ Shanghai members arrested; Guiyang's "Thaw Society" all arrested (later released).

Crackdown and imprisonments

Who opposed

The movement itself was the opposition — the first open civilian political opposition after the Cultural Revolution. Wei Jingsheng ("The Fifth Modernization," 15+14 years, exiled 1997). Liu Qing (~11 years). Xu Wenli (15 years, later China Democracy Party, exiled 2002). Wang Xizhe (14 years). 50+ dissident journals in Beijing. Hu Yaobang publicly criticized Wei's arrest in June 1979 (attributed — unverified).

Who opposed

The Democracy Wall's uniqueness: the movement itself was the opposition — the first open civilian political opposition movement after the Cultural Revolution.

• Wei Jingsheng (b. 1950, Beijing Zoo electrician): December 5, 1978 — "The Fifth Modernization: Democracy and Others," signed with his real name and address (then extremely rare); founded Explorations January 1979, naming the movement "Beijing Spring"; March 25 — "Democracy or a New Dictatorship?" directly criticizing Deng. Arrested March 29, 1979; 15 years; released 1993; re-arrested 1994; 14 years in 1995; exiled to the US November 1997.
• Liu Qing: April Fifth Forum editor; arrested for publishing Wei's trial transcript; ~11 years; released December 1989; later chaired Human Rights in China.
• Xu Wenli: April Fifth Forum editor-in-chief; 15 years in 1982; paroled 1993; co-founded the China Democracy Party's Beijing-Tianjin branch 1998; 13 years; exiled December 2002.
• Wang Xizhe: 1974 "Li Yizhe" poster on socialist democracy and legality; 14 years in 1981, served 12.

Dissident journals (winter 1978–spring 1981, 50+ in Beijing): Explorations, April Fifth Forum, China Human Rights League, Today (literary), Beijing Spring, Fertile Soil, plus Tianjin, Wuhan and Qingdao titles.

Party dissent — Hu Yaobang: in June 1979 the then party secretary-general publicly criticized Wei's arrest: "Wei Jingsheng has been held three months; if he dies he becomes a martyr in the people's hearts." (Attributed — unverified.)

Unlike April Fifth's masses who left poems, Democracy Wall's opponents left names, journals and organizational embryos.

Impact

"Reform without political reform" set. The crackdown showed Deng's reform was economic only; political democracy was off the table. The "Four Cardinal Principles" became untouchable red lines.

Harbinger of 1989. The Wall's demands — democracy, human rights, press freedom — resurfaced in 1989. Wei, Xu and others became spiritual forebears of the 1989 movement.

Source of overseas democracy activism. Exiled Wall figures anchored the 1980s–1990s overseas movement.

Archive supplement: the Wall's texts, Wei Jingsheng's trial and the shutdown

The Wall day to day. The Democracy Wall stood on a long grey brick wall at the Xidan crossing in western Beijing, originally the fence of a bus depot and sports ground. From late November 1978, big-character posters spread along it until the wall became something China had not had since 1949: a standing, unlicensed public forum. From early morning until midnight the pavement in front of it was packed. People copied new posters into notebooks character by character; after dark they read by torchlight. Foreign correspondents kept a permanent watch, and a text posted in the morning could be in the world's newspapers by the following day. Contemporaries joked that this stretch of brick was "China's only free news square." Its contents ranged across everything the Cultural Revolution had left unresolved: redress for persecuted families, attacks on cadre privilege and corruption, demands that the April Fifth Movement be rehabilitated, reassessments of Mao Zedong himself — and then, step by step, the systematic conclusion a minority of posters drew from all of it: that the problem was not this or that leader but the absence of democracy.

What "The Fifth Modernization" actually said. On the evening of December 5, 1978, Wei Jingsheng posted the text that made the Wall famous: "The Fifth Modernization: Democracy and More." Its argument was direct. Deng Xiaoping had promised the nation four modernizations — agriculture, industry, national defence, and science and technology. Without a fifth, Wei wrote, political democratization, the other four were unattainable slogans: a modern economy could not be built by command, and a people denied political rights would never hold its rulers to the promises made in its name. Democracy, he insisted, was not a gift bestowed from above but a right that belonged to the people. Then he turned the argument on the leadership itself, warning readers against a "new dictator" and asking whether, having only just thrown off one man who stood above the law, they intended to enthrone another. Crowds gathered in front of the poster for days. Wei followed it with question-and-answer sheets posted beside the original, rebutting his critics point by point — that the people were "not ready" for democracy, that stability came first, that he was serving foreign interests. In March 1979 his unofficial journal, Exploration, published his essay "Democracy or a New Dictatorship?", which aimed the warning openly at Deng Xiaoping by name. It is widely regarded as the immediate trigger for what happened eleven days later.

Arrest and trial. Wei Jingsheng was arrested on March 29, 1979. The charges combined "counterrevolutionary propaganda and agitation" with supplying important military information to foreigners — he had discussed the Sino-Vietnamese war, then in progress, with a foreign journalist, at a time when the war's course was an official secret. On October 16, 1979, the Beijing Intermediate People's Court sentenced him to fifteen years in prison plus three years' deprivation of political rights. Wei defended himself in court and insisted that calling for democracy was no crime. The trial left an archive of its own: a recording of the proceedings was secretly carried out of the courtroom and reached the outside world, and the full text of Wei's defence was published abroad — allowing readers everywhere to follow, word for word, a Beijing zoo electrician's courtroom argument for democracy. He served the sentence in labour camps in Beijing, Tangshan and Qinghai, much of it in solitary confinement; his teeth rotted, his health broke down, and his letters smuggled out of prison — appealing, among other things, on behalf of Tibetan prisoners — kept his name alive in the international human-rights world throughout the 1980s.

The Fu Yuehua case: "human rights" becomes a charge. The Wall's movement was never only about writers. Fu Yuehua was an ordinary Beijing woman worker whose petitions had gone nowhere for years: she had accused a superior at her work unit of assaulting her and been punished for complaining. On January 8, 1979 — the third anniversary of Zhou Enlai's death — she led several thousand petitioners through Beijing to Tiananmen Square under the banner of a body calling itself the Chinese Human Rights Alliance, shouting "We want human rights," "Down with hunger," "Down with persecution." It was the first time since 1949 that the words "human rights" had been raised as a public slogan in the capital's streets. Fu was arrested the following morning, and later that year she was sentenced to two years in prison, nominally for defamation. Journals such as Exploration and April Fifth Forum campaigned for her release, to no effect. Her case mattered then and matters to the record now because it demonstrated the crackdown's true scope: the target was not only intellectuals posting essays, but also the most marginal petitioners in the country, and the alliance's organizer, Ren Wanding, was likewise arrested and imprisoned.

How the shutdown proceeded. The end of the Democracy Wall came in deliberate steps, each one testing how much resistance it would meet. On March 30, 1979, Deng Xiaoping addressed the party's theory conference and laid down the Four Cardinal Principles — the socialist road, the dictatorship of the proletariat, the leadership of the Communist Party, and Marxism-Leninism-Mao Zedong Thought — as boundaries no speech could cross. From April, Beijing's authorities announced that big-character posters might be posted only at a single designated site inside Yuetan Park, and only by people who first registered their real names and work units. Registration turned expression into self-identification, and the Wall emptied within weeks. In December 1979 the Xidan Wall was formally abolished altogether. In 1980 the National People's Congress completed the legal work, deleting from the constitution the clause that had protected "the four bigs" — speaking out freely, airing views fully, holding great debates and writing big-character posters — the very provision under which the Wall had claimed its legality.

1981: the journals' end, and the long afterlife. In 1980 and 1981 the campaign moved from paper to people. Unofficial journals were closed across the country and their editors arrested in sequence: Xu Wenli of April Fifth Forum, seized in April 1981, was sentenced to fifteen years; Wang Xizhe in Guangzhou received fourteen; Qin Yongmin of Wuhan's journal The Bell was jailed in the same sweep. By the spring of 1981 all fifty-plus unofficial journals that had flowered in Beijing since the winter of 1978 were gone, and the Democracy Wall generation was divided among prison, silence and exile. Wei Jingsheng himself was paroled in September 1993, days before the vote on Beijing's Olympic bid; detained again in 1994 after meeting a visiting United States official; and sentenced in 1995 to a further fourteen years for conspiring to subvert the government. In November 1997 he was taken from prison directly to a plane for the United States, released on medical parole into permanent exile. The Wall itself has vanished without a trace: its site is commercial buildings, there is no plaque, no marker, nothing in Beijing's maps or in mainland textbooks to tell a passer-by what stood there. What survives is the texts — the Fifth Modernization above all — and the question the Wall posed in 1978 and the regime answered by force in 1979: whether China's modernization would ever be allowed to include the fifth one.

The China Human Rights Declaration: nineteen articles. The Wall produced a second foundational text, less famous than Wei Jingsheng's essay but in some ways more radical. On New Year's Day 1979 the Chinese Human Rights Alliance posted its Declaration on the Wall, setting out nineteen demands in systematic form: freedom of speech, of the press and of association; the release of all political prisoners; the abolition of cadre privilege; marriage and emigration freedoms; and general elections. It was the first systematic human-rights manifesto issued by a Chinese civic organisation since 1949 — the moment at which the grievances pasted on the Wall stopped being a list of individual wrongs and became a claim of rights as such. The Alliance's moving spirit, Ren Wanding, was a former schoolteacher. He was arrested in April 1979 and served four years; rearrested in connection with the 1989 movement, he served seven more; and after his final release he devoted the remainder of his life, in Beijing and then in exile, to documenting the cases of others. The Declaration was overshadowed in its own season by the Fifth Modernization, and it is barely remembered today, but no history of the idea of human rights in China can omit it: before there were charters and open letters in the internet age, there was a nineteen-article declaration pasted on a brick wall in Xidan.

Beyond Beijing: a national network of walls and journals. Democracy Wall was the capital of a countrywide phenomenon, not a Beijing anomaly. As early as October 1978, the poet Huang Xiang and fellow members of Guizhou's Enlightenment Society travelled to Beijing, posted Huang's long poem "Symphony of the Fire God" in the Wangfujing shopping district, and on New Year's Day 1979 held an open-air poetry reading near Tiananmen — carrying a provincial protest directly onto the capital's streets. Through that winter and spring, poster walls and unofficial journals appeared across China: Shanghai's Bund, Wuhan's The Bell under Qin Yongmin, Tianjin's Bohai Shore, titles in Xi'an, Chengdu, Guangzhou and Qingdao. Their editors wrote to one another, visited, argued and reprinted each other's essays, forming a loose national network held together by nothing more than letters, train tickets and trust. Moves in 1979 to give the network a shared name and programme foundered on differences of background and politics. But when the crackdown came, it came everywhere at once and in sequence — journal by journal, city by city — which is itself evidence that the authorities had always mapped and treated the movement as the single network it was.

The timing of tolerance: recognition, Washington, then arrests. The Wall's brief life coincides almost exactly with the establishment of diplomatic relations between China and the United States, and the coincidence was not accidental. The joint communiqué normalising relations was issued on December 16, 1978; Deng Xiaoping was named Time magazine's Man of the Year for 1978, with Western coverage repeatedly presenting the Wall as the picture of a China opening up; and Deng toured the United States in late January and early February 1979 while posters still covered the wall at Xidan. Within two months of his return, Wei Jingsheng was under arrest and the Four Cardinal Principles had been proclaimed. The standard scholarly reading of this sequence is that tolerating the Wall served a double purpose in the winter of 1978–79: it demonstrated reformist resolve simultaneously to Deng's conservative rivals inside the party and to the American audience whose recognition and investment he was courting — and that once both purposes had been served, and the criticism on the Wall had turned personally upon Deng, the tolerance was withdrawn. This page records the chronology as established fact and the explanation as the prevailing scholarly inference; the two must not be conflated. But laid side by side, they render the boundary between the Wall's tolerated season and its suppression unusually sharp.

Videos